Survivor Sucks All-Seasons Popularity Poll

0 Kudos

Started By	Comment
Bayou		#2061	[-]
Posts: 178 (01/18/09 1:19 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	So for the individual season results, we got: 1. Borneo 2. China 3. Micronesia 4. Cook Islands 5. Exile Island 6. Vanuatu 7. All-Stars 8. Australia 9. Gabon 10. Africa 11. Marquesas 12. Guatemala 13. Fiji 14. Palau 15. Amazon 16. Pearl Islands 17. Thailand Borneo is at top where it should be. Pearl Islands, Palau, Guatemala, and Fiji are way too low. Australia, Vanuatu, Exile Island, and China are way too high
Middle Kingdom		#2062	[-]
Posts: 332 (01/18/09 1:30 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	China is too high?! It should be at the top! Borneo is the 1 that is extremely overrated just because it was the first season and people like it for sentimental reasons. It was a total snoozefest. I could see it being high for that reason but not number 1. China was better all the way around. Strategy, character development, culture, being stranded, and barely anyone has a bad thing to say about it
Katy Carney		#2063	[-]
Posts: 3648 (01/18/09 1:32 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	I didn't really like China all that much, but I didn't hate it. I don't see it as being as amazing as Sucks generally thinks it is. The only truly great thing about it was Peih-Geesus aka the LAW.
Middle Kingdom		#2064	[-]
Posts: 333 (01/18/09 1:34 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	That's still more than Borneo which had absolutely nothing interesting about it except for it being the 1st reality show
chapera rocks		#2065	[-]
Posts: 10261 (01/18/09 3:14 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Plugs http://survivorsucks.yuku.com/topic/44623 People, vote for the Tocantins poll this season! Pre-show voting is open now, but definitely come and vote for the episodes! ( Wyldawg is the most glaring example of a regular that doesn't vote, not to single you out or anything. )
srvivrfreakevelrich		#2066	[-]
Posts: 61 (01/18/09 3:33 PM) Admin Reply Quote More Recent Posts	so whose left now??
craig		#2067	[-]
Posts: 14774 (01/18/09 7:28 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	So for the individual season results, we got: 1. Borneo 2. China 3. Micronesia 4. Cook Islands ... 15. Amazon 16. Pearl Islands 17. Thailand Those aren't indivivual season results. That's the average popualrity for contestants in each season. Which really doesn't mean much when you consider that all the unpopular people from Amazon left pre-jury while the top 6 from that season made F8. Conversely people aren't fond of ASS because the popular players left early. 8 season results to come - S1, S2, S4, S6, S7, S15, S16, S17. Thanks Redwing for the combined results on the last page.
craig		#2068	[-]
Posts: 14775 (01/18/09 7:52 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Re the discussion about nice, likeable characters vs interesting, entertaining ones: Corinne's final words are great: "I don't want people to like me for someone I'm not. I think part of the reason people like me in general, or the people in my alliance or people in my life, is that I've always been the type of person who says what's on my mind and operates without a filter. That is sort of what's endearing about me in general. I think when you take that away I'm just another girl who doesn't have much of a personality. Just being nice isn't really a personality trait that I find interesting, you know what I mean? I don't have that many friends in my life who are like, 'Oh, she's nice.' That's so...anybody can be nice." The best chaarcters are neither completely dispicable or nice in a boring way. They are complicated enough to be fascinating. Corinne and Randy both have their endearing side, they are smart and original, though they also have aspects that are a bit twisted. That's why people will look back on them as among Gabon's best.
agent2424		#2069	[-]
Posts: 3841 (01/18/09 7:52 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	SURVIVOR SEASON RANKINGS! #8- Survivor Marquesas (Season 4) Average: 6.62 #7- Survivor Australia (Season 2) Average: 6.95 #6- Survivor Borneo (Season 1) Average: 6.96 Sad to see Marquesas so low... that was the season that introduced and made me "get into" Survivor... The 5 that are left are: Survivor China Survivor Micronesia Survivor Gabon Survivor Pearl Islands Survivor Amazon
menelaus		#2070	[-]
Posts: 279 (01/18/09 7:58 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Boo at Marquesas being below Gabon. Marquesas was a much better season.
Mikester		#2071	[-]
Posts: 800 (01/18/09 7:59 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Gabon should have been in between Marquesas & Australia. I didn't know Cook Islands got out yet? Too bad. Such a great season.
Ambient Nite		#2072	[-]
Posts: 566 (01/18/09 8:00 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	That's a great picture of the Borneo cast!
