| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
Kitty Pryde1 |
|||
|
Yeah, the RNO one.
|
|||
Kitty Pryde1 |
|||
185. Charlie Herschel (Survivor: Gabon - 9th Place) Yeah, basically the whole focus of Charlie's edit was Marcus Marcus Marcus, and as a result, he was a boring, one-note character. He also made an effort to be nice and cordial to people, which meant there was nothing of interest for him to bring in terms of entertainment. Right from the start, even before the show began, he proved himself to be the biggest gay stereotype the show has seen since Brandon Quinton (yes, bigger than Chet). He went on about how he was athletic, yet we saw absolutely nothing from him the entire season that set him apart from the many guys that actually seemed to have athletic ability. In fact, of the male cast, I'd say only Ken seemed less physical than Charlie, and that's saying something when you've got two guys older than 45. Charlie was a real fan of the show though, and at least seemed to understand that a blindside made for good TV. But a blindside is only good TV when you care about the person being blindsided. Someone who's blah and boring getting blindsided is nothing special.
36. New New Fang (Charlie, Corinne, Matty, Randy, Sugar) I don't know about this tribe. I mean, they won two challenges and established Randy as having one of the longest tribal winning streaks of all time, but the tribe itself was lackluster. Charlie and Corinne were relatively boring on their own, and they devolved into the BB6 Friendship once Marcus was voted out. Matty has always been a douchebag and seeing him in any situation where he's benefitted sucks. And this tribe also stopped Sugar's continuous streak of being sent to Exile Island, which sucks. The only saving grace of the tribe was Randy, but it was with the swapping of tribes that Randy also went from being a lovable curmudgeon to being an outright asshole that just isn't as much fun to watch anymore. This tribe is just so unspectacular, mainly because all the best players got stuck on New New Kota.
15. New New Kota (Bob, Crystal, Ken, Marcus, Susie) This tribe basically took the five most interesting characters in the game (replacing Susie with Randy), and put them on the same tribe. It also took the most obvious winner in the show's history and put him with two of the game's biggest schemers and someone who didn't trust him at all. The result? Marcus got voted out in the best blindside of the season, saving it from a boring conclusion (although if Matty wins, then it's clear that there are worse things than Marcus winning). Marcus knew Crystal's cousin and was actually a good friend of his. Bob was Bobbish as usual (and used his Exile Island time to create the best fake idol EVER.) Susie's stupidity was overshined by her ability to own Marcus. Crystal was her usual combative self. And Ken became the mastermind. This tribe had a lot going for it, but it's just not up to par with the tribes above it. |
|||
Bayou |
|||
Kitty Pryde1 wrote: WTF?! Hello...Randy? Bob? |
|||
Kitty Pryde1 |
|||
|
Bob and Randy have displayed more athleticism than Charlie.
|
|||
YemaGrl1988 |
|||
|
And nothing about being recruited via Eliza? He should get points docked for that IMO.
|
|||
Thailandsurvivor |
|||
But a blindside is only good TV when you care about the person being blindsided. Someone who's blah and boring getting blindsided is nothing special.Probably the only thing we'll agree on this season. That's exactly why I think the final 6 episode in Micronesia is one of the worst of all time. Still thought the episode was good, but the actual "blindside" wasn't near as exciting as it should have been. |
|||
Kitty Pryde1 |
|||
|
Honestly, who gives a shit if he was recruited? Applicants can suck too.
|
|||
YemaGrl1988 |
|||
Kitty Pryde1 wrote:But Eliza recruited him... and Eliza sucks. |
|||
Expatriate |
|||
Kitty Pryde1 wrote: |
|||
Kitty Pryde1 |
|||
|
Eliza is one of my top ten favorite players.
|
|||
spnintendo |
|||
|
Where did you find that piccie of Charliekins? =O He's purtier than Todd, imo. Oh wellz.
|
|||
kishuu |
|||
|
all I have to say is, Charlie deserves some credit for being the least bitter out of all the onions voted out.
