Top Five Best Survivor Players to Not Win

Re: Top Five Best Survivor Players to Not Win

feeds@yuku.com (ilovekelly752) — Tue, 08 Dec 2009 14:55:41 GMT

JPOz wrote:

ilovekelly752 wrote:

XtremeInnovator420 wrote:
Stephenie was in Rafe's back pocket. She blew her own game in Guatemala so many times it's not funny. She messed up by....voting out Jamie, voting out Judd, not giving Lydia money to see her brother, lying to...

Re: Top Five Best Survivor Players to Not Win

feeds@yuku.com (ilovekelly752) — Tue, 08 Dec 2009 14:52:14 GMT

leroybrown wrote:

ilovekelly752 wrote:

1. Cirie Fields- She was able to work herelf into groups beautifully, was able to know exactly what was going on, and knew who to get rid of at all the right times. Assuming the Micronesia final tribal council would have three people, she played the perfect game. It was incredible to watch. she just had to be...

Re: Top Five Best Survivor Players to Not Win

feeds@yuku.com (ilovekelly752) — Tue, 08 Dec 2009 14:51:07 GMT

Huntorr wrote:
Not one person has said Rafe. That's interesting, he did get 3rd.

I had a tough time choosing between him and Stephen for number 5.

Re: Top Five Best Survivor Players to Not Win

feeds@yuku.com (toomanynachos16) — Tue, 08 Dec 2009 13:39:12 GMT

1. Cirie Fields
2. Jonny Fairplay
3. Rob C
4. Kathy Vavrick O' Brien
5. Tracy Hughes-Wolf undying <3

Re: Top Five Best Survivor Players to Not Win

feeds@yuku.com (Huntorr) — Tue, 08 Dec 2009 11:14:05 GMT

Not one person has said Rafe. That's interesting, he did get 3rd.

Re: Top Five Best Survivor Players to Not Win

feeds@yuku.com (Maximus20) — Tue, 08 Dec 2009 10:42:41 GMT

1-Rob M-He master minded All-stars. Its shameful that he didnt win all-stars and is the stand out reason why bitter jury's suck ass.

2-Cirie-Made it so close the finals twice and got screwed both times, despite the fact she played great both times.

3-Amanada-She made f2 twice and lost....she sucks at jury speeches but generally her game is good

4-Rob C-He owned Amazon but got cut at the end. He totally deserved it

5-Colby-Honestly he should have won...

Re: Top Five Best Survivor Players to Not Win

feeds@yuku.com (roxbury123) — Tue, 08 Dec 2009 10:29:58 GMT

I would have to say Steph, Cirie, B Rob, Rob C, and Kelly W.

I think alot of people have dominated a season and lost, not just Boston Rob, Steph is another example.

I say with confidence Russell will NEVER be on this list for me. He has made too many mistakes, and considering people say Rich was playing with "sheep", everyone in a current season is playing with "mentally retarded sheep".

Re: Top Five Best Survivor Players to Not Win

feeds@yuku.com (Huntorr) — Tue, 08 Dec 2009 10:19:59 GMT

JPOz wrote:

Creating an alliance is a lot easier when you know the other participants and can make plans beforehand.

Good point. If none of them knew each other, Rob C. wouldn't have been an easy first boot.

Re: Top Five Best Survivor Players to Not Win

feeds@yuku.com (JPOz) — Tue, 08 Dec 2009 10:11:07 GMT

Huntorr wrote:
Did anyone else dominate the entire game as much as Rob M. in ASS and not win?

Creating an alliance is a lot easier when a large number share a common goal.

Creating an alliance is a lot easier when you know the other participants and can make plans beforehand.

It's possible nobody dominated quite the way he did but everyone else played under much different circumstances.

Re: Top Five Best Survivor Players to Not Win

feeds@yuku.com (Huntorr) — Tue, 08 Dec 2009 09:47:48 GMT

Did anyone else dominate the entire game as much as Rob M. in ASS and not win?

Re: Top Five Best Survivor Players to Not Win

feeds@yuku.com (leroybrown) — Tue, 08 Dec 2009 08:46:12 GMT

ilovekelly752 wrote:

1. Cirie Fields- She was able to work herelf into groups beautifully, was able to know exactly what was going on, and knew who to get rid of at all the right times. Assuming the Micronesia final tribal council would have three people, she played the perfect game. It was incredible to watch. she just had to be ready for any twists. I can't really say anything else other than that she is number one...

