Yuku free message boards

Worst Survivors in the last 17 Seasons

Stacey Stillman from Borneo. I think she was supposed to be what Jerri ended up being in season 2. She really didn't add much as far as memorable moments which pretty much everyone else in the Borneo cast had. If anyone in the Borneo cast should have been replaced i'd say her.

Amber Brkich from Australian Outback. It had to be her or Nick and I feel like we got to know Nick more since he wasn't hiding behind one particular person through his time on the show, like Amber was Jerri. Amber has "Oh My God, this is soo good!" but that's not something you notice without actually paying attention throughout.

Kim Powers from Africa. She was really Colleen/Elisabeth lite. We'd seen that character play and lose twice already. I do actually like Kim but I don't feel like she was all that entertaining or a good player to keep around.

Zoe Zanidakis from Marquesas. She was really just there long enough to make enough bad moves to boot her. She added very little to the show other than her minor fued with Tammy and being a aprt of the Rotu 4.

Stephanie Dill from Thailand. i was going to sau Jed but I think if he made it farther he could have been great. Stephenie was isolated and quiet a lto of her time on the show and her making it to the end I feel would be dull.

Butch Lockley from The Amazon. He was always just there and in the background in a cast of big characters. I think maybe it was good to have him there since Amazon did have a lot of big characters and he was a nice calm one. That being said I would still pick him to be replaced.

Ryan Opray from Pearl Islands. It was gonna be him or Shawn, but I think Shawn in 7 episodes did more than Ryno did in those same 7 eps, so Shawn would be more entertaining post merge and therefore better casting.

Jenna Lewis from All-Stars. WTF??!! It should probably be Amber but in casting her it created Romber (i'm indifferent on them) so Amber's done more than JLew at this point and though they did not know it at the time, Amber was Survivor Gold as long as far as Survivor is concerned. Jenna Lewis sucked.

Lisa Keiffer from Vanuatu. She is very much like Butch except she sort of shot herself in the foot earlier. She was always kinda just there. If they only had 16 people in Vanuatu Lisa would be one i'd hope they'd have dropped.

Jonathan Libby from Palau. I know i'm not really giving him a chance since he was only in 20 minutes or so of one episode, but in the same time Wanda made a huge mark. Jonathan would have been dull had he lasted..basically a white Ibrehem...but Ibe has more personality imo. If I had to pick someone other than Jonathan i'd probably say Ibe. haha.

Brianna Varela or Morgan McDevitt from Guatemala. Either one would be fine, Brianna added more to the show but Morgan may have had she lasted. If I had to pick one or the other i'd probabaly keep Brianna and lose Morgan. Brooke was close but she would have played well I think.

Nick Stanbury from Panama. This guy was so UTR that no one really remembers him..I've seen Panama twice and off the top of my head I remember him doing nothing but hitting Bruce with a machete and lasting to the end of the F10 IC...and his final words. I think Panama could lose him.

Rebecca Borman from Cook Islands. I want to sayshe'd kick ass near the end but it did seem like she kinda gave up after the mutiny. I think she would have been way UTR post merge. Becky had some good moments though she was quiet most of the way and Sundra was very sweet and it showed. Both were part of the Aitu 4 and that alone says they should be kept over Rebecca.

Melissa McNulty. But otherwise Jessica deBen from Fiji. She would have just rode Rocky's coattails and likely knocked off anyway due to Ravu voting out all women. If they replaced her it may have been better.

Aaron Reisnenberg from China. Kind of like Butch again in the sense that he was very quiet on a season full of characters. I'd pick him based on the fact that I wouldn't like to lose anyone else from China except maybe Amanda or Denise. I liked Amanda in Micronesia so i'd like to keep her here and Denise as much as I dislike her did add to the show. Aaron it is.

Chet Welch from Micronesia. I almost didn't go with him since he had the ongoing feud with Joel but in the end i'd just rather he was never there. Mary could have been better after the swap and Yau sucked but he earned a spot.

Jacquie Berg from Gabon. It may have saved us from the onion bullshit. She didn't add much to the show..I think she would have been a lot like China Amanda if she stayed. Smart but really just there.