TOP CHEF 5 NY--It's not Top Chef, it's Top Pussy!

0 Kudos

Started By	Comment
Drew B		#2581	[-]
Posts: 4332 (02/16/09 3:55 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	CatLurvesDorothy wrote: Drew B wrote: I want a final two of Stefan and Fabio with Stefan winning. These two have had such great competitive respect for one another that I think it would provide the most satisfying competition. Stefan's obsession with Stefan is mental illness, not a sign of respect... Carla has done great to get where she is, but I think her against Stefan would be a blowout. If I may say something: Andrea vs Stefan. Who won that? That was one dish. The finale is always a multi-course meal. I don't doubt that Carla would manage to beat Stefan on one of the courses, but not overall.
CatLurvesDorothy		#2582	[-]
Posts: 4715 (02/16/09 3:56 PM) OMEDETO, CATHY!! Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Lisa beat Blaise on 3/4 dishes lat season. Noone would've called that.
Drew B		#2583	[-]
Posts: 4333 (02/16/09 4:11 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	CatLurvesDorothy wrote: Lisa beat Blaise on 3/4 dishes lat season. Noone would've called that. That is true. I guess Carla COULD pull it out, but I wouldn't expect it.
seaguy		#2584	[-]
Posts: 14304 (02/16/09 4:24 PM) AI Forum Moderator Reply Quote More Recent Posts
MultiGeminii		#2585	[-]
Posts: 1474 (02/16/09 4:36 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	I know I don't know every casual viewer of this show, but I know a LOT of casual viewers of Top Chef, and unfortunately, they are all almost as annoyed that Carla has lasted this long as they are Leah lasted as long as she did. The tortoise/hare storyline could be attempt to soften predicted disgruntlement and could go either way, really. I don't know anyone on the planet who will be happy with a Hosea win. It can not happen with that editing. Right? Anyway... still rooting for Stefan like I have been since episode 1. I'm glad people are finally coming around to him.
seaguy		#2586	[-]
Posts: 14306 (02/16/09 4:43 PM) AI Forum Moderator Reply Quote More Recent Posts	MultiGeminii wrote: I know I don't know every casual viewer of this show, but I know a LOT of casual viewers of Top Chef, and unfortunately, they are all almost as annoyed that Carla has lasted this long as they are Leah lasted as long as she did. Funny, all the casual viewers I've talked all think Carla is great and hate Stefan.
Drew B		#2587	[-]
Posts: 4335 (02/16/09 5:04 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	seaguy wrote: MultiGeminii wrote: I know I don't know every casual viewer of this show, but I know a LOT of casual viewers of Top Chef, and unfortunately, they are all almost as annoyed that Carla has lasted this long as they are Leah lasted as long as she did. Funny, all the casual viewers I've talked all think Carla is great and hate Stefan. But which do they think is the more accomplished CHEF? Isn't that what matters?
MultiGeminii		#2588	[-]
Posts: 1475 (02/16/09 5:05 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	But you hate Stefan and love Carla, seaguy! :p I like both of them. :)
CatNamedRudy		#2589	[-]
Posts: 3173 (02/16/09 5:29 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Drew B wrote: mrsbennett wrote: I have been noticing a surge in affection for Fabio and Carla on the boards. Really? I think there has been tremendous affection for these two from the beginning, even before it was warranted. I want a final two of Stefan and Fabio with Stefan winning. These two have had such great competitive respect for one another that I think it would provide the most satisfying competition. Stefan's obsession with Stefan is mental illness, not a sign of respect... Carla has done great to get where she is, but I think her against Stefan would be a blowout. Is this supposed to say Hosea's obsession with Stefan?
seaguy		#2590	[-]
Posts: 14307 (02/16/09 6:06 PM) AI Forum Moderator Reply Quote More Recent Posts	MultiGeminii wrote: But you hate Stefan and love Carla, seaguy! :p I like both of them. :) Oh no. I have almost always liked Stefan. :) And Drew, maybe some people actually think Carla is the best. I don't know that Stefan is since I haven't tasted the food. The judges said so, so I guess I have to believe them huh?
CAPSattack		#2591	[-]
Posts: 1046 (02/16/09 6:36 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	All these chef's have accomplished careers in their own right so I don't think it matters because once your in the competition, its about whats going on then and now.
Drew B		#2592	[-]
Posts: 4336 (02/16/09 7:39 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	CatNamedRudy wrote: Is this supposed to say Hosea's obsession with Stefan? Oops. Yes.
Drew B		#2593	[-]
Posts: 4337 (02/16/09 7:41 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	seaguy wrote: And Drew, maybe some people actually think Carla is the best. I don't know that Stefan is since I haven't tasted the food. The judges said so, so I guess I have to believe them huh? The judges are certainly part of it. I'd also add in the facts that Carla has talked herself about how she sucked earlier on. Also the facts that all of the other chefs think Stefan is their competition but don't seem to think the same of Carla. Perhaps Carla is the best, but none of the evidence points that way...
seaguy		#2594	[-]
Posts: 14315 (02/16/09 7:49 PM) AI Forum Moderator Reply Quote More Recent Posts	They may think he's their competition because he won several challenges early on (you know, the one the judges gave him win on). As far as Carla not liking her own dishes early on....didn't Stefan say that about a couple of his own? Not that it matters. He could say over and over again how great he thinks his dish is, it doesn't necessarily make it true. And I'd say of the 4 left isn't Carla as accomplished as any of them? What does one consider "accomplished"?
Drew B		#2595	[-]
Posts: 4340 (02/16/09 7:55 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	I don't know who is more "accomplished" - I haven't compared their resumes. I'm just going by what they've cooked on the show. Everybody (Carla included) seems to think he's a more likely winner than her. The only one who maybe DIDN'T think Stefan was the best was Bleah. Somehow, that delusional bitch thought that SHE was the best!
seaguy		#2596	[-]
Posts: 14317 (02/16/09 8:01 PM) AI Forum Moderator Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Exactly and from what they've cooked on the show, the judges have told us Stefan was the winner several times. But who knows. As far as this other person you are speaking of, must have been a season I didn't watch.
LoveNHaight		#2597	[-]
Posts: 117 (02/16/09 11:37 PM) I don't get most of the jokes Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Fabio is my "friend" on FaceBook and he just updated his status (something he rarely does) : What could this mean? Fabio Viviani is going to New York till the 22nd of February.
seaguy		#2598	[-]
Posts: 14328 (02/16/09 11:43 PM) AI Forum Moderator Reply Quote More Recent Posts	I think it means he's going to NY until Feb 22nd.
tdugan333		#2599	[-]
Posts: 9769 (02/16/09 11:52 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	I love you seaguy! As for Carla it's been made pretty clear by the judges AND her resume that she has some serious culinary chops. She's been classically trained correct? I thought her idea for the green eggs and ham was fucking spot on for Dufrey. He's crazy about concepts and he loves eggs. She kept it simple and kicked all their asses. Plus she moseyed around the kitchen whilst kicking their asses which drove them all bonkers. Hooty hoo love, but I still hope Fabio wins.
CoconutPhone		#2600	[-]
Posts: 15854 (02/17/09 12:18 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	I can't see Stefan not winning. He'd have to spectacularly fail to lose and tit's not that the others are bad I just don't think it's really that close.

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

TOP CHEF 5 NY--It's not Top Chef, it's Top Pussy!

Fabio Viviani is going to New York till the 22nd of February.