Hell, we know Corrine and Randy are gonna go into wtfspams in their interviews. |
|||
YemaGrl1988 |
|||
Kitty Pryde1 wrote:Lulz. |
|||
Edinboro |
|||
|
I feel bad for Charlies edit.
|
|||
kishuu |
|||
|
Marcus is pissed/shocked/omfgwtf Charlie runs faster than him in Ponderosa.
that's gotta be saying something about athleticism or whatever. |
|||
YemaGrl1988 |
|||
|
Elle Oh Elle.
|
|||
Kitty Pryde1 |
|||
3. Randy Bailey (Survivor: Gabon - 8th Place) And now we have not only the first Gabon castaway to make my top fifty, but Ruthless Randy even managed to crack my top five. Now, I know most of Sucks HATES Kota because of how boring they were and how arrogant they've been in confessionals, but honestly, I think they have every right to be. Aside from that second swap, I think they were in perfect position to win the entire game, hands down. But let's not argue about that, even though I know we will. This is Randy's write-up, and now that he's in my top three, I think he deserves to be done justice. When I first read Randy's bio on the website, I thought I was going to hate him because he was just going to be an asshole and a bully. But then the first episode came around and it took hardly any time at all for Randy to grow in my heart. Whether Sucks wants to admit it or not, Fang was a complete fuck-up tribe during the early and middle part of the game. They couldn't do anything right at all, and Randy was the only person on his tribe who would say this to us and tell us what we were all thinking. He called out GC for being a shitty leader, which he was, and he called out the rest of his tribe for being fucking retarded, which they were. The whole time though, he played nice to peoples' faces and stayed under the radar as best he could, although he did make a point of telling his tribe that they needed to stop being such fucking pigs about the rice. In episode four, he even got a four-person alliance together that could've held the power in the game. Then the swap happened and Randy, having been ranked third most important on his tribe, behind the two strongest guys, wound up in the minority on Kota. There, he got into the good graces of the ruling Onions and even managed to overtake Bob for the fourth spot in their alliance. So despite a swap putting him in a bad position, Randy worked on it and got himself back into a good one. Of course, then Kota got screwed by a second tribe swap that took out Randy's ally, Marcus, and left him in a numerical minority. As a result, he was pretty much screwed because the people he hated and who hated him made up the majority. I liked Randy for a variety of reasons. For one, he almost always had one moment in each episode where he just gave a laugh-out-loud quote or something of the sort. For two, on the first day he injured his head and needed stitches, yet he fought on and never gave up. He was a strategic player and a smart one at that, and he made a lot of the best moves he could possibly make, given the situations he found himself in. Randy also proved to be quite the challenge threat, scoring a hat trick in water lacrosse, football catching fruit, and the one of the best moments of the season, where he completely fucked with Ace's head and got hi to cost his tribe the win. Randy was bombastic and obnoxious, but in a funny, Judd-like way. And despite being an asshole, like Judd could be, Randy was a strategic player and a smart one at that. Plus, Randy was a real fan of the show and applied many times just because he wanted to play. That's a good attitude to have in the game of Survivor. Towards the end of his run, it became apparent that Randy couldn't win, so at least he went out with a bang in one of the best and funniest episodes of the season. Even though Randy is an asshole, I can really understand where he's coming from. I mean, I'm really anti-social myself, and I can't stand talking to certain people, so I can definitely understand him developing a strong dislike towards the other players out there. Plus, he's the way he is because he's a loner and an outcast, and I know that that sort of persona can make you feel bitter and hateful towards others. But on the inside, Randy is really a sweet person, and it's sad to know that he lost his dog, because that's tough to deal with, even if you're not a big animal lover. Also, I love the fact that Randy has the second funniest hair of the season (behind Bob). And last but not least, I love the fact that, in his interviews, Randy was able to make fun of Sugar's poor quality of marriage. He's definitely destined to be a Suckster. So with that, Randy becomes the highest ranking male on my list, and he deserves it, definitely. |
|||
KiLLamanjaro |
|||
|
Looks like somebody fell for the editing hook line and sinker. Fail
|
|||
kishuu |
|||
|
Randy is not strategic at all.
All his post merge votes casted were PURELY personal. Crystal was a personal vote cause he hated her, Susie was a personal vote as well (even he admits it). Randy is not some strategic player you make him out to be. Onion admits they dragged Randy along because they lost Jacquie and they'd kick him out before they entered F4 (post show interviews). Randy just fit in with the arrogant mean onions (Corrine) more than Dan and Susie did. |
|||
maldoror122 |
|||
|
Oh wow. Didn't see this one coming at all.
|
|||