Survivor 20: Heroes vs Villains

0 Kudos

Started By	Comment
co coach		#3021	[-]
Posts: 352 (08/22/09 9:18 PM) More Recent Posts	In the middle. Challenge 1 is the halftime show, concluding with a Rupert/Coach duet of Poker Face.
surf7		#3022	[-]
Posts: 26 (08/22/09 9:37 PM) More Recent Posts	valentine79 wrote: TDB wrote: I was on TDT's website a few hours ago and he had a list of favorites that did not appear to be on S20. Now I can't seem to find that list on his website. Anyway, he mentioned that Cirie did not appear to be on S20. The only way I could see her not on S20 is if they got Taj instead. However, of all the people JFP mentioned (Rupert, Coach, James, Amanda, and Cirie), it just seems wierd to me that Cirie would be the only one from that list that is not on S20. This is also just a thought that came to me a little while ago, could some former contestants that were speculated to be on this season (Sierra, JT, Big Tom, Tina W., etc.) be flown to Samoa to host a challenge or compete against the tribes in a challenge or something like that? I was thinking about something similar....perhaps they are reusing previous challenges and having the person who won that callenge when it appeared on their season make a cameo? Those are two good ideas that could make the show more fun for us, the audience. These former contestants could be paid to appear for a cameo, no commitment, no nasty stuff.
Redmond		#3023	[-]
Posts: 878 (08/23/09 2:56 AM) More Recent Posts	tynand wrote: Are we even certain filming has even begun? Yes. Filming begans August 9th.
A Dying Clown		#3024	[-]
Posts: 10834 (08/23/09 3:25 AM) Registered User More Recent Posts	Dannielle,Boston,Rob,Jenna? we have 4 Italians in one season! Shane's son randomly being on <3
garyw		#3025	[-]
Posts: 144 (08/23/09 4:21 AM) I don't take hints More Recent Posts	I can't believe people on here believe that Danielle is on.
tynand	Sharea	#3026	[-]
Posts: 20 (08/23/09 5:15 AM) More Recent Posts	I know most people (including myself) rate Cirie, Crystal and Taj and think atleast one of these 3 should be on if not all. As they represent the same type of person (African American middle aged female) but has anyone thought about Sharea from China? She represents the African-American female too and she was strong in challenges and was entertaining to watch as she spoke her mind. She was also close to making it on the jury so she was on for most of the season and apparently (from what I hear and read) some non jury members have been cast for this season. She could be a big possiblity especially if the other 3 have not been cast.
tom320000		#3027	[-]
Posts: 58 (08/23/09 5:29 AM) More Recent Posts	Sherea was voted out 6th, if i remember, so, she was too short time to be on season 20. And she wasn;t that entertaining.
taigark		#3028	[-]
Posts: 642 (08/23/09 6:24 AM) Hey! I kinda like it here! More Recent Posts	tynand wrote: I know most people (including myself) rate Cirie, Crystal and Taj and think atleast one of these 3 should be on if not all. As they represent the same type of person (African American middle aged female) but has anyone thought about Sharea from China? She represents the African-American female too and she was strong in challenges and was entertaining to watch as she spoke her mind. She was also close to making it on the jury so she was on for most of the season and apparently (from what I hear and read) some non jury members have been cast for this season. She could be a big possiblity especially if the other 3 have not been cast. Middle aged? Crystal was 29 when she was on.
Jedijake		#3029	[-]
Posts: 5710 (08/23/09 7:04 AM) MESS member More Recent Posts	The only way Cirie and JT are not on this season is if they declined. And you know they have to have the randomly invisible girl on the show like they had with Amber and Parvati. That is the only reason they'd put Danielle on: to see if the others ignore her they way they did the previous "all star" winners. Still, all is speculation. Unless someone can definitively claim that Cirie and JT appeared somewhere during filming, they could still be on. I'm holding out for those two because I think they would be essential to the show.