sackingsfan33		#2073	[-]
Posts: 232 (01/18/09 8:02 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Gabon should have been out a long time ago! I'm glad China, Micronesia, and Pearl Islands are still in though. Those are 3 of the best!
9RedWing19		#2074	[-]
Posts: 2401 (01/18/09 8:04 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	craig wrote: So for the individual season results, we got: 1. Borneo 2. China 3. Micronesia 4. Cook Islands ... 15. Amazon 16. Pearl Islands 17. Thailand Those aren't indivivual season results. That's the average popualrity for contestants in each season. Which really doesn't mean much when you consider that all the unpopular people from Amazon left pre-jury while the top 6 from that season made F8. Conversely people aren't fond of ASS because the popular players left early. 8 season results to come - S1, S2, S4, S6, S7, S15, S16, S17. Thanks Redwing for the combined results on the last page. I for one find it interesting that the Cook Islands did so well based on the individual contestants results, but so poorly when ranking the season itself. I would have expected to see a much stronger correlation between the ratings for the contestants and the ratings for the season (eg if you liked a season such as Pearl Islands with lots of power shifts post-merge, you would like, or at least not dislike, the contestants that provided such an interesting season). There are seasons that are "hurt" because their early boots got really bad ratings (eg Amazon), but IMO that is not entirely unfair because it doesn't say much for a season if people can't stand the early boots who generally do not get much airtime (eg Janet and Ryan from Amazon).
chapera rocks		#2075	[-]
Posts: 10263 (01/18/09 8:07 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	The best chaarcters are neither completely dispicable or nice in a boring way. They are complicated enough to be fascinating. Corinne and Randy both have their endearing side, they are smart and original, though they also have aspects that are a bit twisted. That's why people will look back on them as among Gabon's best. Blah, blah, blah.
Fei Long Dragon		#2076	[-]
Posts: 371 (01/18/09 8:08 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	9RedWing19 wrote: craig wrote: So for the individual season results, we got: 1. Borneo 2. China 3. Micronesia 4. Cook Islands ... 15. Amazon 16. Pearl Islands 17. Thailand Those aren't indivivual season results. That's the average popualrity for contestants in each season. Which really doesn't mean much when you consider that all the unpopular people from Amazon left pre-jury while the top 6 from that season made F8. Conversely people aren't fond of ASS because the popular players left early. 8 season results to come - S1, S2, S4, S6, S7, S15, S16, S17. Thanks Redwing for the combined results on the last page. I for one find it interesting that the Cook Islands did so well based on the individual contestants results, but so poorly when ranking the season itself. It's because people are actually fine with the contestants but they disliked the result of what happened (Jonathan not winning, Aitu winning, non-Raro winning, or whoever they were rooting for not winning). A simple look at racists like Katy Carney is a perfect example. She loves the cute white girls, but loathes what she feels was rigging against them
menelaus		#2077	[-]
Posts: 280 (01/18/09 8:12 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Also, Cook Islands was a pretty bad season all around. In order to hit their racial quotas they did a bunch of recruiting for people who had never seen the show and sucked at the game. The season was strategically pretty poorly played, the location was really soft and easy to live in, and the Aitu 4 were a rather boring set of underdogs (Ozzy was a challenge beast and Yul is just a kind of dull person). Not to mention that the season was horrendously edited, ignoring a good number of people almost entirely.
agent2424		#2078	[-]
Posts: 3842 (01/18/09 8:12 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Gabon should have been out ages ago!
agent2424		#2079	[-]
Posts: 3844 (01/18/09 8:19 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Just a reminder to take this poll: http://www.surveymonkey.c...nmrlBxNM9fZH_2fAB0g_3d_3d
craig		#2080	[-]
Posts: 14776 (01/18/09 8:24 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	It not racists, but Format Fundamentalists, who drag Cooks down. The sort of folks that give S12 and S15 extra marks just because they had 16 players. One of the biggest Raro fans on the board here, and I always thought Yul was a great winner and rate the season among my top 8. I can see Borneo losing to seasons that took gameplay to another level like S6, S7, and S16. But not to another season where a gay mastermind executed a predicatable pagonging.

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

Survivor Sucks All-Seasons Popularity Poll