Paris Hilton wrote:
Are Sydney fans the most annoying people ever? I think so. She shouldnt still be in this.
She shoulda been indignant about not voting out Spencer.
| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
goohst |
|||
Paris Hilton wrote: She shoulda been indignant about not voting out Spencer. |
|||
kenc333 |
|||
Paris Hilton wrote:Erinn fans are worse, but at least Erinn did something. Sydney fans like to rewrite the storyline. Debbie fans are pretty obsessed too, but at least that stays contained in the Merhag love thread. I don't think there's a definitive strategy that works every season. Everything is conditional depending on the season, depending on the situations with the people and the twists. So for example, Sandra did what was required in the Pearl Islands scenario to win, but she woulda been cut early in Fiji. If placements are close (like JT and Stephen), then it can be debatable, but when the difference is like 7th vs. 11th, then looks like Sierra played better than Sydney, given the situation. |
|||
tomash |
|||
Sikenc333 wrote:Sierra's tribe only had to go to 2 tribal councils before the merge though, while Sydney had to go to tribal council 4 times before the merge. If those had been reversed, Sierra would have been a premerge boot while Sydney could have gone far. Not saying Sydney played a great game or anything, but Sierra had more luck. |
|||
goohst |
|||
tomash wrote: If Timbira goes to tribal x4, Sierra may survive. Erinn would be gone for sure. Having been to exile makes Sierra all the more important, and Brendan may have been able to swing Tyson or Debbie to nail Coach. Doesn't really speak to Sierra's game, but she may have been dragged anyways |
|||
kenc333 |
|||
|
Well Sierra also had two people ahead of her on the chopping block on Timbira. Erinn was slated to go next and then Brendan because of his intertribe
relations. In Tyson's boot episode, Coach even admits that Sierra would've been there longer than Erinn had she/Brendan not voted Coach.
|
|||
goohst |
|||
kenc333 wrote: Regardless, she made an incredibly stupid move at 7. She deserves no higher than her spot. |
|||
JackSparrowBauer |
|||
|
Sierra fans are by far the worst. Some Erinn fanns are pretty bad, but there is some truth to what they claim. Sierra played a horrendous game all around.
|
|||
Paris Hilton |
|||
|
I agree Sierra had horible game. But I still like her a lot. Sierra fans admit she didnt play that great. Sydney and Erinn fans dont.
|
|||
JackSparrowBauer |
|||
|
Erinn didn't play a horrible game. She is by no means a mastermind, but props to her for worming her way into the Final 3 when she was originally on the
outs of Timbira.
Sydney didn't play a good game, but it's fun to pretend she did <3 Sierra sucks. |
|||
spnintendo |
|||
kenc333 wrote:Yeah if Timbira went to one more pre-merge TC right before the merge, then they probably would have booted Brendan which would have been a travesty and made Tocantins the worst.season.ever. Oh right....um, Sierra indifference. |
|||
Mikester |
|||
|
Most Syndey fans admit that they like her mostly because she's amazingly hot. Sierra sucks all around, so just deal with it and stop trying to make it about Sydney. |
|||
tacobellcanon |
|||
|
If we're judging Sierra and Sydney in terms of the "I'm hot" strategy, then Sydney definitely wins.
|
|||
SurvivorFanGP |
|||
|
I actually like Sierra and don't get the "Sierra sux" comments.
Wut? Oh, hey. ^_^ |
|||
Mikester |
|||
tacobellcanon wrote:Sierra didn't have an "I'm hot" strategy because she's not hot, so clearly Sydney wins. Sydney also had a better personality. Sydney wasn't really that good of a player but she survived the same number of Tribal Councils that Sierra did and voted on the right side of all three of them. So Sierra and her fans can suck it kthnx. eta: But not GP because <33 |
|||
SurvivorFanGP |
|||
|
Mikester <33
IF MY DREAM BRENDAN/COACH/TAJ F3 WASN'T GONNA HAPPEN THEN SIERRA FTW DURNIT D= |
|||
kishuu |
|||
|
Um... I'm not a Sydney fan jsyk, I just think she played pretty well considering that's how a female survives pre-merge, flirt and go under the radar.
|
|||
kishuu |
|||
|
8. Sydney (Jalapao, 11th)
Probably the most controversial placing yet, judging from everybody's opinions. Sydney was a woodland g0ddess according to Stephen and in the recap episode, we were shown scenes of her posing a threat to Stephen and he being somewhat intimidated by her. To scare someone like Stephen, who pretty much was relatively calm and composed the rest of the game, she must be doing something right. On the tribe, she was second closest to JT and I think that ultimately paid off, leading her to survive a whooping 3 tribal councils considering she was the weakest in the tribe physically. She couldn't help the fact that Joe was a dud and told her that if she didn't vote out Stephen, she'd be gone. Um... Of course she'd vote him out, considering she was a boot target the previous tribal already. She played up the flirt card well too, she had Joe as an ally and could use him as a shield in the possible merge. JT would be second closest to her (he became close to Taj post-merge) and yanno, she got screwed considering how many alpha males her tribe had, they lost 3 straight immunities, leading to her departure. I'm sure she gets a lot of flack but she didn't make any mistakes with her game except that she was weak physically, which she couldn't help. Majority alliance? Check. Can't fault her for her alliance mate wanting to screw over another alliance mate. Flirt card? Played it well with JT and Joe. Threat? Socially, yes, a huge threat to Stephen/Taj/Sandy especially since she was getting along well with JT, she could do lots of stuff around camp. She got screwed with her tribe going on a losing streak so =(. Ohwells, she is the highest pre-merge boot because unlike previous pre-merge boots, she didn't fuck up her own game. She was in better with JT and that would put her in a good position but Joe screwing Spencer and telling her to vote for him or get voted out was a mistake. 7. Brendan (Timbira, 9th) ![]() Omg, it's Brendan! What a shocker. HE LOOKS FUG OUTSIDE OF THE SHOW, NEVER SHAVE YOUR BEARD AGAIN BRENDAN YOU ASS. Okay, let's continue. Brendan played well tbh. However, he fucked up closer to merge by blatantly telling the whole tribe (or well, pretty much openly waved a flag that said 'HEY GAIS I'M BONDING WITH THE OTHER TRIBE'). He made a good choice with making the Exile Alliance but he totally fucked up at the merge by pretty much turning into a Sugar. He had a good social game and was a huge physical threat. I have nothing much to say about him other than that since he ended up trying to play like Sugar so no, this is as high as he gets since he didn't fuck up as much as Sierra or something. Still Remaining JT Stephen Erinn Taj Debbie Tyson |
|||
kishuu |
|||
goohst wrote: Erinn wouldn't be gone since the tribe started a Brendan attack. They were going to knock off Brendan then Sierra for being his ally then Erinn. It's a toss up between Erinn and Sierra but I likely think Sierra would be gone since she was such a wildcard and was Brendan's ally too. |
|||
tacobellcanon |
|||
kishuu wrote:YOU SPEAK THE TRUTH |
|||
spnintendo |
|||
|
Lucky number 7 <3 <3 <3
Actually getting seventh BrendanGod ^_^ |
|||