S-19 Edgic (editing and logic)

0 Kudo

Started By	Comment
AveryC		#2541	[-]
Posts: 29 (11/06/09 8:35 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	BlakeB717 wrote: AveryC wrote: And like I said, a winner hasn't been UTR/INV 3 episodes in a row (and going to TC all three times) since... HM CAN'T SEEM TO RECALL. =o Amber in All Stars was UTR1 INV UTRP3. It has happened, just like Ethan's Merge UTR1 and Jenna's quitting discussion. Amber didn't go to TC during any of those episodes (there were three tribes, Chapera had a few scenes and she was included with Rob at the start--don't compare this to Russ/Nat since Russ made several alliances and we didn't even know Natalie's name: she was "dumber long-haired blonde"), it was an All-Star season (many other big characters), and Amber--based on the edgic chart--was UTRP1 UTR1 OTTP2. Those numbers you have are strictly chaperarocks' opinion. Consider the circumstances. I missed the bit about Tribal the first time and edited it in, but you must've been too quick :) Curious how an episode can be interpreted as UTRP by one person and OTTP by another. I think this is a case of going with what we know, despite how wacky things seem. That would leave Mick or Jason.
getting real		#2542	[-]
Posts: 1848 (11/06/09 8:58 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Blake, love reading your posts but would it be too much to ask not to include entire quotes in them, page after page? Besides tiring everyone, they're just that more visible when it comes to eating humble pie at the end. And we've all had ample opportunity to do that in the past, haven't we, lol.
rioothello		#2543	[-]
Posts: 16 (11/06/09 9:20 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	BlakeB717 wrote: AveryC wrote: ETA Oops didn't see the Tribal bit the first time. But an UTR start is not unheard of for a winner. It is unheard of: it unofficially happened once in a themed season. Tina had an INV, and Vecepia, Amber, and Danni all had UTR's in their first episodes.
garyw		#2544	[-]
Posts: 269 (11/06/09 9:21 PM) I don't take hints Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	At this stage for me if Mick won I think he would be one of the most if not the most unmemorable winner. I'm not just saying this but if it wasn't for edgic having Mick at the top for weeks I wouldn't have even picked him. This season might be the one to get rid of this INV rule for good.
rioothello		#2545	[-]
Posts: 17 (11/06/09 9:23 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I still believe Natalie never received an INV.
SurvivorNinja		#2546	[-]
Posts: 3015 (11/06/09 9:32 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	rioothello wrote: I still believe Natalie never received an INV. I agree with this. Her short part in the scene with Ben working while everyone was sleeping should have been enough to push her to UTR1 considering others have had less screen time and still be UTR1...
rioothello		#2547	[-]
Posts: 18 (11/06/09 9:36 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	There was also a conversation with her, Ashley, and Betsy about "woman's intuition."
BlakeB717		#2548	[-]
Posts: 2094 (11/06/09 9:48 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	rioothello wrote: BlakeB717 wrote: AveryC wrote: ETA Oops didn't see the Tribal bit the first time. But an UTR start is not unheard of for a winner. It is unheard of: it unofficially happened once in a themed season. Tina had an INV, and Vecepia, Amber, and Danni all had UTR's in their first episodes. Did you forget what you said? We are talking about Natalie's triple UTR start. No winner has officially had that, thus it is unheard of.
Griffin		#2549	[-]
Posts: 6 (11/06/09 9:51 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Did you forget what you said? We are talking about Natalie's triple UTR start. No winner has officially had that, thus it is unheard of. Does it really matter whether Amber's UTR-INV-UTR start is "official" or not? If someone thinks it happened - and most people seem to - then they use that when making predictions. Not UTR-UTR-OTT or whatever's on the chart.
rioothello		#2550	[-]
Posts: 19 (11/06/09 9:56 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	BlakeB717 wrote: rioothello wrote: BlakeB717 wrote: AveryC wrote: ETA Oops didn't see the Tribal bit the first time. But an UTR start is not unheard of for a winner. It is unheard of: it unofficially happened once in a themed season. Tina had an INV, and Vecepia, Amber, and Danni all had UTR's in their first episodes. Did you forget what you said? We are talking about Natalie's triple UTR start. No winner has officially had that, thus it is unheard of. It was unheard of in Amber's season to have 2 UTR starts too. Things change.
scepticA		#2551	[-]
Posts: 1763 (11/06/09 10:02 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	The "despites": If Mick wins it is despite not a huge amount of character development and a miserable merge episode. If Natalie wins it is despite terrible edits in the first 3 episodes and her game revolving around whether or not she is RH's pawn. If Jaison wins it is despite talking about quitting, and having his goal be to last longer than someone else. If Russell wins it is despite a rating average that is so much higher and more OTTN than any other winner - by far. If Shambo wins it is despite her edit as clueless, dumb ("Eric? Who's Eric?") and OTT. If anyone else wins it is despite even the most convoluted rationalization of edgic being somewhat malleable. I predict a tie.
