| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
 finishthemoff |
|||
|
Posts: 8202 (04/21/08 11:09 AM) Registered user |
I love the irony that both Billy and JFP voted against him, wishing that he will win and they wrestled against each other!
The biggest mistake Ozzy made was NOT voting out Cirie when it is clear that she was dragging her team down. |
||
|
mrnoluvstill |
|||
|
Posts: 411 (04/26/08 1:48 AM) Registered User |
I don't care if you have 3 idols in your possession, if you believe your alliance that you are safe, you are going to be blindsided. If everyone tells
you they are voting one person out and you believe them, you are going to be played. Yes you look dumb but no way is that the dumbest move like making it to
the final 3 and choosing the wrong person to go up against in front of the jury.
|
||
|
pocket aces.anti |
|||
|
Posts: 137 (04/26/08 5:43 AM) |
How can anyone be stupider than James? Its not just the failure to play the idols its the fact that even on his second time around he still doesnt grasp
the basic strategy of how the game is played. Ozzy understands it, he was just too arrogant and cocky to believe anyone would vote him out. James despite
what happened to him the first time, doesnt understand how to protect himself when he can clearly see his alliance falling apart by reaching out to create new
ones. Instead he just makes himself a bigger target by pissing off someone who has control over his destiny in the game.
|
||
 Mister Plum |
|||
|
Posts: 1640 (04/26/08 6:02 AM) |
Scout is back in a big way?
|
||
|
mrnoluvstill |
|||
|
Posts: 412 (04/27/08 1:31 AM) Registered User |
pocket aces wrote: I just don't see being dumb with 5 players still in the game as equal to being dumb on who to take to the final to go against. It's no contest. Lillian made a million dollar mistake, me and you both agree, James isn't smart enough to make it to the finals. If he were lucky enough to make it and chose to go against Cirie in the finals rather than Parvati, than he would be the dumbest. |
||
|
ImANewUser |
|||
|
Posts: 1319 (04/27/08 4:04 AM) Registered User |
mrnoluvstill wrote: Um...Lill would've lost to Jon (they did this revote thing in the Reunion, right?) and Ian's was stupider.
|
||
|
pocket aces.anti |
|||
|
Posts: 138 (04/27/08 9:42 AM) |
ImANewUser wrote: If you are talking a single incident in the game Id agree. For overall entire stupidity and not having a fucking clue of how to play the game Id still have to take James.
Last Edited By: pocket aces
04/27/08 4:38 PM.
Edited 1 times.
|
||
|
SashaAldeias |
|||
|
Posts: 37 (04/27/08 9:55 AM) |
No, James wouldn't have fallen for the fake II. He wouldn't have just forfeited the IC and he wouldn't have fallen for Natalie's trick... But
you're right in that he's not bothering to make new alliances. He should at least try to align with Erik, for whatever that's worth
|
||
|
aboutbreakingrules |
|||
|
Posts: 230 (04/27/08 5:41 PM) |
You have two idols, someone basically hands them to you on a silver platter, and you bring them to TC while still trusting your alliance to hold on to you.
Boom, out you go.
