Harper's Island--Decent Summer Slasher

0 Kudo

Started By	Comment
Miles Edgeworth		#4801	[-]
Posts: 1745 (06/28/09 3:46 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Danny has shown an uncanny ability to survive despite doing stupid shit. perhaps there is a reason for his confidence
myopics		#4802	[-]
Posts: 791 (06/28/09 4:05 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Miles Edgeworth wrote: Danny has shown an uncanny ability to survive despite doing stupid shit. perhaps there is a reason for his confidence :omarosa?
Miles Edgeworth		#4803	[-]
Posts: 1746 (06/28/09 4:09 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Now thats just silly. Whay would omarosa give him confidence?
Mystery Buff		#4804	[-]
Posts: 72 (06/28/09 5:16 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	AmightyRo wrote: BTW...Did anybody think maybe Wakefield didn't string Shane up, but instead it was his accomplice (Jimmy would make sense). Definitely.
Mystery Buff		#4805	[-]
Posts: 73 (06/28/09 6:06 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	MrMax34 wrote: Has anybody noticed that when Sully and Danny are in the Candlewick to "seal off" the tunnel, and they have already shot thru the door.... then something/somebody poked back thru from the tunnel side. I think a lot of people have assumed that it was Wakefield's giant knife poking through. But on rewatching, it is not a knife. It doesn't even appear to be a gun. I think it was a pipe. Unless Jimmy snuck there while Trish was asleep, there might still be somebody else still on the island! I also noticed that when Henry, Abby, and Cal were first going through their tunnel, that there was a convenient shovel by the passage they went through. Just another thought: Isn't the plane that the deputies brought still in the harbor, or did it get blown up in the explosion? "Second" killer could get off the island this way.
myopics		#4806	[-]
Posts: 792 (06/28/09 6:12 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Miles Edgeworth wrote: Now thats just silly. Whay would omarosa give him confidence? Cuz that ain't no superpower he's got coasting by despite doing stupid things. He's just surviving cuz he's the token black guy.
pinoyako		#4807	[-]
Posts: 8914 (06/28/09 7:40 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Kitty Pryde1 wrote: Can someone make me an avatar of Chloe's fall? yw! Chloe did the right thing. If he fought with Cal, she would've been stabbed and I cannot imagine her being killed brutally.
PinotEnvy		#4808	[-]
Posts: 1905 (06/28/09 7:52 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I read all the spoilers, so I knew my faves of this show Cal/Chloe were going to die. The only solace I have is that they had the overall best death scene and the acting of these two puts everyone else in this show to shame, especially Abby/Henry. Jimmy is 100% a red herring. No doubt about it. I wonder what he was in prison for, though? My "out on a limb" guess is that (seeing how the sheriff loved Jimmy so much) maybe Jimmy's stint in prison was a total setup by the sheriff to get Jimmy in the prison and close to Wakefield in order to get info from Wakefield or perhaps attempt to kill Wakefiled while he was in prison? This would at least make Jimmy an interesting character. I'm still sticking with my original guess that Henry is the killer and I just want to hurry up and get to the reasons and the hows already. Only some loser like Henry would think some lameass bitch like Abby is worth killing for. I'm sorry, but Abby is the worst and not at all a likeable heroin for me. And the worst possible scenario would be for Chloe to still be alive and end up with that loser Sully. Blech. Chloe can only live if she is with Cal, end of story. Cal is dead, thus Chloe is dead, and they are together forever in their afterlife. Chloe/Cal angel <3<3<3<3<3
tullfan2		#4809	[-]
Posts: 3529 (06/28/09 8:14 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	MrMax34 wrote: Has anybody noticed that when Sully and Danny are in the Candlewick to "seal off" the tunnel, and they have already shot thru the door.... then something/somebody poked back thru from the tunnel side. I think a lot of people have assumed that it was Wakefield's giant knife poking through. But on rewatching, it is not a knife. It doesn't even appear to be a gun. I think it was a pipe. Unless Jimmy snuck there while Trish was asleep, there might still be somebody else still on the island! Thanks for reminding me of that. I noticed that while I was watching. Wakefield was at the sewage drain with Chloe before that scene happened and then he was back at the sewage drain right after that scene happened. I don't see any reason why we would have gone back through the tunnels leading to the Candlewick pantry. You never know with this show though. I continue to be a Jimmy is the killer supporter. As supported by the picture of herself that Abby found taped to the sun visor in Wakefield's truck, Wakefield believes that Abby is his daughter. I don't think there is any other Wakefield child. Jimmy was supposed to still be at the Cannery after Trish escaped so why didn't Wakefield kill hm? It doesn't make any sense that Henry would be Wakefield's accomplice when he put in effort to help Abby dig up Wakefield's coffin to find out if Wakefield was dead or not. Jimmy has been totally emotionally detached from the murders. You never see him being frightened like everyone else has at one time or another. In the preview, Wakefield says to someone, "She's getting away!". That indicates that Wakefield is still alive when the second killer is revealed. Last Edited By: tullfan2 06/28/09 8:23 AM. Edited 1 times.
