2. Pearl Islands
3. Fiji
4. Palau
5. Cook Islands
6. Exile Island
7. Amazon
8. Marquesas
9. All Stars
10. China
11. Vanuatu
12. Australia
13. Africa
14. Borneo
15. Guatemala
16. Thailand
| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
limnThief |
|||
|
1. Fans vs Favorites
2. Pearl Islands 3. Fiji 4. Palau 5. Cook Islands 6. Exile Island 7. Amazon 8. Marquesas 9. All Stars 10. China 11. Vanuatu 12. Australia 13. Africa 14. Borneo 15. Guatemala 16. Thailand |
|||
CSCin3D |
|||
|
I am offended by the high placement of Exile Island. That season was boring as fuck. I'm fucking sobbing right now. |
|||
kishuu |
|||
|
You were bored for like 30mins watching the Amazon cause he got eliminated 30mins before the show ended?
uh... what? |
|||
sweEt Mauritius |
|||
colorofcoils wrote: Terry was boring and bland and unfortunately got shoved down our throats because of his immunity wins. Shane was a great character, not Terry. The thing that carried the season was the awesomeness of Casaya/Shane and all their antics. |
|||
CSCin3D |
|||
|
Shane wasn't a good character. Biggest myth ever. He was totally obviously phony and watching his crazy "antics" just pissed me off.
That's it. I've decided. Exile Island= Worst. Season. Ever. I missed two episodes and I don't even care. |
|||
sweEt Mauritius |
|||
colorofcoils wrote: Yeah, but Stephenie and Rupert had personalities which made them great, memorable characters (whether you loved or hated them). You can't have a great character just because of their storyline, otherwise Yul and Earl would be considered great characters, which they are NOT, and neither is Terry. I singled out Shane, who was certainly one of the best characters of the season, but each member of Casaya had their memorable moments and distinct personalities. That's why I say Casaya/Shane carried the season, not Terry. |
|||
oberon090 |
|||
|
1. Pearl Islands
2. Guatemala 3. Borneo 4. Outback 5. Amazon 6. Marquesas 7. China 8. Micronesia 9. Vanuatu 10. Palau 11. Exile Island 12. Cook Islands 13. All-Star 14. Thailand 15. Fiji 16. Africa |
|||
dragoondaniel78 |
|||
Edinboro wrote: Haha, yeah. You called it right. I'm pretty much done with Palau except the Finale which I will get to, tomorrow but I liked it quite a lot and despite
knowing that Ulong got trashed, I found myself liking several characters like Angie, Stephanie, Bobby Jon, Ian, Jenn, Katie and even Coby, most of it from his
jury cameo. Haha. The Janu-Steph tribal council was entertaining and suspenseful and the Caryn Tribal Council where there was so much drama and
"lying" was hilariously entertaining as well. I know Tom won, which sucks for me because I don't really like him but he's quite okay.
1) Amazon 2) Pearl Islands (moved up a spot because I realized that it was THAT good...) 3) Marquesas 4) Borneo 5) Palau 6) Australian Outback 7) Vanuatu 8) Africa 9) Thailand 10) All-Stars |
|||
dragoondaniel78 |
|||
|
SUCKS POPULARITY CONTEST
1. (-) MICRONESIA - 519
2. (-) PEARL ISLANDS - 524 3. (-) CHINA - 646 4. (+2) AMAZON - 718 5. (-) MARQUESAS - 743 6. (-2) BORNEO - 747 7. (+1) EXILE ISLAND - 812 8. (-1) AUSTRALIAN OUTBACK - 888 9. (+2) COOK ISLANDS - 933 10. (-1) GUATEMALA - 1082 11. (-1) VANUATU - 1089 12. (+1) PALAU - 1097 13. (+1) ALL-STARS - 1158 14. (-2) AFRICA - 1268 15. (-) FIJI - 1342 16. (-) THAILAND - 1386 ---- Only counting those with 16 seasons listed (that means excluding mine) ---- GREATEST JUMPS: Amazon (jumps 2 spots from #6 to #4) Cook Islands (jumps 2 spots from #11 to #9) GREATEST DROPS: Borneo (drops 2 spots from #4 to #6) Africa (drops 2 spots from #12 to #14) |
|||
beatles20147 |
|||
|
Re: Shane - most overrated character ever on the show. I thought he was amazingly entertaining right after S12 aired and one of the best characters ever but rewatching it everything feels just so fake, and not in a fun way like Greg. |
|||
Edinboro |
|||
|
Its a fucking vote!! lol, gets me every single time.
|
|||
WylDawg |
|||
|
I never thought this was possible, but there's roughly 137 reasons why I hate this thread....
|
|||
craig |
|||
|
I expect China's reputation to slip a bit over time but not Micronesia. China will be in the middle where Exile Island is in a year or two. People liked it
because it was return to form after Fiji, traditionalists liked it becaise it had 16 players. But ultimately it had few memorable events (James' boot was
truped by S16 postmerge), the the gameplay was essentially a modified pagonging like Outback. So many player's fate was determined by beiing assigned to
the physically weaker tribe, and the twist screwed strong leader-type males (Aaron).
Micronesia had so much prejudice to overcome to reach #1. Yawn, ASS seaons always sucks. WTF, they're gonna mix ASS and regular players? Damn, 20 players and they're bringing back Parvati and Amanda? OMG, the wrong alliance has taken control! Fuck you Cirie! How can we have a good strategic game without Jonathan and Fairplay, or girlpower without Ami? Then the Cirie\Parv\Amanda alliance give us awesomely entertaining postmerge gameplay on par with Amazon and Pearl Islands. The first half was good too (except ep.6-7), as long as you wern't lamenting the defeat of your prereconceived favorites. If S6 or S7 are your idea of a good season, than S16 belongs in their company. Micronesia doesn't have inflated heroes and villians like Rupert and Fairplay, but not everyone likes that.
Last Edited By: craig
06/22/08 7:16 AM.
Edited 2 times.
|
|||
CSCin3D |
|||
|
Micronesia didn't have good gameplay, it just had extremely idiotic gameplay. It won't hold up on a rewatch, simply because there's virtually no
entertainment beyond the blindsides, and when you already know what happens, it won't be entertaining anymore.
|
|||
craig |
|||
|
The seasons that get stuck in a gameplay rut fair the worst on rewatch. 7 episodes of Ulonging and 6 episodes of Terry's IC streak are the most blatent
examples. Same events, same people winning, same people in contol, over and over. That why Palau and EI were popular intitially but don't hold up like S6
and S7.
|
|||
GnarlsInCharge |
|||
CSCin3D wrote: I agree with you although I think to dismiss it all as people making idiotic moves is unfair to the winner Parvati who positioned herself perfectly all the
way and other than Chris in Vanuatu had probably the strongest post all star social game.
|
|||
Survivor Boy |
|||
|
Fuck everyone who ranked Amazon so high... and Cook Islands for that matter.
|
|||
Mister Plum |
|||
|
WTF, Amazon deserves its rank.
|
|||
GnarlsInCharge |
|||
|
Amazon was one of the most colourful seasons it more than deserves its rep as one of the best of all time.
|
|||
Mister Plum |
|||
|
I hated Roger and unlike you, after he was voted out, that's when I completely love the Amazon.
|
|||