Live Feed Discussion Thread March 26 to April 2, Bye Bye Joshuah

0 Kudo

Started By	Comment
NinaWeena		#5461	[-]
Posts: 1396 (03/30/08 5:38 PM) Registered User More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Joshie's epiphany brought to you by the DR. ;)
sandiegoboy16		#5462	[-]
Posts: 29 (03/30/08 5:38 PM) More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	YES!! Shiela is in the top 6!! Im so excited
highwind44029		#5463	[-]
Posts: 22464 (03/30/08 5:39 PM) More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Josh has not been to the DR at all though...
The Marquesan Godfather		#5464	[-]
Posts: 10535 (03/30/08 5:39 PM) Registered User More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	The only way Team Christ agree to keep him is if they got conformation on his nomination next week. If he gets a extra vote this week... it just makes it impossible for a tie vote, which would be great for Natalie.
RomCen		#5465	[-]
Posts: 10894 (03/30/08 5:39 PM) Registered User More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	DeadTwista wrote: Ryan to Nat "How fucked up is it that I wasnt even part of the sexy six." ... not that surprising MBP Hahahahahahahahahaha! OW! I think I hurt something.
omzig		#5466	[-]
Posts: 3686 (03/30/08 5:40 PM) Registered user More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	RomCen wrote: Hmm...I know they gave Jen a penalty vote, but that wasn't in the rule book then either, was it? Production's interpetation of this rule might vary. At least, I hope so. Depends on how Grodner wants to play it. I think you're right, Rom. AG pulled that rule out of her arse because she felt the penalty nom was unfair to Jameka because ED and Zach were seriously contemplating keeping Jen.
blmetsfan		#5467	[-]
Posts: 1469 (03/30/08 5:40 PM) Registered user More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	DeadTwista wrote: Ryan to Nat "How fucked up is it that I wasnt even part of the sexy six." ... not that surprising MBP
SimplyKimberly		#5468	[-]
Posts: 2853 (03/30/08 5:40 PM) More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	highwind44029 wrote: Josh has not been to the DR at all though... I heard him say he has.
Jarvy		#5469	[-]
Posts: 3464 (03/30/08 5:40 PM) Registered user More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I do find it interesting though, that just this morning, Natalie told Josh that in a tie, she would vote to keep him in the game. Now she says that she will definitely vote to keep him in (if need be) if he does this. Hmmmm....which is it Natalie? Obviously now Josh MUST know that he was lied to by Natalie earlier...(if he didn't already realize this)
LOLABINGO		#5470	[-]
Posts: 1407 (03/30/08 5:41 PM) More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	highwind44029 wrote: Josh has not been to the DR at all though... highwind,when he started the conversation with Nat he said he was just in DR crying his eyes out.
DeadTwista		#5471	[-]
Posts: 1116 (03/30/08 5:41 PM) More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	From what I remember about last year all the houseguests had a meeting with BB and complained that the penalty would in fact help Jen so it wasnt right. BB agreed and gave a penalty vote. I guess like you say it all comes down to how much BB wants Josh to stay in the house. Him staying would be much more entertaining .
quietsurvivorfan		#5472	[-]
Posts: 14335 (03/30/08 5:43 PM) Registered user More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	My understanding of a penalty nomination is that it is in ADDITION to the HOH nominations. So James could still put up 2 players. The remaining 2 players would vote and they would have to decide to remove Josh anyway and spare whatever 2 people that were not on the block. So that would render James just an additional week in the house, and the FOUR would be intact against James for the Final 5 HOH, with James sitting out. This would be an interesting play out in this game. It could cause for some feed drama as the FOUR melt down because they are pissed about circumventing the game in a loop hole. However, they would have to decide if the risk/reward is worth it. Frankly I am not sure any of them are smart enough to figure this out AND if I was in the game, I would want to see it in WRITING from the DR that this is how it would play out. Then they could plan, as a group, to throw the HOH to James, get Josh out next week, and then James can't play for HOH and they take him out the following week IF he doesn't win the veto. This would require a lot of trust, but hey, you have to admit, it adds a very unique strategic element to the game.
LOLABINGO		#5473	[-]
Posts: 1408 (03/30/08 5:43 PM) More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Nat didn't tell Sheila and Adam either!
Battlekid		#5474	[-]
Posts: 83 (03/30/08 5:44 PM) More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	DeadTwista wrote: From what I remember about last year all the houseguests had a meeting with BB and complained that the penalty would in fact help Jen so it wasnt right. BB agreed and gave a penalty vote. I guess like you say it all comes down to how much BB wants Josh to stay in the house. Him staying would be much more entertaining . Ummmm, what??? Next to Dick, Jen was the most entertaining person in that house. Didn't help her.
Maplestyle		#5475	[-]
Posts: 12 (03/30/08 5:44 PM) More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I could be wrong, but I thought that Jen's penalty vote was due to the fact that after she was told to stop eating while on slop she continued to eat. If she had stopped when they told her to then it would have only been a penalty nom.
jackbauer1982		#5476	[-]
Posts: 253 (03/30/08 5:45 PM) Registered user More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	You know this would still work for Josh if they penalized him both ways. If they gave him a penalty vote and told him he would be nommed next week without playing in the HOH and POV if he survived, it would be a great selling point to both Ryan and Adam and Natalie wouldn't matter anymore. With the penalty vote and Sheila's vote going for Sharon to stay, he could still survive with Ryan, Adam and James voting for him to stay and I believe Adam and Ryan would have to do the logical thing and vote Sharon out and guarantee themselves F5.
ShereeLuvsSambuca		#5477	[-]
Posts: 361 (03/30/08 5:45 PM) More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	quietsurvivorfan wrote: My understanding of a penalty nomination is that it is in ADDITION to the HOH nominations. So James could still put up 2 players. The remaining 2 players would vote and they would have to decide to remove Josh anyway and spare whatever 2 people that were not on the block. So that would render James just an additional week in the house, and the FOUR would be intact against James for the Final 5 HOH, with James sitting out. This would be an interesting play out in this game. It could cause for some feed drama as the FOUR melt down because they are pissed about circumventing the game in a loop hole. However, they would have to decide if the risk/reward is worth it. Frankly I am not sure any of them are smart enough to figure this out AND if I was in the game, I would want to see it in WRITING from the DR that this is how it would play out. Then they could plan, as a group, to throw the HOH to James, get Josh out next week, and then James can't play for HOH and they take him out the following week IF he doesn't win the veto. This would require a lot of trust, but hey, you have to admit, it adds a very unique strategic element to the game. NONE of them are smart enough to figure that out. Well, maybe Joshie - but he would not share it with them.
SimplyKimberly		#5478	[-]
Posts: 2854 (03/30/08 5:46 PM) More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	If the DR wants Josh to stay (and I think they really do) then they will work the rules to say anything they want them to mean. DR won't let Josh cut his hair. That ought to tell you something right there. And Josh is far more entertaining than Woobie Girl.
omzig		#5479	[-]
Posts: 3687 (03/30/08 5:47 PM) Registered user More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	So when is this eating of the hamburger taking place?
Funkey 01		#5480	[-]
Posts: 945 (03/30/08 5:47 PM) More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	After Nat says she's going to marinate/cook some fish for dinner, Josh says, jokingly, I'm going to lick the pan when you're done. Ryan, seriously, responds "Can we lick pans on slop?" Damn this slop's killing MBP.

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

Live Feed Discussion Thread March 26 to April 2, Bye Bye Joshuah