Aitu4fan27		#4810	[-]
Posts: 270 (06/28/09 8:17 AM) OMEDETO, CATHY!! Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	PinotEnvy wrote: I read all the spoilers, so I knew my faves of this show Cal/Chloe were going to die. The only solace I have is that they had the overall best death scene and the acting of these two puts everyone else in this show to shame, especially Abby/Henry. Jimmy is 100% a red herring. No doubt about it. I wonder what he was in prison for, though? My "out on a limb" guess is that (seeing how the sheriff loved Jimmy so much) maybe Jimmy's stint in prison was a total setup by the sheriff to get Jimmy in the prison and close to Wakefield in order to get info from Wakefield or perhaps attempt to kill Wakefiled while he was in prison? This would at least make Jimmy an interesting character. I'm still sticking with my original guess that Henry is the killer and I just want to hurry up and get to the reasons and the hows already. Only some loser like Henry would think some lameass bitch like Abby is worth killing for. I'm sorry, but Abby is the worst and not at all a likeable heroin for me. And the worst possible scenario would be for Chloe to still be alive and end up with that loser Sully. Blech. Chloe can only live if she is with Cal, end of story. Cal is dead, thus Chloe is dead, and they are together forever in their afterlife. Chloe/Cal angel <3<3<3<3<3 It would make sense if Henry was the killer for a few reasons: He stopped Abby from chasing after and possibly killing wakefield (Henry could be hiding behind the whole it's Wakefield thing and if Wakefield is killed and another person dies then he becomes a target. Also, none of the groomsman have died except for 2. Booth was an accidental death and Malcom's death could have beeen revenge from Henry for what happened to Booth if he holds him responsible. How else could Danny and Sully survive so long?
The Purple Parrot		#4811	[-]
Posts: 10623 (06/28/09 8:25 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Trish's chase scene looks EPIC!!!!! I just hope she survives it.
Regardless		#4812	[-]
Posts: 158 (06/28/09 8:35 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	This whole Wakefield is alive and killing is a total letdown in regards to this show. It's no longer the mystery that this show was setting things up to be. Wakefield being responsible for the deaths of the shows two most interesting characters totally steals the thunder from the person on the bingo card of death who may also be doing some killings. Thank you Katy for catching up the bingo card of death. I so appreciate it!
mundo446		#4813	[-]
Posts: 1376 (06/28/09 8:36 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	If the final four is really Abby, Henry, Trish, and Jimmy, then that is the most horrible, predictable final four they could have possible had. What a great idea, lets have the four main characters be the ones at the end, no one would see it coming! Assholes. Heres hoping Sully and/or Danny survive too. Last Edited By: mundo446 06/28/09 5:15 PM. Edited 1 times.
Que		#4814	[-]
Posts: 1430 (06/28/09 9:22 AM) MESS member Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Who was it who had the idea about the wedding of the dead? Where Trish is forced to go to down to the Church and the dead bodies are all there? That was me! lol. right after the show became a B grade slasher. JIMMY.... red Herring. As others have said the Sheriff made a point of telling Abby that he was a good kid and they belonged together etc... He knew about his "past" and why he was in jail. He probably arreseted him. They became friends. IF...Henry is wakefields kid.......... Then the whole murder everyone reason could be...when asked "WHY?" By Trish, He anwsers... "YOU DIDN'T INVITE ME TO THE WEEDING! NOW get that damn dress on and lets get to the church...I CAME TO SEE A WEDDING." BUT...I still think Abby is wakefields kid. and Wakefiled is the lone killer. Just a f'ed up physcho who loves to kill a loved one and leave the other alive to suffer. (that's why he wasn't going to kill Chole) In the END... ABBY and Jimmy will be together and leaving the Island and she will say...."I AM NEVER COMMING BACK to this damn Island!" The SAME taxi driver is at the marina.. "ENJOY your STAY?" (Trish,Shea and MAdison also survive)
