EP12: The Good Guys Should Win in the End

Re: EP12: The Good Guys Should Win in the End

feeds@yuku.com (Heliox) — Fri, 12 Dec 2008 01:12:09 GMT

That label 'good guys' is so subjective. An example was when she voted out Corinne, that she hoped that there were no hard feelings as she gave Corinne her extra food. I think outside of playing the game, Susie is one of the good guys. She hasn't spoken badly of anyone, and she has worked very hard around the camp.

She has not backstabbed anyone openly in the game, with the exception of Marcus.

Re: EP12: The Good Guys Should Win in the End

feeds@yuku.com (Willy2Fun) — Thu, 11 Dec 2008 23:27:46 GMT

I don't see Suzie as 'one of the good guys'. I think she's done nothing but schmooze along and let everyone else do the work (but , she didn't even think that out)...if she is in the final '3' I will feel sick.

Re: EP12: The Good Guys Should Win in the End

feeds@yuku.com (rower) — Thu, 11 Dec 2008 23:22:20 GMT

Wanna change that to Bob, Kenny, Susie?

Re: EP12: The Good Guys Should Win in the End

feeds@yuku.com (KJ4TheWin) — Thu, 11 Dec 2008 20:57:41 GMT

CMSBBall wrote:
yes, Bob makes F3, and tonight Kenny leaves, Bob, Crystal, Susie are F3

CMSBBall wrote:
I live in Portland Maine right outside of the town Bob Teaches I think I would know

Oops!

Re: EP12: The Good Guys Should Win in the End

feeds@yuku.com (birdlady) — Thu, 11 Dec 2008 19:01:27 GMT

Right, but he didn't need to preface the rebuke with that statement, all he needed to do was not go on about it. Or if he had started with the rebuke, to wrap it up with the statement that he was over it, and a handshake or something.

And we didn't need to see him saying it. There was plenty of space for an editing cut.

Re: EP12: The Good Guys Should Win in the End

feeds@yuku.com (Trixiego) — Thu, 11 Dec 2008 18:55:42 GMT

Bob would have been stupid if he didn't say he was over it
Him going on about it would not have helped him at all.

Re: EP12: The Good Guys Should Win in the End

feeds@yuku.com (birdlady) — Thu, 11 Dec 2008 18:52:39 GMT

Bob did preface his rebuke of Sugar with "I'm over it now". Which he didn't have to say. So maybe he really is over it, it's not going to affect his dealings with Sugar going forward. And/or, maybe we the viewers are supposed to be over it now, too. It's not going to prevent Sugar from being "good" (=in the finals).

Re: EP12: The Good Guys Should Win in the End

feeds@yuku.com (Trixiego) — Thu, 11 Dec 2008 18:41:41 GMT

urrout wrote:
Corrine said all of them went up to Bob and told him to give the idol to Randy, not just Sugar so you can't believe anything Corrine said especially when the episode did not back her up. They would have shown us this or at least showed him telling Corrine this the next episode to make Bob look better. Randy already acted up before Bob gave him the idol. Bob was at EI. The others knew nothing about it. He gave...

Re: EP12: The Good Guys Should Win in the End

feeds@yuku.com (urrout) — Thu, 11 Dec 2008 15:59:42 GMT

Corrine said all of them went up to Bob and told him to give the idol to Randy, not just Sugar so you can't believe anything Corrine said especially when the episode did not back her up. They would have shown us this or at least showed him telling Corrine this the next episode to make Bob look better. Randy already acted up before Bob gave him the idol. Bob was at EI. The others knew nothing about it. He gave the idol knowing it was just to embarrass Randy and for a laugh. They also did...

Re: EP12: The Good Guys Should Win in the End

feeds@yuku.com (montanagirl) — Thu, 11 Dec 2008 15:45:15 GMT

Bob should not have scolded them like that when there was no other purpose in giving Randy the fake idol other than to embarrass him and laugh at him and he knew it.

The purpose was twofold:

1) Sugar promised Bob that they wouldn't vote for him if he could get Randy to play the idol. (also confirmed by a Corinne interview, btw)
2) Randy had to think it was real so he could ass it up and draw the votes to him.

It was not to...