You found the real immunity idol while placing a phoney there. Lucky for you an uber-doofus found it. The phoney idol gets played and has an even stronger effect on your progress than you assumed. You don't bring your salvation to TC, trusting your alliance not to whack you at the kneecaps. Boom, you're gone. That's worse than dumb. It's downright retarded. On the plus side, all of this ends on Mother's Day and we can all prepare for a much-needed rest. |
||
|
BGrenier |
|||
|
Posts: 1178 (04/28/08 7:02 PM) Registered User |
fucking clue of how to play the game Id still have to take James. I don't see how you can even remotely argue that after last week's episode. Jason: 1. Was not liked by anyone. After Eliza, he was next on the list to be voted out until the GP saw an opportunity. 2. He trusted a group that included 2 people who had just betrayed an alliance. 3. He believe Natalie sent him to Exile to find the immunity idol and not because they just didn't want him around. 4. Ozzy had JUST BEEN VOTED OFF with the HII in possession. He knew this AND STILL didn't use the HII. I mean, c'mon...compared to the above, James just doesn't count. And the above doesn't even count trading votes for food, or falling for a stick with a face in it. |
||
|
BGrenier |
|||
|
Posts: 1179 (04/28/08 7:09 PM) Registered User |
You don't bring your salvation to TC, trusting your alliance not to whack you at the kneecaps. Boom, you're gone. Yeah, and Jason BROUGHT the REAL HII with him AND STILL did not use it. That's worse than dumb. It's downright retarded. I agree. Jason is retarded. |
||
|
DuckyLu |
|||
|
Posts: 51 (04/30/08 8:01 PM) |
I still think hands down James made the stupidest survivor move, because 2 idols...3 tribal councils...etc, etc. you all know it. Jason's blunder I really
think was pretty minor. Either Natalie was playing fans v/ faves or she wasn't. If it was him v. everyone else, and he didn't go this time, he'd go
the next time he didn't win immunity. He was taking a risk that he'd actually found an alliance, which was really his only chance of winning anyway. It
would have been quite reasonable for the fans to take that opportunity to shift the power away from the faves, who were taking a huge risk to let it get down
to 4 fans v 4 faves. I think his mistake was not talking to more people and trying to ascertain how real Natalie's loyalty was, but really his chance of
winning was almost nil anyway. The people who I think made the bigger blunder were Amanda, James, and Erik who were all on the outs of the last vote, but had a
chance here to grab some power.
|
||
|
aboutbreakingrules |
|||
|
Posts: 234 (05/01/08 7:09 PM) |
BGrenier wrote:
Last Edited By: aboutbreakingrules
05/01/08 7:14 PM.
Edited 1 times.
|
||
|
mrnoluvstill |
|||
|
Posts: 422 (05/10/08 6:51 PM) Registered User |
Well now we know this thread is full of shit. Maybe 2nd dumbest.
|
||
|
yosimtesam |
|||
|
Posts: 108 (05/10/08 6:58 PM) |
mrnoluvstill wrote: parv didnt care,., she didnt even want to look for the idol when she was on exile..so does that mean parv is dumb?... you decide.
|
||
|
mrnoluvstill |
|||
|
Posts: 424 (05/10/08 7:08 PM) Registered User |
yosimtesam wrote: After Thursday, we all agree who's the dumbest! |
||
|
yosimtesam |
|||
|
Posts: 111 (05/10/08 7:11 PM) |
I'll agree after tomorrow.... you dumbass; you dont even know when the show is on.
|
||
|
Sole Survivor Genius |
|||
|
Posts: 651 (05/10/08 8:41 PM) Registered User |
Wow a noob that said something smart!!^^
Agreed, mrnoluvstill you are the dumbest, and It's not even Thursday yet... |
||
|
BGrenier |
Erik: Definitely dumbest Surfvivor ever. | ||
|
Posts: 1191 (05/10/08 9:45 PM) Registered User |
I still think hands down James made the stupidest survivor move, because 2 idols...3 tribal councils...etc, etc. you all know it. No, I don't know that at all. All I know is that James believed & trusted his alliance and got voted out. I don't see how it's a stupid move to not play the immunity idol if you don't think you need to. James was ignorant, but certainly not supid. Ozzy was arrognat, but not stupid and got caught in it like James did. Jason is harder to even make any rationalization for...but I notice you tried. He had just seen a blindside on a person who had the HII. Why in the hell you don't play the HII in that instance is beyond me. But ok, he trusted an alliance and like James & Ozzy before, got cought with his pants down. There is no defending Erik. None. Nothing. It's just...wow. I mean, really. I still think Natalie put it best when she said "I feel stupid sitting here just listening to you." When I read Probst say someone does something even more stupid, the only thing I could think is that tsomeone gives up the necklace. Wow. Actually, there is only one rationalization I can think of. He figured he was screwed when it came to jury votes so he goes out making some kind of move. No, it doesn't work for me either. The people who I think made the bigger blunder were Amanda, James, and Erik who were all on the outs of the last vote, but had a chance here to grab some power. Uh...how? |
||
|
Riliss |
|||
|
Posts: 3739 (05/10/08 10:30 PM) Ugly on the inside |
AnomyBC wrote: |
||
