| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
Screerider |
|||
|
And what about the horrible singers you have to watch 3 times.... and they make it to the Top 12! And then you have to listen to them every week after that!
Until he, Taylor Hicks, wins! Aaaauuuuuggggghhhhh!!!!
|
|||
Drew B |
|||
|
I feel your pain, brother. The only solace is in knowing that in that season, nearly anybody else winning would have been equally horrendous...
|
|||
eraserhead19 |
|||
Screerider wrote: or what about Sanjaya? there is no way in hell he would've made it past the group rounds to make the top 12 IMO.... Group rounds I believe started in season 4 and I hated that format from then on. I don't think they should separate the guys and girls out...I think the top 12 should be comprised of the 12 BEST singers, regardless of gender... the equality bullshit is just lame. |
|||
Drew B |
|||
eraserhead19 wrote: If they had the rule they had this year where a guy had to make it through from each group, he very well may have. The guys that year were REALLY bleak and Sanjaya was well-liked early on... |
|||
Sheri |
|||
Drew B wrote: That's one of the problems with either requiring 6 guys and 6 girls for the final 12 OR for making sure at least 1 guy and 1 girl from each girl gets through. |
|||
eraserhead19 |
|||
Drew B wrote: it seemed to me the guys were better this year and the girls had a harder time getting through but i do see what you're saying. Either way, I think they should totally do away with all that bullshit and just put the top vote getters through regardless of gender. If there is an all male/female top 12 so what... at least we get the people who the audience wanted. |
|||
Drew B |
|||
|
The guys this year WERE better. The girls were better in season 6 when Sanjaya was on the show...
|
|||
Miraclemax |
|||
|
This is what they should do. First of all don't put people that suck and make us want to stab our ears out into the top 24 to begin with.
Top 24 format: week 1: 12 girls perform, 12 guys perform, 2 people from each group get voted though. week 2: mix the groups up, 10 perform one night, the remaining 10 perform the next night. 4 more go through week 3: mix the groups up again, 8 perform each night, the last 4 get through. That way you have to be on top of your game to get voted through, but you get 3 chances. Think of the 2nd and 3rd rounds as Wildcard rounds. The worst gender split that can happen is 10:2. You can't get sick of all the contestants because the first 4 that get voted through you won't hear again until the finales, and the next 4 won't perform on the 3rd week either. Taylor would've made it with either format and so would Kris. |
|||
bradwalk |
|||
|
You people act like a female has no chance on AI. 4 of the 8 winners have been female and 5 of the 8 finales have had at least one girl, (6 if you count
Clay). America has no problem voting for GOOD females. The producers just need to do a better job in picking the finalists.
|
|||
smileyriley14 |
|||
|
How about this:
|
|||