Survivor 20: Heroes vs Villains

0 Kudos

Started By	Comment
Syoma		#801	[-]
Posts: 2824 (08/01/09 7:03 AM) Registered User More Recent Posts	Seriously no more James. He'll win people's choice again after sucking on the game.
birdlady		#802	[-]
Posts: 2701 (08/01/09 7:20 AM) Registered user More Recent Posts	The problem with Jerri-style bitches (Crystal is in that tradition) is that they lack self-awareness, and their poor social game dooms them to exit early (unless they get lucky). If we have to do this repeat thing, Jerri is one who could be interesting to me as someone who has developed since their Survivor experience. She was an engaging character in Outback, because we all had the awareness she lacked. We could sit and scream at our televisions all the things that were right in front of her face. But there was also some sense that she would be embarassed (or at least sheepish) when she got to see herself. (Remember the reward with Colby? In her mind it was a date, but his priority was collecting presents for everyone who didn't get to go. That wasn't strategic bitchery, that was unawareness.)
Mypoody2		#803	[-]
Posts: 10051 (08/01/09 9:18 AM) Registered User More Recent Posts	Syoma wrote: Seriously no more James. He'll win people's choice again after sucking on the game. Fuck you! James ftw!
divatox16		#804	[-]
Posts: 748 (08/01/09 9:36 AM) Registered user More Recent Posts	Jenna Morasca's Myspace status is now "Packing for a fantastic voyage" Hmmm.
SurvivorGuy24		#805	[-]
Posts: 28 (08/01/09 9:43 AM) More Recent Posts	Syoma wrote: Seriously no more James. He'll win people's choice again after sucking on the game. Not if Rupert is there.
srvivrfreakevelrich		#806	[-]
Posts: 2234 (08/01/09 9:46 AM) Admin More Recent Posts	divatox16 wrote: Jenna Morasca's Myspace status is now "Packing for a fantastic voyage" Hmmm. :D
WorthPlayingFor		#807	[-]
Posts: 68 (08/01/09 9:52 AM) Registered user More Recent Posts	I WOULD COME IF IT WAS Sugar, Sandra, Steph, Cirie, Tom W, Tom B, Ozzy, Rupert and James VS Parv, Courtney (China), Coach, Twila, Fairplay, Jenna M, Jerri, Rob M and Shane Powers This exemplifies the inherent difficulty with the 'Heroes vs Villains' concept. Imagine that the above contestants comprised our two tribes; the 'Heroes' would annihilate the 'Villains' at every immunity challenge, and our beloved snakes and schemers would not be long for the game. The question then becomes, "Are there enough contestants that simultaneously 1) fit the 'Villain' mold of strategizer and/or instigator and 2) pose an adequate physical threat to the predefined Survivor Hero archetype?" Tyson, I believe, falls neatly into this category, as does Rob Mariano. But I'm not sure if there are enough of them.
Redmond		#808	[-]
Posts: 685 (08/01/09 9:58 AM) More Recent Posts	divatox16 wrote: Jenna Morasca's Myspace status is now "Packing for a fantastic voyage" Hmmm. That pretty much confirms Jenna is at least been flown out to Samoa then. They leave on Monday.
FroggyMudd		#809	[-]
Posts: 5 (08/01/09 10:27 AM) More Recent Posts	WorthPlayingFor wrote: I WOULD COME IF IT WAS Sugar, Sandra, Steph, Cirie, Tom W, Tom B, Ozzy, Rupert and James VS Parv, Courtney (China), Coach, Twila, Fairplay, Jenna M, Jerri, Rob M and Shane Powers This exemplifies the inherent difficulty with the 'Heroes vs Villains' concept. Imagine that the above contestants comprised our two tribes; the 'Heroes' would annihilate the 'Villains' at every immunity challenge, and our beloved snakes and schemers would not be long for the game. The question then becomes, "Are there enough contestants that simultaneously 1) fit the 'Villain' mold of strategizer and/or instigator and 2) pose an adequate physical threat to the predefined Survivor Hero archetype?" Tyson, I believe, falls neatly into this category, as does Rob Mariano. But I'm not sure if there are enough of them. Just replace James & Ozzy from the hero tribe. I wouldn't want them back for a 3rd time anyways.
ElisabethNelehHeidiRok		#810	[-]
Posts: 1151 (08/01/09 10:43 AM) Registered User More Recent Posts	I agree to more James or Ozzy. And yay for Jenna M!!!
Outback		#811	[-]
Posts: 3 (08/01/09 10:44 AM) More Recent Posts	If they are considering having past winners and 3rd timers(I don't like it). They need to get Brian H. He is awesome player and for 3th timers. I want to see Colby, Jerry, Rob.C., Rubert, Bobby Jon, Steph, Amanda, Yau-Man and Cirie.
FroggyMudd		#812	[-]
Posts: 7 (08/01/09 10:56 AM) More Recent Posts	Outback wrote: If they are considering having past winners and 3rd timers(I don't like it). They need to get Brian H. He is awesome player and for 3th timers. I want to see Colby, Jerry, Rob.C., Rubert, ~~Bobby Jon, Steph, Amanda~~, Yau-Man and Cirie. Now I agree with you.
srvivrfreakevelrich		#813	[-]
Posts: 2237 (08/01/09 11:04 AM) Admin More Recent Posts	FroggyMudd wrote: Outback wrote: If they are considering having past winners and 3rd timers(I don't like it). They need to get Brian H. He is awesome player and for 3th timers. I want to see ~~Colby~~, Jerry, Rob.C., ~~Rubert, Bobby Jon, Steph, Amanda, Yau-Man~~ and Cirie. Now I agree with you. Jerri Jerri or Peepaw Jerry? Now I agree with both of you.
Katy Carney		#814	[-]
Posts: 6959 (08/01/09 12:05 PM) More Recent Posts	I'm kind of shocked about Jenna M. She better not have taken Parvati, Jerri or JLew's spot because I will get feisty.
Bjorkrazy		#815	[-]
Posts: 529 (08/01/09 12:22 PM) More Recent Posts	Do they tell alternates they're just alternates or do they break their hearts once they arrive on location?
island sun		#816	[-]
Posts: 1163 (08/01/09 12:40 PM) Registered user More Recent Posts	Bjorkrazy wrote: Do they tell alternates they're just alternates or do they break their hearts once they arrive on location? It would suck to fly all the way out there and then find out you had to turn around and go straight back home.
ActingDude17		#817	[-]
Posts: 21 (08/01/09 12:45 PM) More Recent Posts	Bjorkrazy wrote: Do they tell alternates they're just alternates or do they break their hearts once they arrive on location? According to Billy Garcia, Shane knows he's an alternate. I assume they're told. And if Jenna takes Parvati's spot that will be amazing.
Outback		#818	[-]
Posts: 4 (08/01/09 1:03 PM) More Recent Posts	srvivfreakevelrich wrote: Jerri Jerri or Peepaw? --------------------------------------------------- Look at my avatar and you will know who.
Kirblar		#819	[-]
Posts: 8090 (08/01/09 1:10 PM) Registered user More Recent Posts	Jenna M is a great choice, given that she didn't even get a chance to play in the first ASS due to her mother's death.
Katy Carney		#820	[-]
Posts: 6961 (08/01/09 1:21 PM) More Recent Posts	I like Jenna M a lot, it's just that all of my favorites are bad girls except for Cirie, Tom W and Steph.

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

Survivor 20: Heroes vs Villains