GrenadeJumper85 wrote:
Vicarious wrote:
After that final tribal council question and answer performance, i wonder if he could have beat Amanda?
![]()
![]()
![]()
So true. Maybe they both would lose.
dreamz wins, 7-0-0.
| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
WTFscissoring8 |
|||
GrenadeJumper85 wrote: dreamz wins, 7-0-0. |
|||
JLK Name |
|||
|
S15- Amanda
S17- Sugar S18- Stephen = All Stars 2.0 (except Amanda bcos of FvF) |
|||
Screerider |
|||
|
My working theory going into the Final Immunity Challenge was:
|
|||
Survivor Boy |
|||
|
Sad that even Katie got a vote.
But then again, she wasn't a jew. |
|||
shoeless rye |
|||
|
I wasn't an Erinn fan all season, however I found myself hoping she'd get to the jury. I wanted to see Jalapao eat their own, it would have sort of
been poetic to see Timbira get decimated by the smaller Jalapao and then the remaining Timbira beat the 3 vs 1 odds to win the game.
I think there is a chance Erinn could have won with that argument. She played the odds, figuring fourth was better than 6th to explain her switch to Jalapao 3, and then weaseled her way into the F2 by exploiting the same divisions that doomed Timbira at the merge. I think it would have been a close vote, even if the jurors didn't like her. Hell she could explain that away saying she had to be annoying/disliked so the F3 immunity winner would think she was easily beatable and that she'd be seen as a goat and kept around rather than a threat. Her UTR/Goat strategy could be defended as saying she was always the odd person out, never had an alliance and was always lowest on the totem pole and thus could never make power plays but had to react and maneuver behind the scenes. |
|||
jenni007 |
|||
|
It would've been close.Stephen,for all of his education,did not argue a good case for himself and when he did speak.....he came off as not owning up to his
role in the game.Maybe he would've been more comfortable if he did go against Erinn.On the other hand,this is the same guy who looked as if he was gonna
pass out when he got a vote earlier.
|
|||
EPR2012 |
|||
Survivor Boy wrote: Tom wasnt as charming as JT... |
|||
Kirblar |
|||
|
Erinn would have come down her FTC performance, but she had one hell of an argument to make, and I think this is a scenario where we'll really never know
the answer.
|
|||