Yuku free message boards

Scott MacIntyre.

Wild Angels by Martina McBride.

What is he doing a woman's song for? Does he want to get booted? Even Randy says "it wasn't quite right" in the vidclip. On the baby grand piano, he starts with a nice phrase until he misses the bottom notes. But whose bottom range is good, anyway? We're used to missed low notes on this show; they're obligatory. He brings some dynamic effect to the title line, with the needed emotion. But the rest of it is, perhaps, headed for boresville. Whoa, there he goes putting it into a higher gear, missing some falsetto up top, but doing enough to maybe squeak through to the tour. It must suck to be Matt Giraud right about now.

A 6.

Crowd: IEEEE!!!
Paula: Scott. Scott. To me tonight was another impressive, lovely performance. You work harder than most on that stage. But the piano may be a bit of a crutch now. It separates you from the audience. People need to see you as a showman.
Scott: We can move it closer.
Paula: I want you to mix it up a little bit.
Simon (making sense?): Paula, what do you expect him to do? You're being disrespectful. Nothing wrong with being behind the piano. Elton John did that. If that's what you want.
Paula: So did Billy Joel.
Simon: Take Paula's advice, don't play the piano. I don't think it has anything to do with the piano. Both performances, last and this week, very similar. I don't think you're good enough songs.
Scott: I've also lost a lot of hat picks, by the way. But no one expected me to sing a Martina McBride song.
Simon: Your songs are going over my head.
Paula: That's disrespectful!
Randy: For me, not so much the songs, but I'm looking for the vocals. Last week and this, just kinda nice.
Simon: Safe.
Randy: This is a singing competition.
Kara: Up your game. Wow us. Go for those high notes.
Simon: Just choose better songs.
Kara: You bring class and poise.
Paula: Yes you do!