Survivor 20: Heroes vs Villains

0 Kudos

Started By	Comment
WylDawg		#281	[-]
Posts: 18778 (07/16/09 12:13 PM) Registered user More Recent Posts	Sandra was Rupert's closest ally. She could molest little kids and CBS would still consider her a hero. Case closed.
ChiSoxx		#282	[-]
Posts: 2 (07/16/09 12:45 PM) More Recent Posts	Darrah from Pearl Islands
tullfan2		#283	[-]
Posts: 3592 (07/16/09 3:12 PM) Registered User More Recent Posts	WylDawg wrote: Sandra was Rupert's closest ally. She could molest little kids and CBS would still consider her a hero. Case closed. She doesn't fit the part though. On a casting basis she is similar to Courtney Yates with her sassy mouth and her being useless in challenges. She would be better off on the villains tribe because the heroes would immediately target her because of her lack of physical prowess. I doubt that casting would want her on the same tribe with Rupert again. She would be more entertaining fighting with JFP on the villains tribe.
yutun		#284	[-]
Posts: 3 (07/16/09 5:57 PM) More Recent Posts	what about Rafe from Guatemala??? i can't believe that they choose ignore this great season
Cyberball2072		#285	[-]
Posts: 422 (07/16/09 7:24 PM) I love ShiiAnn More Recent Posts	I think it would be better if we the fans got some input...that makes a TRUE all star game (ala major league baseball)
XtremeInnovator420		#286	[-]
Posts: 1824 (07/16/09 7:36 PM) Registered user More Recent Posts	Well, then Rupert, Steph, and Yau Man would be on FOR SURE. Oh, and so would JT and Bob...and Sugar....urgh. 5/6 of that wouldn't be great.
Keyer2x		#287	[-]
Posts: 99 (07/16/09 9:16 PM) Registered User More Recent Posts	I know it would NEVER happen, but I'd kill for the 10-year anniversay edition they go back to Borneo with the original 16 Borneo players, and play it out again. Mabye it's just me, but I'd find it fascinating if they "re-did" a season -- any of them -- go back to the same location, the same original players, and see what happens. It'd probably be the early boots teaming up to get the ones that did well out ... but who knows? This would be the perfect time to do it, back where it all began.
Attack of the Nuns		#288	[-]
Posts: 111 (07/16/09 10:27 PM) Registered user More Recent Posts	Keyer2x wrote: I know it would NEVER happen, but I'd kill for the 10-year anniversay edition they go back to Borneo with the original 16 Borneo players, and play it out again. Mabye it's just me, but I'd find it fascinating if they "re-did" a season -- any of them -- go back to the same location, the same original players, and see what happens. It'd probably be the early boots teaming up to get the ones that did well out ... but who knows? This would be the perfect time to do it, back where it all began. It would be great to see any season again with the same players, only if we could somehow erase the memories of the players first. Unfortunately, that cannot happen, therefore, this idea is fail.
