Rank the Winners

0 Kudo

Started By	Comment
CSCin3D		#1021	[-]
Posts: 10778 (12/15/08 1:28 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	based on my overall satisfaction with their win and how they represented their seasons: 1. Richard 2. Bob 3. Sandra 4. Vecepia 5. Danni 6. Tina 7. Chris 8. Tom 9. Jenna 10. Yul 11. Parvati 12. Brian 13. Earl 14. Ethan 15. Todd 16. Amber 17. Aras Wow I just realized there are now a shitload of people to rank. I remember the days when there were like 7 or 8
BladeBlur		#1022	[-]
Posts: 13 (12/15/08 1:34 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	1. Hatch 2. Sandra 3. Chris 4. Danni 5. Tina 6. Bob 7. Todd 8. Parvati 9. Vecepia 10. Tom 11. Earl 12. Brian 13. Yul 14. Aras 15. Ethan 16. Jenna 17. Amber
Stranded		#1023	[-]
Posts: 2320 (12/15/08 2:00 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Why are people ranking Bob so highly? I like the guy, but he didn't really DO anything in the game, and his FTC performance is easily one of the worst in years. He admitted several times that he made no strategic decisions. Where is all of this respect coming from, people?
CSCin3D		#1024	[-]
Posts: 10780 (12/15/08 2:03 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Just because he seems like a nice person and that plays a huge part for me : /
Kitty Pryde1		#1025	[-]
Posts: 7308 (12/15/08 2:03 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Stranded wrote: Why are people ranking Bob so highly? I like the guy, but he didn't really DO anything in the game, and his FTC performance is easily one of the worst in years. He admitted several times that he made no strategic decisions. Where is all of this respect coming from, people? He was a great character.
ZombieLinda		#1026	[-]
Posts: 6142 (12/15/08 2:21 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	If I ranked gameplay Bob would probably be dead last. I really don't see how you could make much of a case for him in that light. I don't root for people based on that though. It's just a bonus if the people I like happen to be good players. I actually like that Bob didn't really care about the game and ended up winning in a cast filled to the brim with rabid and desperate players. <3
Stranded		#1027	[-]
Posts: 2324 (12/15/08 2:30 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I never said Bob was unlikable. If anything, I think that's why he won the million. But if you're ranking the winners, I think gameplay trumps likability. All winners of Survivor deserve to win because the jury gave them the most votes. That's just a fact. But Bob admitted several times that he made no strategic moves in the game, and to rank him highly on a list of winners doesn't really make any sense. One last time - I like Bob. However, he isn't a strong winner.
BladeBlur		#1028	[-]
Posts: 16 (12/15/08 3:08 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Stranded wrote: Why are people ranking Bob so highly? I like the guy, but he didn't really DO anything in the game, and his FTC performance is easily one of the worst in years. He admitted several times that he made no strategic decisions. Where is all of this respect coming from, people? My list changes constantly but mainly because Bob did manage to screw a tight 5-people alliance by making Kenny vote for Matty. If it weren't for the fake idol he made, he wouldn't have won. That also pretty much was the pivotal moment that made Kenny crumble completely and he knew his days were numbered.
LKMOSCAR		#1029	[-]
Posts: 5684 (12/15/08 3:32 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Bob is definitely one of the worst winners ever. I think that he lucked out at F4 by being with a girl who would change everything if you were the last person in her ear. If you think of his moves and FTC, too, then you'd know that he is unworthy.
James Barber		#1030	[-]
Posts: 14784 (12/15/08 4:06 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Bob is definitely one of the worst winners ever. I think that he lucked out at F4 by being with a girl who would change everything if you were the last person in her ear. If you think of his moves and FTC, too, then you'd know that he is unworthy. Ken and Crystal lucked out by having her there to get rid of Ace. Many players used Sugar for their own purposes. Bob was the one who managed to convince her he was a "good" person, such a good person that she handed him the game. Bob won most of the immunity challenges he needed to stay in the game, he managed to get and keep Sugar on his side. He was a low-key player who won in a season full of OTT, desperate players who spent so much time bragging about their cleverness or what nice people they were that they struggled to play the actual game. He managed to win in spite of gimmicks which bailed out the Fang alliance over and over. Not the best winner, but I'd say he's better than Ethan, Chris, Aras, Jenna, Earl, just off the top of my head.