Re: Top Five Best Survivor Players to Not Win

feeds@yuku.com (Lexxan) — Tue, 08 Dec 2009 04:59:25 GMT

XtremeInnovator420 wrote:
Stephenie was in Rafe's back pocket. She blew her own game in Guatemala so many times it's not funny. She messed up by....voting out Jamie, voting out Judd, not giving Lydia money to see her brother, lying to Judd's wife, voting out Cindy, letting Rafe let her keep Danni around, having a horrible jury performance, being stuck up, etc. Yeah, I'd say voting out every loyal ally and person...

Re: Top Five Best Survivor Players to Not Win

feeds@yuku.com (JLK Name) — Tue, 08 Dec 2009 02:45:46 GMT

Top Five Best Survivor Players to Not Win
1. Stephenie
2. Stephen
3. Amanda
4. Kathy if only she had won that last IC in S4
5. Cirie

Re: Top Five Best Survivor Players to Not Win

feeds@yuku.com (JPOz) — Tue, 08 Dec 2009 02:10:53 GMT

ilovekelly752 wrote:

XtremeInnovator420 wrote:
Stephenie was in Rafe's back pocket. She blew her own game in Guatemala so many times it's not funny. She messed up by....voting out Jamie, voting out Judd, not giving Lydia money to see her brother, lying to Judd's wife, voting out Cindy, letting Rafe let her keep Danni around, having a horrible...

Re: Top Five Best Survivor Players to Not Win

feeds@yuku.com (ilovekelly752) — Mon, 07 Dec 2009 22:34:52 GMT

XtremeInnovator420 wrote:
Stephenie was in Rafe's back pocket. She blew her own game in Guatemala so many times it's not funny. She messed up by....voting out Jamie, voting out Judd, not giving Lydia money to see her brother, lying to Judd's wife, voting out Cindy, letting Rafe let her keep Danni around, having a horrible jury performance, being stuck up, etc. Yeah, I'd say voting out every loyal ally and person...

Re: Top Five Best Survivor Players to Not Win

feeds@yuku.com (XtremeInnovator420) — Mon, 07 Dec 2009 22:28:39 GMT

Stephenie was in Rafe's back pocket. She blew her own game in Guatemala so many times it's not funny. She messed up by....voting out Jamie, voting out Judd, not giving Lydia money to see her brother, lying to Judd's wife, voting out Cindy, letting Rafe let her keep Danni around, having a horrible jury performance, being stuck up, etc. Yeah, I'd say voting out every loyal ally and person she could beat in front of the jury means she played a REALLY good game...

Re: Top Five Best Survivor Players to Not Win

feeds@yuku.com (ilovekelly752) — Mon, 07 Dec 2009 22:18:54 GMT

Dr Will Hatch two point oh wrote:

survivorisdabest wrote:
And just cause we're watching edited footage it doesnt mean we cant get a good idea of who the best player is.

I don't agree. The editing can have us believe almost anything it wants us too. They can't actually decieve us by showing false footage(Or perhaps they can?),...

Re: Top Five Best Survivor Players to Not Win

feeds@yuku.com (ilovekelly752) — Mon, 07 Dec 2009 22:13:05 GMT

5. Stephen Fishbach- He was able to align with the perfect people, one weaker than himself, and one being the unofficial leader of the tribe, who had control over the outcome of the tribal councils. He also had a big part in turning the whole game around, more so than Russell is this season. He probably would've won if JT didn't win that final immunity challenge.

4. Stephenie Lagrossa- I'm putting her on this list for her game in Guatemala, not Palau. She played one of...

Re: Top Five Best Survivor Players to Not Win

feeds@yuku.com (brittanyess) — Mon, 07 Dec 2009 17:09:50 GMT

Duh.

1. Cirie (S16..why the hell couldn't there have been a final three?)
2. Cirie (S12)
3. Rob C.
4. Kathy VO
5. Rob M. (Even though I hated him)

Re: Top Five Best Survivor Players to Not Win

feeds@yuku.com (gravenwraith) — Thu, 08 Oct 2009 11:13:37 GMT

1. Cirie
2. Kenny
3. Amanda
4. PG
5. Kathy (Marqueses)

Top Five Best Survivor Players to Not Win

feeds@yuku.com (MghtyMouse33) — Mon, 08 Jun 2009 15:07:41 GMT

5. Yau Man Chan--Sure, he may have screwed up royally in the end by putting his faith in Dreamz, but he proved to be one of the most underestimated Survivors in the game, time and time again beating the strongest guys in challenges and in overall gameplay. And had Dreamz lived up to his deal and taken Yau Man to the final three, it would have been one of the best plays (and example of foresight) in the game.

4. Kathy Vavrick-O'Brien--Started out extremely rough, but she wound up...