Yuku free message boards

Kitty Pryde1 wrote:

---

m0t0 maj1 wrote:

---

ArtieeLange wrote:

---

oh ehm gee wrote:

---

Tracy managed to get Mary and Mikey out despite the old people being a clear minority.

omg u retard, the way she "managed" that was to bond with other weaklings, and outnumber the threats.

Tracy bonded with Chet and Kathy, that makes them three. How did they outnumber 7 others.
You sir, and this idea of yours:

FAIL.

I noticed that you skipped this post when making your witty reply to Skittles. In short, you continue to ignore any post that proves you wrong and pick and choose what you want to agree with. You also seem to ignore the fact that typically, the first four boots under the current system ARE the weakest players in the game. Let's look back (And note that I'm not including quits or the pick 'em boots from Palau):

Borneo: Sonja (Oldest woman in the cast), B.B. (Oldest player on his tribe), Stacey (Not exactly strong), Ramona (Sick for the first week or so)
Australia: Debb (Not necessarily weak, but Kucha was a physically strong tribe), Kel (Strong player), Maralyn (Oldest woman in the game), Mitchell (Weakest man in the game)
Africa: Diane (Older woman and sick early on), Jessie (Sick early on), Carl (Wasn't anything special), Linda (Weakest older woman on Samburu)
Marquesas: Peter (Strong player), Patricia (Old and fat), Hunter (Strong player), Sarah (Weak and lazy)
Thailand: John (Strong player), Tanya (Sick early on), Jed (Strong player), Ghandia (Weak and mentally unstable)
Amazon: Ryan (Nothing special), Janet (Old and sick), Daniel (Nothing special), JoAnna (Nothing special)
Pearl Islands: Nicole (Nothing special), Ryan S. (Weak male), Lill (Weak older woman), Burton (Strong player)
All-Stars: Tina (Weak older woman), Rudy (Oldest man in the game), Rob C. (Physically weak man), Richard (Strong Player)
Vanuatu: Brook (Tribe of strong men, doesn't make a difference), Dolly (Nothing special), John P. (Tribe of strong men, doesn't make a difference), Mia (Nothing special)
Palau: Jolanda (Strong player), Ashlee (Weak quitter), Jeff (Strong player), Kim (Weak player)
Guatemala: Jim (Old and injured), Morgan (Nothing special), Brianna (Lazy and uncaring), Brooke (Nothing special)
Exile Island: Tina (Strong player), Melinda (Out-of-shape), Misty (Nothing special), Ruth Marie (Oldest woman in the game)
Cook Islands: Sekou (Strong player), Billy (Physical liability), Cecilia (Nothing special), JP (Strong player)
Fiji: Jessica (Nothing special), Erika (Nothing special), Sylvia (Weak and old), Liliana (Strong player)
China: Chicken (Nothing special), Ashley (Sick early on, but a strong player), Leslie (Weak older woman), Dave (Nothing special)
Micronesia: Jon (Weak and injured quitter), Mary (Nothing special), Yau-Man (Nothing special), Mikey (Strong player)

First off, that's 64 players in total. Of those 64, only 15 could really be considered strong players that shouldn't have been voted out. That's less than one fourth. Interesting to note is what happened to the tribes that booted those fifteen players. Ogakor booted Kel and went on a three-round losing streak for immunity. Maraamu booted Peter and Hunter and they never won a single challenge. Chuay Ghan booted John and took four episodes before they were able to come back. Sook Jai booted Jed and wound up blowing a massive numbers advantage. Drake booted Burton and didn't win a single immunity challenge from that point on. Mogo Mogo booted Richard and didn't win a single immunity challenge from that point on. Ulong booted Jolanda and Jeff and never won a single immunity challenge at all. Tina was an exception as her original tribe was dissolved shortly after she was booted, but without her, Casaya never would've won any challenges. Hiki booted Sekou and almost lost the next immunity to a team that was throwing it. Raro booted JP and down the line, they got owned by Aitu. Fiji is another exception, as the haves/have-nots twist basically meant the haves would always win (and they did, aside from one challenge). Zhan Hu booted Ashley and to a lesser extent, Chicken, and got owned. Mikey is the third exception, given that a swap happened just after he was booted.

So basically, the way the game is set up now, it's smarter to keep the stronger players until the merge and boot the weaker players early on. Just because someone like Courtney or Chet made it past the first four boots doesn't mean that's how the game always works. You're just being a troll by ignoring large chunks of Survivor history AND ignoring intelligent arguments that prove you wrong. Under the current system, the "strong" as you put it, are beneficial to the weak to keep around, and the only reason a strong player may be voted off under this system is in the event that they cause conflict in the tribe, or they simply don't bother forming bonds with people. Under your system, there are absolutely no benefits to keeping the strong in the game, since the strong to nothing to help out the weak. Thus, if a "strong" player happens to have the misfortune of falling into the "weak" group, then it's a no-brainer that the strong player will be voted out. It shouldn't be that difficult to understand. Unless you give a good reason as to why the strong would NOT be voted out upon losing a challenge under your system (aside from changing the rules to make it even less fair), then you have absolutely no rational argument.