survivorsims07		#289	[-]
Posts: 1881 (07/16/09 10:33 PM) Hey! I kinda like it here! More Recent Posts	Keyer2x wrote: I know it would NEVER happen, but I'd kill for the 10-year anniversay edition they go back to Borneo with the original 16 Borneo players, and play it out again. Mabye it's just me, but I'd find it fascinating if they "re-did" a season -- any of them -- go back to the same location, the same original players, and see what happens. It'd probably be the early boots teaming up to get the ones that did well out ... but who knows? This would be the perfect time to do it, back where it all began. Oh snaps I actually kinda like that idea. Take a season with a lot of backstabbing went on and see how people play the second time around in the same situation trying to prevent what happened in the past while still trying to navigate the future
survivorready		#290	[-]
Posts: 441 (07/16/09 10:51 PM) More Recent Posts	I know there are some skeptics out there, but I think the Heroes Vs. Villains twist is a great idea. They already did the "ALL STAR" edition and also the favorites edition, so it would be useless to have another one of those. Here is who I would think would make a great cast: Heroes: 1. Tina (S2) - I would love to see her play again. She went out too early in All Stars. 2. Stephenie (S10) - She was one of the few stand out women post AS 3. Colleen - I doubt whether she will return, but she was the first sweetheart to emerge from Survivor. 4. Sugar - I really hated her, but she was portrayed as a sweetheart and a lot of people liked her. 5. Amanda 6. Rudy - I think Richard, Sue, and him truly shaped the Survivor franchise. 7. Micheal Skupin - I was shocked he didn't make the AS cut, but he really needs to be back. 8. Rupert - I am not a big fan of his, but he is maybe one of the most stand out characters in Survivor history. 9. Yau-Man 10. JT Other possibilities - Ozzy, Colby, Sandra, Chrisite, Twila (she was considered for fvf), Tom W., Terry D., Yul (Ughh...), James (S15), Erik (S16), Amanda (S15,S16) Villains 1. Jonny Fairplay 2. Rob Mariano 3. Coach 4. Shane (S12) 5. Brian (S5) 6. Jerri 7. Cirie (I think it is crazy that people want her in the Heroes tribe. She is a true mastermind and manipulator and definitely deserves to be in the villains tribe) 8. PGee 9. Jenna M. 10. Corrine (I really really wish she isnt cast, but there are very few choices for women in both categories)
YemaGrl1988		#291	[-]
Posts: 6800 (07/17/09 12:07 AM) Registered user More Recent Posts	Would Vecepia be considered a hero or a villain?
yautheman		#292	[-]
Posts: 57 (07/17/09 12:13 AM) More Recent Posts	Okay heres my guess, based on gut instinct, not necessarily who I want to see on: Villains: Jerri: I'm sure she got an invite, to this day one of the games most memberable villains Jenna M: Won the game, gotta fill up some slots Parvati: Thought she said she wouldn't come back again, but I'll bet we see her again Natalie: Convinced Eric to give up the idol... helped cause the biggest blunder in the shows history Crystal: Not nessessarily a villain, but spoke her mind and was entertaining JFP: He's good for ratings Boston Rob: Loves the spotlight, I'm sure he'd come back if asked... one of the best villains ever Shane: Very memorable, deserves a shot and hopefully CBS will give him one Randy: Entertaining, grumpy, great character Coach: Jeff alrady said they want him back again Heroes: Tina: First ever female winner, probably wants to avenge her poor perforamance in ASS Stephanie: No explanatin needed, the female Rupert, CBS loves her Cirie: Made it far twice, extremely popular and well known to average fans Amanda: Made it to the finals, x2, solid player Sugar: Made it far in Gabon, popular player Rupert: a CBS favorite, of course he'll be back Ozzy: Another favorite James: Very popular with the audience, likeable guy hard not to root for Yau Man: same as Rupert, but I actually want to see him back JT: Arguably the most popular winner ever So yea, I know Ive got a buncha third timers up there, but I'm pretty sure CBS is looking to bring back contestants who the "casual" fan will recognize, even if that means some of the favorites here at sucks get snubbed.... just the reality of the situation... doesn't bother me too much as I'd like to see people like Yau and Boston Rob play again.
