| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
 ShanesThinkingSeat |
|||
|
Posts: 306 (05/13/08 7:01 AM) |
1. Brian Heidik, our Lord and Master, is the undisputed GREATEST player (gamewise) to ever set foot on ANY season of Survivor.
2. The Tominator. 3. Parvati 4. Hatch 5. Earl 6. Tina 7. Yul 8. ...Sandra... 9. Chris 10. Aras 11. Danni 12. Todd 13. Danni 14. Ethan 15. Todd 16. Vecepia |
||
|
RBMSCJB |
|||
|
Posts: 815 (05/13/08 7:29 AM) |
1. Richard
2. Earl 3. Parvati 4. Todd 5. Sandra 6. Yul 7. Brian 8. Chris 9. Tina 10. Jenna 11. Sandra 12. Aras 13. Amber 14. Ethan 15. Danni 16. Vecepia |
||
|
colleenlover |
|||
|
Posts: 8128 (05/13/08 8:22 AM) Registered User |
Parvati (maybe the best game I've ever seen played)Parvati took out Ozzy leaving it 4 fans vs 4 faves- what if Natalie and Alexis only used the female alliance card to weed out the male faves? |
||
|
Robert Qld |
|||
|
Posts: 1060 (05/13/08 8:25 AM) Registered User |
Parv had Nat & Alexis eating out of her hand, she loosing them at the F8 for a purple rock senario.
|
||
|
colleenlover |
|||
|
Posts: 8129 (05/13/08 8:28 AM) Registered User |
Yeah, just like Tina had Lis and Rodger eating out of the palm of her hand. it's the same thing.
|
||
|
The Very Insane Shark |
|||
|
Posts: 3632 (05/13/08 9:06 AM) Registered user |
Are we ranking based on who we like or who played the best game?...I'll do game. Game? Seriously? ETA: 
|
||
|
The Very Insane Shark |
|||
|
Posts: 3633 (05/13/08 9:11 AM) Registered user |
Danni (made moves pre-merge that cost her the numbers, made it to the end thanks to one player's high-and-mighty approach to the game rather than anything of her own doing, faces up against the biggest goat of all time that any brain dead player could have defeated and she argues in favor of Stephenie at the final tribal council. The biggest offense of all is that she cites God as the reason for her win and turnaround in the game.) Thank you for that accurate description of Danni. Such an overrated winner. |
||
|
SurvivorSurvivorSurvivor |
|||
|
Posts: 5557 (05/13/08 4:20 PM) Registered User |
Parvati took out Ozzy leaving it 4 fans vs 4 faves- what if Natalie and Alexis only used the female alliance card to weed out the male faves?Nope, it would only be a tie scenario, purple rock. Would the girls risk it? Meanwhile, Natalie/Alexis had nothing to gain by going to the F3 with Jason or Erik at their side. They've seen the last four seasons and the result, plus they think Parvati's good on her word. Same way Boston Rob managed to string together two alliances that could have turned the scales at any time. Tina's situation is completely different. After Jerri's exit, it's 3-3-1. If Amber jumps ship it's over. Tina had absolutely no side alliance going on with Nick/Elisabeth/Rodger to prevent this from happening. |
||
|
BCNFAN |
My rank | ||
|
Posts: 23 (05/13/08 5:10 PM) Registered User |
1.- Parvati (Great Biiiitch)
2.- Tom Westman 3.- Ethan Zohn 4.- Danni Boatwright 5.- Todd Herzond 6.- Richard Hatch 7.- Jenna Morasca 8.- Aras Baskauskas 9.-Sandra Diaz 10.-Chris Daugherty 11.-Yul Kwon 12.- Brian Heidik 13.- Tina Wesson 14.- Amber Brkich 15.- Vecepia Towery 16.- Earl Code |
||
|
Kitty Pryde1 |
|||
|
Posts: 4112 (05/13/08 5:16 PM) |
SurvivorSurvivorSurvivor wrote: Uh...yes she did. |
||
|
SwineForkbeard |
|||
|
Posts: 1521 (05/13/08 6:45 PM) Registered user
|
SurvivorSurvivorSurvivor wrote: It would not have been a tie, because a) Jason had the idol, so as long as he was the target, the fans would prevail if he played it, and b) James voted for Parvati, so the favorites' votes were split. Natalie and Alexis were duped just like the men were by letting Parvati exploit their fear of the men as competitors and get them to accept the fourth and fifth spots in her alliance when they could have finished first and second had they stuck with Erik and Jason. |
||
|
SurvivorSurvivorSurvivor |
|||
|
Posts: 5559 (05/13/08 9:08 PM) Registered User |
If the fans taking over scenario plays out, Erik would've outlasted Jason because he's less of a physical threat. He then would've won the
remaining immunities against the females and find himself in the F3 with the two girls. He'd win the last challenge and be in the F2. He'd receive the
votes of Ozzy/James/Amanda because they all weren't part of the dethroning of Ozzy. Parvati/AlexisorNatalie vote for AlexisorNatalie. Eliza/Jason's
votes are up in the air but certainly favor Erik or especially Jason if he makes it to the F2 instead. I don't think the girls (Alexis/Natalie) were wrong
to fear the men more than the favorites. On paper, Parvati has a much better shot against the two fans in a F3 scenario, so they had no reason not to stick
with that, and teaming back-up with Erik (who was already blindsided) could lead to him turning the tables later on.
