How will you feel if Amanda wins??? in Survivor Sucks Forum

0 Points

How will you feel if Amanda wins???

Started By	Comment
Yeaster		#61	[-]
Posts: 5138 (05/03/08 06:55 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	I'd have a photographic memory but it was never developed. Remove this ad Cirie deserves it the most, I think. Amanda, like, JUST playing. If she won...I don't know, I would be totally indifferent. I just don't find her interesting at all. Same goes for Erik. I'd root for Parvati or Natalie before those two.
mtj1282		#62	[-]
Posts: 1079 (05/03/08 07:26 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	what i really want to know is if alexis or nat used amanda getting to the final three last time as reason to want to get rid of her. everyone out there knows she already made it to the end last season so i dont know why they wouldnt feel threatened by that?!?!
Ozzmanda Fan234		#63	[-]
Posts: 169 (05/03/08 07:39 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	1. Will you feel it's deserved?? Yes!!! Amanda is a great player and she would definetly deserve it. 2. Will you still consider this to be a great season?? One of the best seasons ever 3. Will it make this season worth it? Of course. 4. Will it be the perfect story book ending?? A happily ever after ending. Win the milion and will probably get engaged to Ozzy 5. Will you be pissed? Nope 6. Will it make the season just mediocre? Nope as well.
hippo2002		#64	[-]
Posts: 829 (05/03/08 07:46 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	If Amanda wins,then Micronesia is the best season ever!
angstygoldfish		#65	[-]
Posts: 1297 (05/03/08 08:01 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	How could this even be a valid question now?
dayzdnconfuzd		#66	[-]
Posts: 920 (05/03/08 08:20 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	riskysurv wrote: At this point of time, I wouldn't mind anyone of them winning except for Erik. Erik is possibly the worst player out of the final 10. He has done no powerplay thus far and has no clue whatsoever that Alexis and Natalie would have chopped him up if he didn't win immunity. Amanda, Parv, Cirie and Natalie all deserve to win more than him. I agree, erik does not deserve to win. He's a follower. I got sick of his "i'm not worthy!" schtick with ozzy long ago. Natalie played the game. She annoyed the fuck out me and she was obnoxious as hell in her diary rooms, but she made some big moves. Cirie - I know she's a favorite, but I'd rather see someone else win. Amanda - I don't like her, but she managed to blindside everyone and she used the idol the way it was intended. I respect that. But, I think her motives in voting out alexis were based on jealousy (her interactions with ozzy), which I think was a stupid move. She should have voted out Natalie, the one that was a threat in challenges. Why vote out the gimpy that will have difficulty in physical challenges? And now, she's in sequestor with your boyfriend. dumb move, amanda. But I still have to give her credit, after ozzy was voted out, her alliance crumbled. James is gone, parv plays both sides.... If amanda makes it to the end after losing her alliance, I have to give her credit for that. Parvati - I didn't like her either, but she started to grow on me. She played the game. She didn't prop up a showmance with james as more important than the prize. She betrayed her alliance in order to remove a huge threat. That was a good move, IMO. She may have lost ozzy's vote, but I think James and amanda would respect her move in the end.
hippo2002		#67	[-]
Posts: 835 (05/03/08 09:52 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Amanda did want to vote out Natalie,but Parvaty wanted to voted out Alexis because she thought Alexis was a threat in F3
kennethp21		#68	[-]
Posts: 2916 (05/03/08 10:23 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	hippo2002 wrote: Amanda did want to vote out Natalie,but Parvaty wanted to voted out Alexis because she thought Alexis was a threat in F3 hence, amanda < parv
Relynn		#69	[-]
Posts: 430 (05/03/08 10:50 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	DGVision1 wrote: Here is the difference as I see it - Cirie played a defensive game. In her own words, "I don't care which one goes home as long as I stay." Her consistent theme, though it may be only an edited version of her actual game, seems a little one dimensional. Amanda play a coattails game until Oz left. While she admittedly gave one of the best acting performances in Survivor history, is she a one hit wonder? From a jury perspective, she owned Cirie, Eric, Natalie and Alexis. Would any among them be that impressed? Possibly. But would even Oz see her as a multi-dimensional game player? I don't know. Parvati was on offense from day one first with her relationship with James, then with the end of Oz, and finally telling the remaining "fans" who could have turned on her that she would be loyal to Amanda. At each turn she risked offending jurrors (While Cirie most just offended serious viewers). In my opinion, when you take risks in the game and survive, you truly do outwit, outlast and outplay. I will be fun being in the audience for the first time since 05 to see how it goes down. (ps.. I used to post years ago under another screen name but have not memory of the name/password combo. Too many dead brain cells apparentl y...) There are different ways of playing the game. One could argue that it is a risk not to make millions of alliances with millions of people. But that risk pays off when you get to the jury. Survivor is all about deciding what risks/to take what risks not to take. Still Amanda does take risks in the game, she took out James last Season..But she also insisted that they take out James at 7 when the fans numbers had dwindled. I suspect that Amanda might have wanted to take out Ozzy/James, but she probably wanted to wait until a few more fans were gone. If the fans hadn' been so completely stupid, they could have taken control of the game. In challenges, Ozzy was clearly not as strong as he was in Cook Islands. Still honestly, according to James, Amanda/Parvati were running the show in their alliance, and I'm not sure how anyone can say that Ozzy is a better strategic partner than Amanda. Amanda is much more aware of what's going on and much more game smart than Ozzy ever was. hence, amanda < parv Why we already knew from editing that Amanda didn't want to face Alexis in the Final 3.
riverheightsnancy		#70	[-]