OnlyTheHunter		#2552	[-]
Posts: 2047 (11/06/09 10:11 PM) Edgician Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I don't think they'd allow a tie. But that's me. UTR1 is the issue for episode one. It's the one some are ignoring. Amber got a UTRP1, with Tone, and that was when the visibility scale was 1-3 and not the current 1-5. Has Warrior or anyone used the current V calculations for that episode - I would not be shocked if the current system gives her an UTRP2. Natalie would indeed be the only winner starting with an UTR1. Except she won't be winning. Michael
cookie		#2553	[-]
Posts: 321 (11/06/09 10:12 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	you know, i COmmented too quickLy, and hadn't even watched the episode. mick did have a confessionaL, and it encompassed the thEmE and new developmeNt -a merge. And how it's a new stage in the game. That is narrativeLy a big deal. and yOu then compare it to monica's confessional also about the merge, but about the Various details of the food. mick's was about the themE, monica narRating.
MasterDarkNinja		#2554	[-]
Posts: 2864 (11/06/09 10:17 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	scepticA wrote: ETA: MDN, I understand your rationale for Russell. And also your dissing of Mick. I just see the entire odd edit of the whole frigging season and come to a different conclusion. No biggee either way. Jeez - some people take this crap way too seriously. I was being sarcastic because of all of the fighting between some Mick & Russel supporters, sorry if it wasn't obvious. I'm also pondering if I've missed something in the past in Jaison's edit after his merge episode, or if I was right to eliminate him earlier, so I'm not just a Russel supporter. Last Edited By: MasterDarkNinja 11/06/09 10:21 PM. Edited 1 times.
OnlyTheHunter		#2555	[-]
Posts: 2048 (11/06/09 10:20 PM) Edgician Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I'm not very familiar with Africa and don't have copies of it. Ethan's merge episode was UTR1, followed by an equally astounding OTTP5. Can someone refresh me on that setup. Sorry, I don't have that in the memory banks. Michael
BlakeB717		#2556	[-]
Posts: 2095 (11/06/09 10:35 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	cookie wrote: you know, i COmmented too quickLy, and hadn't even watched the episode. mick did have a confessionaL, and it encompassed the thEmE and new developmeNt -a merge. And how it's a new stage in the game. That is narrativeLy a big deal. and yOu then compare it to monica's confessional also about the merge, but about the Various details of the food. mick's was about the themE, monica narRating. I definitely agree!! It was significant. Last Edited By: BlakeB717 11/06/09 11:15 PM. Edited 1 times.
beatles20147		#2557	[-]
Posts: 12576 (11/06/09 10:46 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	In the merge ep, Ethan started off the "I never" game and he breakdances and I think he got a TC question. Personally I had him rated as UTR2 there. Then the episode after, he won a reward that took up a huge chunk of the episode and played hackysack with (and gave it to) some local children--most entertaining reward ever btw. In all honesty, I don't get why he wouldn't be PP for that but there might be other stuff that countered it; I don't remember. He also won immunity so he was definitely very visible that week.
rioothello		#2558	[-]
Posts: 20 (11/06/09 10:49 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	OnlyTheHunter wrote: I don't think they'd allow a tie. But that's me. UTR1 is the issue for episode one. It's the one some are ignoring. Amber got a UTRP1, with Tone, and that was when the visibility scale was 1-3 and not the current 1-5. Has Warrior or anyone used the current V calculations for that episode - I would not be shocked if the current system gives her an UTRP2. Natalie would indeed be the only winner starting with an UTR1. Except she won't be winning. Michael Yeah she will. Loser.
SurvivorGuy24		#2559	[-]
Posts: 1070 (11/06/09 10:53 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	So rioothello is pretty much a shoo-in for the "Worst New Edgic Poster" award.
BlakeB717		#2560	[-]
Posts: 2096 (11/06/09 10:54 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	rioothello wrote: OnlyTheHunter wrote: I don't think they'd allow a tie. But that's me. UTR1 is the issue for episode one. It's the one some are ignoring. Amber got a UTRP1, with Tone, and that was when the visibility scale was 1-3 and not the current 1-5. Has Warrior or anyone used the current V calculations for that episode - I would not be shocked if the current system gives her an UTRP2. Natalie would indeed be the only winner starting with an UTR1. Except she won't be winning. Michael Yeah she will. Loser. Ohhhh no you didn't. Fuck off, you idiot. Not only are you incompetent in every fucking thing you say, your arguments completely lack consistency or truth. Go jerk off to Natalie's picture because no one here gives a shit about your fanboy bias. If you aren't biased, then you are absolutely retarded and I feel very, very sorry for you. If you're going to post in Edgic, then read the rules and guidelines before you run your mouth about your ridiculous "gut feelings". I was fine playing nice, but don't go off insulting someone. OTH a loser? ... Please, DIAF. Know yourself before you speak. Idiot.

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

S-19 Edgic (editing and logic)

Quick Reply