If Amanda hadn't been sent to exile at the right time, the votes swing against her 4-2. Erik is duped the next week. Then everyone votes out Cirie at F4 especially Parvati who has no choice but to go along with this in order to make it look like she wanted to go to the end with the fans. Natalie wins the last immunity and takes Alexis to the end of the game. Sticking with Parvati was the right move for Alexis/Natalie which is why Parvati 100% had them in her pocket.
Last Edited By: SurvivorSurvivorSurvivor
05/13/08 9:12 PM.
Edited 2 times.
|
||
|
Robert Qld |
|||
|
Posts: 1063 (05/14/08 6:24 AM) Registered User |
Lets not forget Nat & Alexis depised Jason and proberly would've rather got herpes then allign with him (wait... they did allign with Parv... maybe
they did get herpes).
|
||
|
Survivorjus |
Rate the Winners | ||
|
Posts: 159 (05/14/08 7:40 AM) Registered User |
I think its hard to rank an order - as circumstances were different based on when they played (for example: Rich, yes a great winner and really defined how to
play the game, but he really was shooting fish in a barrel. Parvati also played well, but again, was playing with some pretty dumb players and had 3 people
taken out for her). I will rank this way:
Great Winners: Rich - see above - adding that he was a target many times and if not for Sean being an idiot - "alphabet", the outcome could have been different. Todd - Owned up to his game and played really well. His 2 faults were - Amanda could have won if she performed well in the jury, He was not always in control as people discussed voting for him - they never talked about voting out Amanda. Sandra - Talk about adaptability. Created the "aslong as its not me" strategy. Couldn't rely on her challenges to get her through - total social and brain game. Brian - Argueably the best player ever. Really was totally in control Good Winners: Tom - Total domination in challenges. Take a few points off for Ian handing him the easy win, and for not having much social game - relied totally on physical game. Earl - Hard to put down perfection - however Cassandra and Dreamz were so obviously worthless players. He did well through being a minority. Danni - A quieter game , but still had to fight back from a minority and win over Steph/ Rafe. Luckily Steph screwed a lot of people over. Parvati - Though she really is the "Amber" of this season in terms of being a "favorite" and not really deserving to be there...she was playing from day 1. Though Fairplay would have left anyway, she helped that along and really was in the drivers seat for most of it. She took out the threats when needed and was pretty secure in the final 2 spot with either Amanda or Cirie. I would have liked to see her win some challenges and really earn her spot. Ethan - played the honesty game and was in a solid alliance. Probably one of the most likeable winners - but was sort of carried by Lex and Tom and their social/physical game. Jenna - won challenges when she needed to - built solid alliances - used sex to win. She outplayed Rob, which says something. Meh Winners - Aras Baskauskas - kind of a blah season. Cirie and Terry would have been a more interesting final 2. And who wouldn't have won against Danielle? Yul Kwon - I think everyone wanted Ozzy to win. Becky was a waste of space. He was fine. Just didn't excite me and his game didn't stand out. Tina Wesson - She did have a lot of social game, and had to rely on that since she couldnt win challenges. But Colby could have won easily - she wasnt in control. I think Jerri and Alicia voted a bit bitterly. At first we were excited - first woman winner, older woman winner, second season - woo hoo! but her game pales in comparison to all the above winners. Chris Daugherty - Twila handed him the winning strategy. The women saved him. It was dumb. A disgrace to Survivor: Amber Brkich - Should have never been on All Stars. Rob should have won. Their whole romance killed the season. Vecepia Towery - Ugh. Don't get me started. If Neleh could have laid off the "I didn't play until day 24" crap, perhaps we could have had a better (but not great) winner. V did nothing but thank jesus. Jesus didn't help you win - Kathy, Pappy and Neleh saved you and Sean. You were dead in the water way before that. |