matty p		#293	[-]
Posts: 128 (07/17/09 1:06 AM) More Recent Posts	yautheman wrote: Okay heres my guess, based on gut instinct, not necessarily who I want to see on: Villains: Jerri: I'm sure she got an invite, to this day one of the games most memberable villains Jenna M: Won the game, gotta fill up some slots Parvati: Thought she said she wouldn't come back again, but I'll bet we see her again Natalie: Convinced Eric to give up the idol... helped cause the biggest blunder in the shows history Crystal: Not nessessarily a villain, but spoke her mind and was entertaining JFP: He's good for ratings Boston Rob: Loves the spotlight, I'm sure he'd come back if asked... one of the best villains ever Shane: Very memorable, deserves a shot and hopefully CBS will give him one Randy: Entertaining, grumpy, great character Coach: Jeff alrady said they want him back again Heroes: Tina: First ever female winner, probably wants to avenge her poor perforamance in ASS Stephanie: No explanatin needed, the female Rupert, CBS loves her Cirie: Made it far twice, extremely popular and well known to average fans Amanda: Made it to the finals, x2, solid player Sugar: Made it far in Gabon, popular player Rupert: a CBS favorite, of course he'll be back Ozzy: Another favorite James: Very popular with the audience, likeable guy hard not to root for Yau Man: same as Rupert, but I actually want to see him back JT: Arguably the most popular winner ever So yea, I know Ive got a buncha third timers up there, but I'm pretty sure CBS is looking to bring back contestants who the "casual" fan will recognize, even if that means some of the favorites here at sucks get snubbed.... just the reality of the situation... doesn't bother me too much as I'd like to see people like Yau and Boston Rob play again. It looks like that'll be pretty close to the cast, with maybe a couple of changes. 1. Tyson in as a villain, probably for Fairplay. The villains need more strength in challenges so Tyson and Boston Rob are musts. I don't think Fairplay will be included in this season. 2. Personally, I'd have Erik Reichenbach as a hero instead of Ozzy, but from what I've heard this is unlikely. Hopefully Erik will make the cut though. 3. Courtney Yates will probably be cast if she accepts. She would replace Parvati or Jenna M. Twila is also a chance. 4. Tina and Amanda wouldn't be sure things for the heroes. Personally I'd put Peih-Gee in for Amanda, but I'm not sure if this will happen. Heroes: Rupert JT James Yau Man/Bob/Tom W Ozzy/Erik R Stephanie Sugar Cirie/Sandra/Taj Tina Peih-Gee/Amanda Villains: Coach Tyson Randy Shane Boston Rob Jerri/Corinne Natalie Crystal Courtney Y Twila/Sue
DarrahColleenJerri		#294	[-]
Posts: 579 (07/17/09 6:27 AM) Registered User More Recent Posts	yautheman wrote: Okay heres my guess, based on gut instinct, not necessarily who I want to see on: You mean your gut based on what Coby has said. Why would anyone in their right mind give Natalie a spot just randomly like that? She was INVISIBLE most of her season, and yeah the few episodes where she was crazy were memorable but not to the average viewer.
birdlady		#295	[-]
Posts: 2694 (07/17/09 7:03 AM) Registered user More Recent Posts	I think it would be better if we the fans got some input...that makes a TRUE all star game (ala major league baseball) I agree - I vote Charlie O. Finley.
yautheman		#296	[-]
Posts: 58 (07/17/09 9:22 AM) More Recent Posts	DarrahColleenJerri wrote: yautheman wrote: Okay heres my guess, based on gut instinct, not necessarily who I want to see on: You mean your gut based on what Coby has said. Why would anyone in their right mind give Natalie a spot just randomly like that? She was INVISIBLE most of her season, and yeah the few episodes where she was crazy were memorable but not to the average viewer. haha yes my gut + I def took into account what coby has said
QualityBobby		#297	[-]
Posts: 6632 (07/17/09 9:57 AM) O.o More Recent Posts	I think it would be better if we the fans got some input...that makes a TRUE all star game (ala major league baseball) Yeah, because fans do a GREAT job putting the right people in the game. That makes it just a popularity contest for the people that got the best and biggest edits.
WylDawg		#298	[-]
Posts: 18840 (07/17/09 11:03 AM) Registered user More Recent Posts	How was Stacy a vilain?? She helped the good guys of that season gain the upper hand on the douchey 4 horsemen alliance.
XtremeInnovator420		#299	[-]
Posts: 1826 (07/17/09 11:46 AM) Registered user More Recent Posts	There were actually GOOD GUYS on Fiji? Well, I guess by default it's "whatever side Yau is on" but it was just essentially a bunch of uh...not 'good' people, lol.
Terrywins		#300	[-]
Posts: 841 (07/17/09 12:12 PM) Registered User More Recent Posts	i hope to god that ozzy isnt on again.... that would piss me off to no end. he has no game!!!!! stop bringing him back

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

Survivor 20: Heroes vs Villains