Yuku free message boards

The Dorff article is certifiably stupid in a number of ways: 1) Saying Carly is the "most likely" to be booted next is dubious. She certainly could be, but more sucksters would probably pick KKKristy or Syesha. 2) Calling Carly "tiny" is laughable. 3) The album, which I reviewed here, certainly IS pop but so what? It doesn't mean that as an adult singer 7 years later she can't or shouldn't do rock. The songs were picked by the would-be starmakers at MCA, probably with minimal input from Carly. Dorff knows this as well as anybody. 4) Yes, the album flopped. Dorff implies it's Carly's fault. As some of you have already pointed out, Dorff is assuming we haven't actually heard the album and that it must be terrible. It ISN'T terrible and Carly's voice isn't the main problem. I thought its biggest flaw was in the producers' lack of empathy with or confidence in her voice. They tried to get her to be another Britney, which she isn't.