Jedijake		#3030	[-]
Posts: 5711 (08/23/09 7:08 AM) MESS member More Recent Posts	Oh, and if the season is indeed a "Heroes vs. Villains" season, there would be no place for Danielle. She was neither and a complete non-entity. There is no way viewers will ever be able to even place her because NOBODY would remember her. The same would probably hold true for Candice. What about Twila and Shane? Have they been conclusively eliminated as contestants?
tynand		#3031	[-]
Posts: 21 (08/23/09 8:23 AM) More Recent Posts	Jedijake wrote: Oh, and if the season is indeed a "Heroes vs. Villains" season, there would be no place for Danielle. She was neither and a complete non-entity. There is no way viewers will ever be able to even place her because NOBODY would remember her. The same would probably hold true for Candice. What about Twila and Shane? Have they been conclusively eliminated as contestants? I think people would remember Candice for the mutiny which in a way made her a villian for jumping ship and betraying the likes of Yul and Becky. However being sent to exile so many times made her a bit of a hero in my opinion. Danielle was less memorable but making the final 2 might be why she is remembered by people. She also would fit in the villian role as everyone hated her and she was seen as lazy. She also betrayed Courtney and the males didn't like her at all except Bruce. As for the Parvati/Amber role that occurs every All Star season, I think Julie from Vanuatu would be a good candidate for this more so than any of the girls that have been mentioned. My apologies in regards to Crystal's age. I shouldn't have said middle aged and left it at African American females. In regards to Sharea she was one person off making the jury. Boston Rob and Shii-Ann were also in this position and appeard on the first All Stars. Sharea was good entertainment as she rubbed people the wrong way for being lazy and she told Dave and Jean-Robert exactly what she thought of them. A verbal fight is always fun to watch on Survivor and she was in a few of them.
streetlightrox		#3032	[-]
Posts: 81 (08/23/09 8:41 AM) More Recent Posts	but china had the final three, which made all post-merge players on the jury. boston rob and shii-ann at least made it to the merge. i know that in thailand it wasnt really a merge, but she still placed in the top ten. if china had a final two, jamie wouldnt have been on the jury and sherea wouldnt have been one place away.
vman	I'm not happy with the cast either	#3033	[-]
Posts: 1 (08/23/09 9:28 AM) More Recent Posts	So they're really chucking some people on for the THIRD freaking time? This is ridiculous!! Okay well, people from Survivor All Stars 1~some of them~ I can live with that since it was 5 years ago....but James? Parvati? FREAKIN AMANDA?? What the fragging frag?? We just saw them not less than 2 years ago!! And ugh....Stephenie? Reeeally? And wtf? Are they seriously gonna put Coach and Tyson in the same tribe? How seriously stupid is that? Not to mention pathetic!! Basically I'm gonna go down the supposed cast list and replace them with people who I think should've been on for Hero's v Villains: Males: Rupert - Hero JT - Hero James - Hero - NOOO - As if they're not gonna get Matty from Gabon?!? WHY HIM AGAIN.... Tom W - Hero Colby - Hero - okay fair enough I like Colby...but why can't they get more people from pre All Stars? <.< Coach - Villain Tyson - Villain Randy - Villain Boston Rob - Villain - ooooooh great here we go again...but I can't really think of anyone else other than Rob Cesternino Samoa Male - Supposed Villain - he better be good. Females: Stephenie - Hero - ugh LAME why not Colleen or Teresa? Tee would've been good too cuz there would be more age representation Sugar - Hero Amanda - Hero - I'd replace with Christy from Amazon Candice W - Villain - reeeeeally? LAME CHOICE. Kelly Goldsmith from Africa better!!! Jerri - Villain - this bitch actually agreed to do this again? If I hear any complaints from her I'll just lose it! Courtney Y - Villain Danielle - Villain - WHY THE HELL WOULD THEY BRING HER BACK? As if they're not gonna get Corinne? She was the one and only one true female villain in the entire survivor history...THEY'RE CRAZY DANIELLE WAS A WALLFLOWER Parvati - Villain - again........UH-freaking-gain? Sighs. Sandra - Hero - pretty meh for a hero...she doesn't fit in the villain side though...