||
|
Quiddity |
|||
|
Posts: 2514 (05/14/08 3:58 PM) Registered User |
Danni (made moves pre-merge that cost her the numbers, made it to the end thanks to one player's high-and-mighty approach to the game rather than anything of her own doing, faces up against the biggest goat of all time that any brain dead player could have defeated and she argues in favor of Stephenie at the final tribal council. The biggest offense of all is that she cites God as the reason for her win and turnaround in the game.) wrong, Wrong, Wrong, WRONG! Did I just talk to you about this in another thread? Or perhaps just someone saying the same thing. FACT: Danni is the only player in game history to successfully turn the tables by using the leaders of the majority alliance rather than those at the bottom. FACT: Danni was more than servicable from a challenge performance standpoint, despite the fact that she was so sick out there. FICTION: Danni being down 6-4 at the merge was her fault. FACT: Danni won just as many immunity challenges pre-merge as 4/6 of the majority alliance, and was only in the minority because she got completely screwed over by the tribal switch, which had a net effect of losing 2 immunity challenges, without actually losing them! FICTION: Danni and Cindy turning their backs on original Nakum had anything to do with Danni herself. FACT: The principal reason Judd and Cindy turned their backs on original Nakum was because they were so enamored with Stephenie. FACT: Danni knew exactly what to say to the jury, that Stephenie screwed them over, and that fact was arguing in HER favor because of the mood of the jury. This wasn't a jury looking to reward Stephenie because she was in a power position. FACT: Regardless of any nonsense you want to spew out about Danni arguing in Stephenie's favor, the fact remains that Danni received every single jury vote with the exception of ultra bitter Rafe, who was extremely pissed at Danni for voting him out (even though he released her from her promises to him) As for the God stuff, as an athiest I certainly don't find much enjoyment when people like Vecepia, Danni, Jameka, etc... credit their successes or failures to God. But they can say whatever the heck they want. That's not gonna raise or lower them in my eyes when it comes to how good they played. Let's stop beating around the bush. You're bashing Danni for saying that because you either hate religion or are an athiest and simply want to bash someone because they are religious. |
||
|
solesurvivor01 |
|||
|
Posts: 1721 (05/14/08 4:20 PM) Registered user |
Based on gameplay ONLY (with 1 being the best), I'd say...
1. Richard 2. Tina 3. Todd 4. Brian 5. Chris 6. Aras 7. Vecepia 8. Earl 9. Danni 10. Jenna 11. Tom 12. Parvati 13. Yul 14. Sandra 15. Ethan 16. Amber Feel free to bash/criticize this all you want, but I'm sticking to it. |
||
 Us Kids Know |
|||
|
Posts: 5883 (05/14/08 5:27 PM) Registered user
|
Get ready for the only acceptable answer hos <3
1. Sandra 2. Tina 3. Tom 4. Chris 5. Jenna 6. Amber 7. Ethan 8. Parvati 9. Richard 10. Danni 11. Todd 12. Brian 13. Aras 14. Earl 15. Vecepia 16. Yul |
||
|
CSCin3D |
|||
|
Posts: 8166 (05/14/08 6:00 PM) Registered user |
|
||
|
Dr Will Hatch two point oh |
|||
|
Posts: 3565 (05/14/08 6:10 PM) Registered user |
Us Kids Know wrote: WTF? Thats the most random ranking Ive seen
Its more like this 1.Brian 2.Richard,Tina,Tom,Yul,Earl 7.Aras 8.Parvati 9.Chris 10.Jenna 11.Danni 12.Vecepia 13.Todd 14.Sandra 15.Ethan 16.Amber |
||
|
unduli clone |
|||
|
Posts: 2801 (05/14/08 8:02 PM) Registered User |
Survivorjus wrote: You can't compare the two - Parvati may have not been quite deserving of her spot, but she had a reputation as a player and was immediately called out by Jonathan as a threat and seen as a threat the whole game. Amber had no reputation as a threat by any means and thereby coasted. |
||
