Justin "Milk Carton" Guarini
Clay "I am your father and your mother." Aiken
Diana "Waiting for Hee-Haw revival" Degarmo
Bo "F- Daughtry" Bice
Kat McPhee
Blake "Who?" Lewis
David "Daddy - that HURTS!" Archuleta
"Just" Adam
| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
For Petes Sake |
You knew it would be next: Rank the 2nd place finishers... |
Lead | |
|
In terms of sales, hotness, most likely to serve you fries at McD, Whatevia
Justin "Milk Carton" Guarini Clay "I am your father and your mother." Aiken Diana "Waiting for Hee-Haw revival" Degarmo Bo "F- Daughtry" Bice Kat McPhee Blake "Who?" Lewis David "Daddy - that HURTS!" Archuleta "Just" Adam |
|||
americanidolfan4life |
|||
|
1. Diana
2. Adam 3. Katharine 4. Clay 5. Blake 6. David 7. Bo 8. Justin Meh. ETA: Not a big fan of most of them, but I really only like half of the winners. o_o
Last Edited By: americanidolfan4life
05/23/09 8:10 PM.
Edited 1 times.
|
|||
JasonSiskaLulz |
|||
|
1. Katharine
2. Bo 3. Blake 4. David 5. Diana 6. Adam 7. Justin 8. Clay i hate almost all of them tho : / |
|||
Spanky Hot Dog |
|||
|
1. Adam
2. Blake 3. Bo 4. David 5. Diana 6. Justin 7. Katharine 8. Clay |
|||
LeeLeeRaRa |
|||
|
Are you kidding?
1. ADAM The rest are high school musical tryout rejects. |
|||
dashbrdparadise |
|||
|
1. Adam
In retrospect I don't know why I wanted Fantasia to win, but I was like 12 so whatever. |
|||
Will |
|||
|
Would buy their album if they had something good
1. Justin 2. Bo Eh 3-5. Adam/Katherine/Clay 6.Diana Vocals are completely incompatible with my tastes and the tards need to DIAF. 7.David DIAF YOU SPOT STEALING SPITTING TOOL! 8.Blake |
|||
sadllama |
|||
|
1. Diana
2. Adam 3. Bo 4. Blake 5. Clay 6. David 7. Katherine 8. Justin I really only like the first two though. |
|||
Miss Alley Shack |
|||
|
1. Bo
2. Adam 3. Archie 4. Diana 5. Katharine 6. Clay 7. Justin 8. Blake |
|||
SardonicallyIrrelevant |
|||
|
1. Adam
2. Clay (just on vocal ability, don't take this to mean I like him outside of a 30 Rock episode) 3. Bo 4. Blake 5. Diana 6. Devil Child 7. Katharine 8. Justin |
|||
mom2jdbe |
|||
|
1. Adam
2. Katharine 3. David 4. Clay 5-8. Diana, Blake, Bo, Justin (in no particular order) |
|||
Charming Nemesis |
|||
|
1. Bo
2. Clay 3. Katherine 4. Diana 5. David 6. Justin 7. Blake 8. Adam |
|||
eraserhead19 |
|||
|
1. ADAM
2. Kat 3. Bo 4. Justin 5. Diana 6. Clay 7. Pork Chop 8. Blake |
|||
taks |
|||
|
1. Adam - Amazing
2. Archie - ... sue me, I liked him 3. Kat - I think I like her more just because she was against Taylor 4. Blake - Meh 5. Bo 6. Diana 7. Clay - Dislike 8. Justin - Hate |
|||
highwind44029 |
|||
|
1. Katharine McPhee (hottest runner up ever)
2. Adam Lambert 3. Diana DeGarmo 4. Bo Bice 5. Blake Lewis 6. David Archuleta 7. Clay Aiken 8. Justin Guarini |
|||
PhantomPlanetQueen |
|||
|
1. Adam Lambert
2. Blake Lewis 3. David Archuleta 4. Kat Pee 5. Diana Degarmo 6. Bo Bice 7. Clay Aiken 8. Justin Guarini What a crappy bunch. The only one I genuinely like is Adam. I did love Blake during his season, but I don`t care about him anymore. Archie is kinda adorable sometimes, but his music sucks. |
|||
dashbrdparadise |
|||
|
Seriously, I never realized how terrible the lineup of runners-up looked. I guess the talented ones come in 4th 3rd and 1st.
|
|||
Gawkamoley |
|||
|
In terms of performance ability:
1. Adam 2. Kat 3. Archie 4. Clay 5. Bo 6. Blake 7. Diana 8. Justin In terms of appeal: 1. Adam 2. Kat 3. Bo 4. Blake 5. Archie 6. Diana 7. Justin 8. Clay |
|||
Tony48 |
|||
|
God, such sucky runner-ups. Diana, Katharine, Justin, Blake.....
While I care for NONE of them, I'll make a list anyway: 1. Clay Aiken 2. Adam Lambert 3. David Archuleta 4. Bo Bice 5. Katharine McPhee 6. Diana DeGarmo 7. Justin Guarini 8. Blake Lewis |
|||
Nods |
|||
|
1. Bo Bice
2. Adam Lambert 3. Katharine McPhee 4. Clay Aiken 5. Blake Lewis 6. Diana DeGarmo 7. Justin Guarini 8. David Archuleta |
|||
ANDand19 |
|||
|
Wow, the runner ups suck. I believe Diana and Kat were the only ones I wanted to win, and Adam I was indifferent.
1. Bo Bice 2. Katharine McPhee 3. Adam Lambert 4. Diana DeGarmo 5. Blake Lewis 6. Clay Aiken 7. Justin Guarini 8. David Archuleta |
|||