ETA: I included Beth and Katherine in that "who's that" list, but Beth has had more screen time now and Katherine was a prominent character in episode 6.
| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
Tom2433 |
|||
|
Unless the killer turns out to be Nikki or Maggie (or possibly Shane) - who have definitely gotten the least screen time - I don't really think ANY other
character would illicit the reaction of "who's that?" But I really think the average person who has watched this show from the beginning would
know who all the suspects are by the end of the season, so I'm really confused about the "who's that" comment. Maybe it was just meant to
throw us off..?
ETA: I included Beth and Katherine in that "who's that" list, but Beth has had more screen time now and Katherine was a prominent character in episode 6. |
|||
Drew B |
|||
Tom2433 wrote: That's assuming the killer is one of the 25. They could pull a fast one and have it be somebody we don't know yet or have barely seen at all (e.g. the gardener or the cabbie). |
|||
Tom2433 |
|||
|
I really think it is one of the 25... they wouldn't label the 25 characters as "suspects" if one of them wasn't the killer, and like someone
said before, all the advertisements said something along the lines of "25 suspects... 1 killer among them". Logical thinking says that the killer is
one of those 25.
|
|||
Drew B |
|||
Tom2433 wrote: I hope you're right, but I wouldn't count on it. The producers create the show, and then it is handed off to the network publicity department to market however they see fit. The "25 suspects" paradigm is part of the marketing campaign and not part of the show itself. I've seen some pretty misleading campaigns before ("The Family Stone" being marketed as a comedy, for one), and this could be another of them... |
|||
mundo446 |
|||
|
You know what? I want Danny to survive just to give the black guys a break. Having the black survive would shock me more then any other twist, it just never
happens.
|
|||
Tom2433 |
|||
|
I really hope you're wrong about the killer being just some random person. I feel like that would kind of be an insult to the viewers. And considering this
show is only gonna be one season, I would really hope the writers and producers wouldn't string us along to believe the killer was one of the 25 characters
billed as "suspects" and then all of a sudden make the killer be some totally random, irrelevant person.
|
|||
KatelynTsar |
|||
Que wrote:Dun dun dun! |
|||
KatelynTsar |
|||
Tom2433 wrote:I'm going with that it will be one of the 25 "suspects". One thing I'm not sure with is that I heard that there will be at least one person dieing each episode, does that mean they'll be knocking off the suspects or just a random killing like the priest? |
|||
Understandermant |
|||
|
I just realized this wedding doesnt have a ring bearer.
|
|||
loveski |
|||
|
I just read the writers' blog here. I
want to see the alternate version of the FatGuy's death now!
|
|||
GoHomeAndEatYoRice |
|||
|
Little Creppy Girls > Little Boy
ETA: <3 FatGuy Burned Body<3 |
|||
Fcuk You ywia |
|||
Annoying Tool Fanboy wrote: THANK YOU. This show is not that intelligent. People saying "anyone with an airtight alibi is out" are clearly not aware that the editors leave out huge pieces of the plot, and are not thinking that much about how things work on this show. |
|||
cabanachat |
|||
loveski wrote:Fan of grease fires, are you? |
|||
Coachocd |
|||
|
Again, the killer on Harper's Island is the same one on Harper's Globe.
I hope we see more of Robin Matthews. I expect BOTH her and Abby to survive in the end. |
|||
Fluffynurse |
|||
|
I can't watch the videos on Harper's Globe since I'm on dial-up. Is the killer killing different people there? Who is Cheshire Cat?
|
|||
Fitfcuk |
|||
Understandermant wrote: Wow, that took some insight. Did you realize that there is not going to be a fucking wedding yet? |
|||
dennydoylelives |
|||
Understandermant wrote:It could mean that the producer, (or whoever it was that made the comment), thinks that 1/3 of the people in the audience are total morons. |
|||
wrsrules |
|||
|
Yeah it is kind of insulting that they would think 1/3 of the audiance would not know who one of the 25 suspects are, it is just crazy, by now I would think
anyone watching ever week trying to solve the mystery knows who all the suspects are.
|
|||
XtremeInnovator420 |
|||
|
I think Malcolm was the uh....what, 9th victim? I'm not sure if he was 9th or 8th, but I'm pretty sure the victim tally hasn't hit double digits
yet.
|
|||
wrsrules |
|||
|
I think Malcom is the 10th
Cousin ben Uncle marty Priest Kelly Lucy Hunter Booth Mr. Wellington Richard Malcom but, priest and cousin Ben are not included the 25 suspects |
|||