JoshCflyring		#4815	[-]
Posts: 846 (06/28/09 9:26 AM) "Jay Leno is funny" Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I think he was going to kill Chloe.
bumlets1		#4816	[-]
Posts: 1457 (06/28/09 9:34 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I have no freaking idea who the killer is, I was all about Maggie- not su much. Then I was convinced Nikki was brought back to be the killer- not so much. I give up. The only ones I don't suspect at all are Sully and Danny, so it's probably one of them. I suck at this.
DoYouHaveToes		#4817	[-]
Posts: 264 (06/28/09 9:34 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Que wrote: Who was it who had the idea about the wedding of the dead? Where Trish is forced to go to down to the Church and the dead bodies are all there? That was me! lol. right after the show became a B grade slasher. JIMMY.... red Herring. As others have said the Sheriff made a point of telling Abby that he was a good kid and they belonged together etc... He knew about his "past" and why he was in jail. He probably arreseted him. They became friends. IF...Henry is wakefields kid.......... Then the whole murder everyone reason could be...when asked "WHY?" By Trish, He anwsers... "YOU DIDN'T INVITE ME TO THE WEEDING! NOW get that damn dress on and lets get to the church...I CAME TO SEE A WEDDING." BUT...I still think Abby is wakefields kid. and Wakefiled is the lone killer. Just a f'ed up physcho who loves to kill a loved one and leave the other alive to suffer. (that's why he wasn't going to kill Chole) In the END... ABBY and Jimmy will be together and leaving the Island and she will say...."I AM NEVER COMMING BACK to this damn Island!" The SAME taxi driver is at the marina.. "ENJOY your STAY?" (Trish,Shea and MAdison also survive) x 10000
Regardless		#4818	[-]
Posts: 159 (06/28/09 9:38 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Zeep wrote: I feel like this show is now a completely different one from the one that premiered in April. Like, different writers, different plot lines and different scenery. Big red X of agreement. The more I think about last nights episode, the less I like this series which was not all that great to begin with. Having Wakefield, who came out of nowhere alive and well, kill off favorite characters/be responsible for their deaths so late in the game truly altered this shows dynamic, and not in a good way. If Trish is the only survivor when this show is all said and done, I will feel like this was a huge waste of time. If Jimmy is the killer instead of Henry or Trish, this show will compound my existing frustrations ten-fold. Last Edited By: Regardless 06/28/09 9:44 AM. Edited 1 times.
Regardless		#4819	[-]
Posts: 160 (06/28/09 9:49 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Vinsincere wrote: Henry: He did it. And the motive is banal. We know he's a crack shot and let his father-in-law beat him at skeet on purpose, but he can't even wing a mass murderer to protect his fiancee and his mistress? "We should split up."? That's all a lot of crap, though. It was Wakefield, and to the extent anyone helped him, it was to help Wakefield. Man, what a turd. Totally forgot about Jimmy's sharp shooting abilities! The dude so could have nailed Wakefield at several points throughout the episode. Henry so has to be the killer! And by killer, we now mean "Wakefield's helper." Lame that we're trying to figure out who Wakefield's helper is, and not who the killer is.
Dan Down Under		#4820	[-]
Posts: 5052 (06/28/09 9:54 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Que wrote: Who was it who had the idea about the wedding of the dead? Where Trish is forced to go to down to the Church and the dead bodies are all there? That was me! lol. right after the show became a B grade slasher. JIMMY.... red Herring. As others have said the Sheriff made a point of telling Abby that he was a good kid and they belonged together etc... He knew about his "past" and why he was in jail. He probably arreseted him. They became friends. IF...Henry is wakefields kid.......... Then the whole murder everyone reason could be...when asked "WHY?" By Trish, He anwsers... "YOU DIDN'T INVITE ME TO THE WEEDING! NOW get that damn dress on and lets get to the church...I CAME TO SEE A WEDDING." BUT...I still think Abby is wakefields kid. and Wakefiled is the lone killer. Just a f'ed up physcho who loves to kill a loved one and leave the other alive to suffer. (that's why he wasn't going to kill Chole) In the END... ABBY and Jimmy will be together and leaving the Island and she will say...."I AM NEVER COMMING BACK to this damn Island!" The SAME taxi driver is at the marina.. "ENJOY your STAY?" Abby: It was KILLER olololololol xinfinite. (Trish,Shea and MAdison also survive) Fixed. The sad thing is that the writers are so retarded that that's what'll probably happen.

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

Harper's Island--Decent Summer Slasher

Quick Reply