Posts: 113 (05/03/08 11:30 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	I'd have a photographic memory but it was never developed. Remove this ad I only want Cirie to win, with Parvati 2nd. Cirie has been outspoken about most of the boots ALL season long, unlike Amanda. Amanda was too busy making little Ozzlettes to give a shit about the game. Amanda thought they she could coast to a final 4 with her showmance alliance. For myself, finally giving a shit and playing the odds by playing the HII at final 5, is a little too little too late. I liked Amanda during China and really thought that she was the mastermind of Todd, but her implosion killed it for me. I cannot stand her bottom lip out with the big sad look and doe eyes. If she wins I will be LIVID. Furthermore, the lividAmanda thread needs her to lose so that it can continue on in livid glory.
platinumtlc		#71	[-]
Posts: 2434 (05/03/08 11:36 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Amanda JUST started playing, AKA NELEH. Cirie and Parvati have been playing since the very beginning. THe way I see it, Amanda is no different than Catalie in terms of when they actually started playing the game.
Relynn		#72	[-]
Posts: 438 (05/03/08 11:47 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	platinumtlc wrote: Amanda JUST started playing, AKA NELEH. Cirie and Parvati have been playing since the very beginning. THe way I see it, Amanda is no different than Catalie in terms of when they actually started playing the game. What are you talking about.. We saw Amanda on the boat with Cirie/Pavarti discussing their Final 3 alliance in Episode what was it FOUR. In fact, they panned to Amanda I believe when Cirie talked about how people should be offering her stuff. We saw Amanda discuss with others lots of different boots. Including Yauman, Joel, Chet, Ami, etc) It's not the case that Amanda has not been playing this game. There was even a line where Amanda tells Cirie, just let Ozzy think he's in charge right now. And we were also shown Amanda basically predicting people would flip. Has Amanda's game been as flashy as Parvati/Cirie's. No becasue she hasn't betrayed anyone, but to say that she hasn't been playing since day one, isn't fair. How is making the Final 3 deal with Cirie/Parvati, Not Playing the Game?
platinumtlc		#73	[-]
Posts: 2437 (05/03/08 11:48 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	I don't think making a deal to be F3 is 'playing the game'. I think playing the game is making power plays and strategic votes and being IN power.
Relynn		#74	[-]
Posts: 439 (05/03/08 11:53 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	platinumtlc wrote: I don't think making a deal to be F3 is 'playing the game'. I think playing the game is making power plays and strategic votes and being IN power. Whatever..There are different ways to play the game. Todd/Amanda in China wanted Aaron to think that he was the leader of the tribe (Todd even agreed to boot off Leslie with this aim) They wanted to do this so that some of the heat would be taken off them, and when the time was right they planned to backstabb Aaron, before he oculd reach the Final 3. There are different ways to play this game. And sometimes smart players know there are times to follow, as well as times to lead. (If Parvarti/Cirie wanted to do Amanda's dirty work for her by getting rid of Ozzy, well good for them) Smart players though, know when to follow and when also to take the lead. Plus, since Parvarti/Cirie did Amanda's dirty work by getting rid of Ozzy, it's not so stupid know for Amanda to just continue not making promises and continue to make sure she gets to the end. If she can convince Cirie/Parvarti to keep her around, inspite of the fact that she's pissed off a lot less jury members, that's Cirie/Parvarti's mistake.
Bobby Jon goes apeshit		#75	[-]
Posts: 1200 (05/03/08 11:55 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Meh...anyone but Erik.
platinumtlc		#76	[-]
Posts: 2440 (05/03/08 11:56 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Meh... anyone but Manhanda.
ProbstFan123		#77	[-]
Posts: 10045 (05/03/08 12:10 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	^ Agreed.
AnomyBC		#78	[-]
Posts: 4678 (05/03/08 12:25 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Will you feel it's deserved? I think Amanda would be a deserving winner, but Parvati and Cirie would be more deserving. Will you still consider this to be a great season? Yes. Will it make this season worth it? This season is already "worth it". It has been since "It's just a stick!" Will it be the perfect story book ending? No. Will you be pissed? I might be a little bit LIVID that Parvati or Cirie didn't win, but I love Amanda too (and Catalie as well.) Will it make the season just mediocre? No. It would still be an awesome season.
LaurenTheLush		#79	[-]
Posts: 1045 (05/03/08 12:33 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Will you feel it's deserved? Not really. While I loved the wonderful acting job she did with the HII, it doesn't make up for her coattailing the previous 30 days. Will you still consider this to be a great season? Most definitely, I loved this season. Will it make this season worth it? This season was amazing regardless of who wins. Will it be the perfect story book ending? Negative. Will you be pissed? No, Amanda isn't undeserving, I just don't think she is the most deserving. Will it make the season just mediocre? No. It would still be an awesome season.
Relynn		#80	[-]
Posts: 441 (05/03/08 12:48 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	I'd have a photographic memory but it was never developed. Remove this ad See my thinking is kind of this if Cirie and Parvarti (Perhaps this game's versions of Stephanie and Rafe) let Amanda (Danni) into the finals then maybe you deserve to lose. Eliza said it very well, a lot of players make the mistake of taking likeable people to the finals. If Richard Hatch had let Rudy get into the Finals, Rudy would have won! If Jan/Helen had gotten into the finals they would have beaten Brian James/Pei Gee would have beaten Todd. easily. So if they are letting Amanda, who is clearly paying a much better social game this time get into the finals, with her hands clean. Well then one could argue that perhaps they deserve to lose because they were warned that Amanda would be hard to beat. After all it's not "just making moves" it's also convincing the rest to give you a million dollars...That's why you have to bring the goat to the finals. Not someone who everyone knows was a game player, but also stayed true to her alliances.

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

How will you feel if Amanda wins???