Edgic Charts

0 Kudos

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Started By

Comment

cantthinkofaname

[-]

Posts: 1446

(06/02/09 9:48 PM)

Registered User

I just did a VF count for Palau episode 4. here's my chart so far and the official chart for comparison.

astroline

[-]

Posts: 2337

(06/15/09 9:11 AM)

Registered user

Sorry for being so late, but I love the chart so far. I guess the only ratings that surprise me are...

-- Jeff's CPN in Episode 2
-- Ibrehem's MOR3 in Episode 2

Other than that, you're doing an awesome job. Hope to see another update soon.

cantthinkofaname

[-]

Posts: 1457

(06/15/09 7:37 PM)

Registered User

Yeah I'm still fine tuning. I'm debating those 2 ratings you mentioned as well as Kim's ep 4 rating.
i may make Ibrehem UTR3, Kim MORN, and Jeff is tough, I just picked what was the best choice I thought.

Also in ep 5, James is in the 4 range rather than 2 like in the original chart.
I'm also debating giving Janu a P for episode 6.

Last Edited By: cantthinkofaname 06/15/09 7:43 PM. Edited 1 times.

astroline

[-]

Posts: 2349

(06/16/09 9:58 AM)

Registered user

Kim MORN for which episode -- Episode 4? I dunno, the official chart always had it as OTTN and I always thought of it as CPN. MORN doesn't really seem to fit any of her episodes at all except for Episode 2, which is essentially the poster child for a moderately high visibility MORN episode (not that there have been so many, but whatever).

Janu, P for Episode 6? I guess I could see it, but there wasn't really a lot of manipulation into making it P, just reporting. And nobody else really had much to say positive about it, I think it was good for making Tom get a P edit, but Janu was just the story that allowed him to do that. You know?

cantthinkofaname

[-]

Posts: 1462

(07/08/09 12:44 PM)

Registered User

Here's my chart through episode 6

BlakeB717

[-]

Posts: 1703

(09/15/09 12:56 AM)

Registered user

Have you gotten much more done on your Palau chart?

cantthinkofaname

[-]

Posts: 1477

(09/15/09 9:55 AM)

Registered User

No sorry, I've gotten sidetracked with other things.
Well here's episode 7

Last Edited By: cantthinkofaname 09/20/09 8:35 PM. Edited 1 times.

Erinnloveee

[-]

Posts: 220

(10/29/09 4:50 PM)

I rewatched Amazon a little while ago and worked on a new chart. I thought the old one was a bit outdated. I don't have visibilities because I'm not great at calculating that accurately, so it would've just been a guess. But anyways, here it is. It'd be great if others looked at Amazon again too.

Original Chart:

My Chart:

BlakeB717

[-]

Posts: 1982

(10/29/09 6:45 PM)

Registered user

and cantthinkofaname's chart:

AveryC

[-]

Posts: 30

(11/08/09 10:11 PM)

I've recently rewatched Cook Islands and decided to make an edgic chart whilst I was watching. This is what I ended up with:

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

SEKOU

OTTN5

BILLY

MORN3

OTTN5

CECILIA

UTR1

MOR3

UTRP3

JP

UTR2

OTTN5

UTR2

OTTN5

STEPHANNIE

CPP5

UTR2

UTRP2

CPP4

MORP3

CAO BOI

OTTM5

MORN3

CPM5

OTTM4

OTTN4

OTTN5

CRISTINA

INV1

CPP5

INV1

MOR3

OTT4

OTTP5

JESSICA

OTTM3

UTR2

CPM5

UTR2

OTTM2

MOR2

OTTM5

BRAD

MOR2

UTR1

MOR3

MOR2

MOR3

MORP3

MORN3

MOR3

REBECCA

CPP5

UTRP2

UTR1

CP3

MOR3

UTR1

UTR2

INV1

UTR1

JENNY

UTR2

INV1

CP4

CPN3

UTRN2

UTR1

UTRN1

MORN3

NATE

MOR4

MOR3

MORP3

CPP5

CPN4

CPP4

CPM4

CPM5

UTR2

MORN4

CANDICE

UTR2

MOR3

MOR2

UTRN2

MOR2

CP3

OTTNN5

CPN4

MORN2

OTTNN4

JONATHAN

CPM4

MOR3

CPM5

MORP4

CP2

CPM4

CPM5

CPN5

CPP4

CPP5

OTTM5

CP4

PARVATI

MOR2

UTR1

MORM3

CP5

MORP3

INV1

UTR1

UTR2

UTRN2

OTTNN4

MORP4

CP4

ADAM

UTR2

MORN2

INV1

MORN5

OTTN4

MOR2

MORN4

MORN5

OTTN3

MORN3

MOR3

MORN2

SUNDRA

MORP4

UTR2

UTR1

CPP3

MORP2

MOR2

OTTP4

UTRP2

MORP3

MOR2

OTTP4

MOR2

CPP3

BECKY

INV1

MOR2

CP4

UTR1

UTR2

UTRP1

UTRP2

MOR2

MORP2

CPP3

CPM3

OZZY

MORP3

OTTN5

MOR3

OTTP4

MOR3

MORP3

CPP5

OTTP3

MORP3

UTR1

CPP3

OTTP4

YUL

CP3

CPP4

CPP5

UTR1

MOR3

CPP4

CP4

MORP3

OTTP3

CPP5

CP4

CP3

CP4

CPP4

It's clear that my visibilities are different from the oringinal, and there's also a deviation between Brad and Sundra's ratings. I'm interested to see what the rest of you think and will listen to suggestions, but I'm not subjecting myself to flames and rampant sarcasm. It's a controversial season so I don't expect everyone to agree.

BlakeB717

[-]

Posts: 2287

(11/13/09 10:14 PM)

Registered user