Re: EP12: The Good Guys Should Win in the End

feeds@yuku.com (cindidindi76) — Thu, 11 Dec 2008 15:38:06 GMT

CMSBBall wrote:
I live in Portland Maine right outside of the town Bob Teaches I think I would know

Re: EP12: The Good Guys Should Win in the End

feeds@yuku.com (ts2) — Thu, 11 Dec 2008 15:33:20 GMT

Or by the time Corinne and Crystal interacted Crystal's frame of mind was much better.

Re: EP12: The Good Guys Should Win in the End

feeds@yuku.com (crzypunk2004) — Thu, 11 Dec 2008 15:32:00 GMT

Corrine even said that Crystal wasn't even that bad, that she was very soft spoken at camp. I think she just got a bad rap from Randy and Matty as being a bully.

Re: EP12: The Good Guys Should Win in the End

feeds@yuku.com (urrout) — Thu, 11 Dec 2008 15:30:09 GMT

We only saw Matty suggest Bob. No one else said yes Bob goes. It wasn't "they" as in K/C/S/M who used Bob's idol. It was only Sugar and Bob. The others did not know about the plan or why else would she tell the others to expect a bang at TC?. Also someone asked him about it when they got back from TC. They may have gone overboard but Bob should not have scolded them like that when there was no other purpose in giving Randy the fake idol other than to embarrass him and laugh...

Re: EP12: The Good Guys Should Win in the End

feeds@yuku.com (montanagirl) — Thu, 11 Dec 2008 15:17:28 GMT

Yes, SUgar and Bob were the only ones in on the FAKE IDOL part. The original boot plan was for Bob - because Bob was the II threat (and has thus proven that to be true). Sugar was the only one going for Randy - but with Randy's extra bad behavior that day, they were able to get the vote to switch over to Randy. The 'bang' was the hysteria of Randy playing a fake idol. HIlarious. It was not enough for her to get them to vote Randy out, but she had to rub his face in it in the...

Re: EP12: The Good Guys Should Win in the End

feeds@yuku.com (urrout) — Thu, 11 Dec 2008 14:59:54 GMT

Randy was the vote long before Bob gave him the idol. Bob was away at EI when the vote turned if they really ever did consider booting Bob. We really only saw Matty suggesting Bob but saw no one agree to do it. Sugar and Bob were the only ones in on it judging by the clip where Sugar tells the others to expect a bang at tonights TC or something like that. They looked like they didn't know what she was talking about. If Bob were forced into it they would have shown it to keep his...

Re: EP12: The Good Guys Should Win in the End

feeds@yuku.com (Heliox) — Thu, 11 Dec 2008 14:58:52 GMT

Corinne quote:

Did you know at the time that Sugar had an idol?

I knew that she got the idol. She spent like an eternity on exile. But I was told, and I believed, by Sugar and Matty when they were on Fang, that Kellie went home because Sugar played the idol. That made sense to me because Kellie was more athletic and no one liked Sugar. She was very annoying to have...

Re: EP12: The Good Guys Should Win in the End

feeds@yuku.com (montanagirl) — Thu, 11 Dec 2008 14:50:36 GMT

urrout wrote:

James Barber wrote:

Why Bob? After the last 2 shows, why is he considered to still be on the "good" list? Just curious. Come on, what was the purpose of the fake idol
if they were not going to have fun with it - meaning laughing at Randy? Sugar and Matty and possible Susie are...

Re: EP12: The Good Guys Should Win in the End

feeds@yuku.com (The Very Insane Shark) — Thu, 11 Dec 2008 14:38:23 GMT

I live in Portland Maine right outside of the town Bob Teaches I think I would know

Wow! What an fucking awesome source! That totally, 100% proves that Bob makes the F3 along with Crystal and Susie, and Kenny gets voted off tonight. Thank you so much!!!

douchebag

Re: EP12: The Good Guys Should Win in the End

feeds@yuku.com (CMSBBall) — Thu, 11 Dec 2008 14:30:03 GMT

nope, Bob can't and hasn't said anything, just us Mainers like to spread rumours about who we want to win haha, :-p I read in the paper that Bob is a Celeb at school now but he cant say anything till hes voted off or wins

EP12: The Good Guys Should Win in the End

feeds@yuku.com (anywho) — Thu, 04 Dec 2008 23:11:09 GMT

Thursday
December 11

Survivor:...