JPOz wrote:My statistics do take into account challenge sit-outs. If you remove performances from challenges Lydia did not really compete in, her numbers are what I stated them to be, 2 out of 20. (Although Lydia actually was on the winning tribe for three Immunity Challenges, so even if you wanted to give her credit for wins she didn't participate in achieving, your statistics are still wrong.)
In summary, Lydia - not taking into account challenges she may have sat out - was in 24 challenges and won in 3 of them.
ETA: I also don't include the first post-merge challenge in Guatemala for Lydia's stats, although you could make an argument for why it should be held against her. Sure, she didn't participate (so a lack of victory not indicative of challenge strength), but she chose not to participate, which could be construed as a loss in a way (especially since there are plenty of thrown challenges in the history of Survivor that on would count as challenge "losses").