val.kellyclarksonex...		#3034	[-]
Posts: 51 (08/23/09 9:58 AM) More Recent Posts	Jedijake wrote: And you know they have to have the randomly invisible girl on the show like they had with Amber and Parvati. That is the only reason they'd put Danielle on: to see if the others ignore her they way they did the previous "all star" winners. Agree about Amber but Parvati invisble?have you watched Micronesia at all? She was the mastermind of the black widow alliance. c'mon!!
unduli clone		#3035	[-]
Posts: 6892 (08/23/09 10:08 AM) Registered User More Recent Posts	Jedijake wrote: What about Twila and Shane? Have they been conclusively eliminated as contestants? Not much news on Twila - isn't she scheduled at event or something, though? I seem to remember something that pointed to her NOT being on but didn't confirm it. Shane had the drama about sending a letter to CBS about how they're assholes and such, which some thought might be a cover-up but apparently he's been online since filming began.
strawberrybitch		#3036	[-]
Posts: 733 (08/23/09 10:31 AM) More Recent Posts	Is it 100% positive that Peih-Gee isn't on? Should I wake up and stop dreaming?
Aitu4fan27		#3037	[-]
Posts: 658 (08/23/09 10:36 AM) OMEDETO, CATHY!! More Recent Posts	val wrote: Jedijake wrote: And you know they have to have the randomly invisible girl on the show like they had with Amber and Parvati. That is the only reason they'd put Danielle on: to see if the others ignore her they way they did the previous "all star" winners. Agree about Amber but Parvati invisble?have you watched Micronesia at all? She was the mastermind of the black widow alliance. c'mon!! Amber was very invisible but Parvati on both seasons was very much a mastermind only in Micro it actually worked out. If Raro had had the numbers she would have been golden. She and Cirie very much deserved to win Micro so since Cirie got taken out I was glad it was Parv
Redmond		#3038	[-]
Posts: 879 (08/23/09 10:56 AM) More Recent Posts	Aitu4fan27 wrote: Amber was very invisible but Parvati on both seasons was very much a mastermind only in Micro it actually worked out. If Raro had had the numbers she would have been golden. She and Cirie very much deserved to win Micro so since Cirie got taken out I was glad it was Parv A lot of luck went Parvati's way though (and Amanda and Cirie's for that matter). Because if Penner hadn't have had to be taken out and if Kathy didn't quit, they would have went in to the merge numbers up. Because Eliza, Jonathan, Jason and Kathy would have been a four and would probably have pulled in Alexis and Natalie. But that's a lot of what ifs. Parvati was an okay player, but I wouldn't say she was a mastermind of anything.
Jedijake		#3039	[-]
Posts: 5712 (08/23/09 11:11 AM) MESS member More Recent Posts	Agree about Amber but Parvati invisble?have you watched Micronesia at all? She was the mastermind of the black widow alliance. c'mon!! I'll make my point again. Both Amber and Parvati were invisible in their FIRST seasons. They were both brought back as the underdog females. Neither made a big impact the first time around. (not that either were spectacular during their second time either, despite winning).
Heliox		#3040	[-]
Posts: 3037 (08/23/09 11:17 AM) More Recent Posts	tynand wrote: I know most people (including myself) rate Cirie, Crystal and Taj and think atleast one of these 3 should be on if not all. As they represent the same type of person (African American middle aged female) but has anyone thought about Sharea from China? She represents the African-American female too and she was strong in challenges and was entertaining to watch as she spoke her mind. She was also close to making it on the jury so she was on for most of the season and apparently (from what I hear and read) some non jury members have been cast for this season. She could be a big possiblity especially if the other 3 have not been cast. I wouldn't put Crystal in the same grouping as the other 3. She was a character unto herself. Sherea is a good idea actually, if they decided they needed a black female. Unfortunately, it sounds like they already have 2 from China in James and Amanda. I think Sandra probably fills the older soccer mom role.

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

Survivor 20: Heroes vs Villains