Would Stephen have won against Erin?

Re: Would Stephen have won against Erin?

feeds@yuku.com (Kirblar) — Tue, 19 May 2009 00:36:01 GMT

Erinn would have come down her FTC performance, but she had one hell of an argument to make, and I think this is a scenario where we'll really never know the answer.

Re: Would Stephen have won against Erin?

feeds@yuku.com (EPR2012) — Tue, 19 May 2009 00:22:54 GMT

Survivor Boy wrote:
Sad that even Katie got a vote.

But then again, she wasn't a jew.

Tom wasnt as charming as JT...

Re: Would Stephen have won against Erin?

feeds@yuku.com (jenni007) — Tue, 19 May 2009 00:20:32 GMT

It would've been close.Stephen,for all of his education,did not argue a good case for himself and when he did speak.....he came off as not owning up to his role in the game.Maybe he would've been more comfortable if he did go against Erinn.On the other hand,this is the same guy who looked as if he was gonna pass out when he got a vote earlier.

Re: Would Stephen have won against Erin?

feeds@yuku.com (shoeless rye) — Mon, 18 May 2009 18:04:44 GMT

I wasn't an Erinn fan all season, however I found myself hoping she'd get to the jury. I wanted to see Jalapao eat their own, it would have sort of been poetic to see Timbira get decimated by the smaller Jalapao and then the remaining Timbira beat the 3 vs 1 odds to win the game.

I think there is a chance Erinn could have won with that argument. She played the odds, figuring fourth was better than 6th to explain her switch to Jalapao 3, and then weaseled her way into the F2...

Re: Would Stephen have won against Erin?

feeds@yuku.com (Survivor Boy) — Mon, 18 May 2009 17:28:21 GMT

Sad that even Katie got a vote.

But then again, she wasn't a jew.

Re: Would Stephen have won against Erin?

feeds@yuku.com (Screerider) — Mon, 18 May 2009 16:43:36 GMT

My working theory going into the Final Immunity Challenge was:

Erinn wins IC -> Stephen wins Survivor
Stephen wins IC -> Erinn wins Survivor
JT wins IC -> JT wins Survivor

Re: Would Stephen have won against Erin?

feeds@yuku.com (JLK Name) — Mon, 18 May 2009 15:27:17 GMT

S15- Amanda
S17- Sugar
S18- Stephen

= All Stars 2.0 (except Amanda bcos of FvF)

Re: Would Stephen have won against Erin?

feeds@yuku.com (WTFscissoring8) — Mon, 18 May 2009 15:15:22 GMT

GrenadeJumper85 wrote:

Vicarious wrote:
After that final tribal council question and answer performance, i wonder if he could have beat Amanda?

...

Re: Would Stephen have won against Erin?

feeds@yuku.com (JLK Name) — Mon, 18 May 2009 15:12:01 GMT

I don't think Tyson and brendan would vote for Erinn because Stephen was the reason why they are gone - I don't think they would base their vote because of their bitterness.

Re: Would Stephen have won against Erin?

feeds@yuku.com (Boo Radley 2001) — Mon, 18 May 2009 14:31:46 GMT

JLK Name wrote:
JT: Stephen
Taj: Erinn
Coach: Stephen
Debbie: Erinn
Sierra: Erinn
Tyson: Stephen
Brendan: Stephen

Both Brendan and Tyson had alliances with Stephen which he broke immediately. I don't see why either of them would vote for him over Erinn. Coach was such a chauvenist that he would still vote for Stephen. I...

Re: Would Stephen have won against Erin?

feeds@yuku.com (pinkdolphin) — Mon, 18 May 2009 13:58:31 GMT

Buzzkill wrote:
I think once Stephen got rid of Taj at #4 he gave up any chance to win. His best shot was against Taj if he had remained loyal to her to the F2.

And no way would he have won against Taj. She was another jury favorite. He was pretty much destined to be #2.

Re: Would Stephen have won against Erin?

feeds@yuku.com (Thailandsurvivor) — Mon, 18 May 2009 13:57:55 GMT

No.

Thailandsurvivor wrote:

If it was a Stephen/Erinn final 2, Stephen would've been the JT replacement. In other words, 7-0 victory.

6-1. With Taj voting for Erinn. I do think Erinn had a chance to get votes from Debbie, Sierra, and JT (if Stephen won the final challenge), but looking back, Stephen would have been able to state his case much better if he...

Re: Would Stephen have won against Erin?

feeds@yuku.com (GrenadeJumper85) — Mon, 18 May 2009 13:33:17 GMT

Vicarious wrote:
After that final tribal council question and answer performance, i wonder if he could have beat Amanda?

So true. Maybe they both...

Re: Would Stephen have won against Erin?

feeds@yuku.com (Gregoire) — Mon, 18 May 2009 13:21:42 GMT

The only person Stephen was equipt to beat after that sorry TC performance was LIL.

Re: Would Stephen have won against Erin?

feeds@yuku.com (Buzzkill) — Mon, 18 May 2009 13:05:36 GMT

I think once Stephen got rid of Taj at #4 he gave up any chance to win. His best shot was against Taj if he had remained loyal to her to the F2.

Re: Would Stephen have won against Erin?

feeds@yuku.com (JLK Name) — Mon, 18 May 2009 12:27:37 GMT

JT: Stephen
Taj: Erinn
Coach: Stephen
Debbie: Erinn
Sierra: Erinn
Tyson: Stephen
Brendan: Stephen

Re: Would Stephen have won against Erin?

feeds@yuku.com (MikeHaggarKJ) — Mon, 18 May 2009 12:26:29 GMT

dcsurvivor wrote:

and he just acted like he was far more superior than the others......

when did that happen?

Re: Would Stephen have won against Erin?

feeds@yuku.com (Torchflame) — Mon, 18 May 2009 12:23:06 GMT

Vicarious wrote:
After that final tribal council question and answer performance, i wonder if he could have beat Amanda?

Re: Would Stephen have won against Erin?

feeds@yuku.com (Vicarious) — Mon, 18 May 2009 12:20:35 GMT

After that final tribal council question and answer performance, i wonder if he could have beat Amanda?

Re: Would Stephen have won against Erin?

feeds@yuku.com (Katy Carney) — Mon, 18 May 2009 12:16:34 GMT

I think Erinn would've had a decent shot. She had a much tougher road to the finals than anyone else did. She had to make exactly the right moves and she did. No one was fighting for Erinn except her.

Would Stephen have won against Erin?

feeds@yuku.com (StarRider) — Mon, 18 May 2009 11:47:50 GMT

That fukker Probst never asked this at the reunion.

Besides being curious, i always like a good show of hands. It keeps these morons from speaking.