
| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
Shagnanigans |
|||
|
There are loads of Hollywood stars who have Broadway experience and could sing & dance live. Next time get Hugh Jackman, Audra McDonald, Kristin Chenoweth
or hell, even John Travolta would be better than Katie.
|
|||
Craptaculous |
|||
It wasn't even the same stage, was it? Wasn't it obvious that it was pre-taped? |
|||
Dawnmarise |
|||
|
And read what Tyce has to say...Worthy of an OSCAR? And they wonder why people are up in arms. Oh, I found this shit by going to google and typing in Tyce
Diorio/Scientology. lol.
http://www.tomkatcrazy.com/katies-choreographer-tyce-diorio-calls-her-performance-oscar-worthy/ |
|||
Ann Margret Thatcher |
|||
Craptaculous wrote: Yes, it was obvious. That's why I'm saying that going from Cat's introduction to the number, it's like Katie was stuck in another dimension. It's obvious and it looks stupid. |
|||
Craptaculous |
|||
|
I hated the way they made it seem like she was on stage at the end. And her SMIRK...her shit-eating smirk.
|
|||
seaguy |
|||
|
Does Tom Cruise read here? If so, please ignore the rest of my post:
Katie Holmes was horrific. Her "singing" sucked and her "dancing"??? |
|||
Dawnmarise |
|||
Craptaculous wrote:You would be smirking too if your performance was worth of an Oscar. |
|||
suckshardcore |
|||
|
Is Tyce serious? An Oscar?
Wow, do they inject all employees of SYTYCD with some sort of drug that causes them to be deluded and arrogant even though this show is supposedly about the dancers? Cat must be the only one exempt for these experimental treatments which have obviously gone grievously wrong. |
|||
seaguy |
|||
suckshardcore wrote:This. The delusion of these people and their worth really is astonishing. They believe their own hype, that's the main problem. Like I said about Idol after it became so popular, they take themselves WAY too seriously! Get over yourselves. |
|||
Dawnmarise |
|||
suckshardcore wrote:That is the only explanation! Maybe Tomcat really is in charge of this production. LOL. |
|||
suckshardcore |
|||
|
In all honesty even Simon, Randy and Paula aren't as bad as the likes of Nigel, Mia, Tyce in terms of delusion and arrogance. Simon is there for the
paycheck and I doubt he gives a shit if people criticize the show or any of the performances. He'd never get into a petty argument with a fan if they
criticized a performance from IGB. I thought the AI judges were bad but then I turned into this show, damn these fucking people.
|
|||
Ann Margret Thatcher |
|||
|
Seaguy, as usual, you are right too. When a show starts to get really popular, especially a show like this with that many performers (ego x infinity), they
lose they damn minds. I hope it doesn't cause this show to completely run off the rails, but if Wednesday night's self congratulatory nonsense after
the Cancer Dance is any indication, it ain't looking good.
|
|||
Dawnmarise |
|||
suckshardcore wrote: Very true, Simon would just answer to critisism with an, "I'm right! SORRY!" and that would be the end of it. Nigel is acting like a fucking 2 year old playing in a sandbox! |
|||
NellB |
|||
|
This 100th episode blew it. They should have dedicated one 2-hour ep to great performances from the past 5 seasons. Leave the competition aspect out of it.
Janette and Jason probably had a pretty crappy time at the after-party!
I loved the bench routine on the night it premiered. I agree that it was more emotional because we had seen Heidi break down because she didn't think she could pull it off. But then she did an amazing job, and it seemed like Mia and Travis helped bring it out of her. HOWEVER, it was pretty basic, and like the bed routine, sometimes one dancer would just sit on the prop while the other dancer flew around the stage. If you pay attention, the girls in the crowd always go NUTS when the couples do something remotely sexual. And the teens seemed to really respond to the part of the dance where Heidi was under and Travis was over and they touched hands, you know, THROUGH the bench. "Like OMG they want to be together but they can't BE TOGETHER!!!" It's all very Twilight-y. Teen girls love that shit. Ramalama did rule though. Missed Alison! P.S. seaguy I'm a married mom of two, not a straight guy! :) |
|||
Dawnmarise |
|||
suckshardcore wrote: Very true, Simon would just answer to critisism with an, "I'm right! SORRY!" and that would be the end of it. Nigel is acting like a fucking 2 year old playing in a sandbox! |
|||
cginspace |
|||
meatball77 wrote:Partially true, though I think Janette had the MOST oomph in her sell, without (and I know many a y'all disagree with me here) OVERSELLING it. Evan and Brandon oversell it: Brandon in an attempt to play cutesy with his audience, and Evan in an attempt to hoodwink people into thinking he is better than he is. |
|||
cginspace |
|||
seaguy wrote: Let's put it this way... you generally need more years of solid training to be a good ballet dancer. I wanted to start classes at 18 and they told me there was no way at that age that I would go anywhere with it... you need to start training your form at a very young age (though there are obviously exceptions). The sad thing with this show is that, mostly due to ignorance, people are VERY lenient with crappy classical or social dance routines, but are extremely unforgiving with more recent genres. So Evan gets away with a lackluster performance in his Rhumba (my latino friend said, "I don't even know dance but know enough to tell you that is not a good Rhumba... his face was horrible), and Melissa gets spanked for not being hard enough in some of her routines. BOTH accusations are correct, but people are only willing to be easy on one of the two... but then,. that is the history of this show. |
|||
PinotEnvy |
|||
seaguy wrote:I don't know anything about it, other than the name of the guy who started it and the name of some "stars" who belong to it. All I am saying is that as far as I know, I have never heard Tom, Katie, Travolta or others declaring jihad on other religions, going around spreading hate or just being downright hateful bad people. So, if they want to believe in that, it must be working for them, so they can knock themselves out and believe what they believe in. How does it hurt anybody? I'm just saying that as long as you are not out trying to hurt people, spread hate or try to take other peoples' rights away, then I say live and let live, I have no reason to hate on your belief or question why you believe it. Back on the Katie number. It was over-hyped, however it was a fair re-enactment of Judy Garland's routine. This whole season has been lackluster, so in reality Katie's mediocre Judy Garland tribute was perfect for this season. The person who deserves the criticism is Nigel for doing his best to ruin what was once a great show. He needs to learn to shut his mouth, quit going personal on his critiques, be more objective and quit playing favorites, quit lusting after young female dancers, quit being a homophobe and either get his teeth fixed or stop with the open smiles. This would make the world a better place. |
|||
PinotEnvy |
|||
seaguy wrote: I can get behind all of this. X! |
|||
cginspace |
|||
|
The sad thing is, I AGREE that shows like this should be lauded for introducing dance that most might not see. The fact that they have to have every guest
judge say that in an obviously teleprompted way, however, makes it seem like bullshit even when it is not.
The other problem? They spend ten minutes on each judge (same prob Idol has) instead of having more dance. Whittle it down to two judges: one recurring, one guest, and you will liely have a nice little shift that would put things in a better perspective. It would also be nice to have a show where people compete with others in THEIR OWN genre. Then, people would see what dancing is meant to be. I mean... Mary saying she has seen the best dance on her life on this program throughout the years? A woman who has been a professional in her field? PUH_LEASE! |
|||