sackingsfan33		#1031	[-]
Posts: 215 (12/15/08 4:12 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	1. Sandra 2. Todd 3. Parvati 4. Jenna 5. Rich Those are really the only 5 I like. 6. Tina 7. Danni 8-17 The rest
LKMOSCAR		#1032	[-]
Posts: 5685 (12/15/08 9:26 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Ken and Crystal lucked out by having her there to get rid of Ace. Many players used Sugar for their own purposes. Any winner this season was going to be bad. Except for Susie, every player got extremely lucky.
Dr Will Hatch two point oh		#1033	[-]
Posts: 6565 (12/15/08 9:30 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	James Barber wrote: Bob is definitely one of the worst winners ever. I think that he lucked out at F4 by being with a girl who would change everything if you were the last person in her ear. If you think of his moves and FTC, too, then you'd know that he is unworthy. Ken and Crystal lucked out by having her there to get rid of Ace. Many players used Sugar for their own purposes. Bob was the one who managed to convince her he was a "good" person, such a good person that she handed him the game. Bob won most of the immunity challenges he needed to stay in the game, he managed to get and keep Sugar on his side. He was a low-key player who won in a season full of OTT, desperate players who spent so much time bragging about their cleverness or what nice people they were that they struggled to play the actual game. He managed to win in spite of gimmicks which bailed out the Fang alliance over and over. Not the best winner, but I'd say he's better than Ethan, Chris, Aras, Jenna, Earl, just off the top of my head. Really? I would rank him just over Ethan and Amber.
menelaus		#1034	[-]
Posts: 55 (12/15/08 9:42 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I wouldn't even rank him over Ethan, Ethan made two strong strategic moves, Bob made none. As far as challenges are concerned, Ethan never needed them because of his meatshield Lex.
Dr Will Hatch two point oh		#1035	[-]
Posts: 6569 (12/15/08 9:46 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	You're right. Actually, yeah, Bob is probably the least strategic winner ever.
survivorcreep		#1036	[-]
Posts: 91 (12/15/08 9:55 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	1. Sandra 2. Tina 3. Jenna 4. Richard 5. Vecepia 6. Parvati 7. Brian 8. Aras 9. Chris 10. Yul 11. Todd 12. Danni 13. Ethan 14. Earl 15 Bob 16. Amber 17. Tom
GnarlsInCharge		#1037	[-]
Posts: 2868 (12/15/08 10:16 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	The dude even admited he let others do the thinking for him and that he outwitted and outplayed no one. There might have been other winners just as usless but none of them were stupid enough to admit it to the jury and during multiple questions even. I don't even think it is even debateable gameplay wise he is the worst winner ever. Likeability wise though he isn't bad as a couple of them.
PJMichaelangelo		#1038	[-]
Posts: 134 (12/15/08 10:59 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I've never understood why people are so quick to discredit UTR as a credible strategy. Each season has its own mix of different people which requires a different strategy. Bob said in his RNO interview that his strategy was to not be strategic. He felt that if he let others take the lead then they'd take the hits and he would get further in the game. And he was absolutely right. His strategy worked for him. Would it work every season? No. But it worked with this mix of people. What's the best strategy? The one that gets you a million dollars. And it's going to be different every season. Hatch's strategy won't work every season. Hedik's strategy won't work every season. Parvati's strategy won't work every season. Sometimes you gotta be Vee or Sandra to win. And while you may think their win wasn't as good as Brian or Hatch's, guess what? Their million spends just the same.
fireballinsky		#1039	[-]
Posts: 220 (12/15/08 11:05 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	01. Richard 02. Danni 03. Jenna 04. Tom 05. Tina 06. Parvati 07. Brian 08. Ethan 09. Sandra 10. Earl 11. Aras 12. Yul 13. Todd 14. Bob 15. Chris 16. Vecepia 17. Amber
Katy Carney		#1040	[-]
Posts: 2756 (12/15/08 11:32 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	17. Bob.

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

Rank the Winners

Quick Reply