| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
 Oowatanite |
|||
|
Posts: 9405 (11/19/09 08:03 PM) Registered User |
Vyvvi wrote: It was not a confessional, it was a voiceover which will count as two sentences. And talking about how hungry you are is not MOR. Mick had the shelter scene with Jaison and Monica, plus the confessional about his concerns with trusting Monica. He is MOR. |
||
|
The Marquesan Godfather |
|||
|
Posts: 11880 (11/19/09 08:04 PM) Registered User |
Man, every shot of Shambo was her cackling. OTTN indeed.
|
||
|
troynuncdicit |
|||
|
Posts: 612 (11/19/09 08:05 PM) |
I would give Mick a CP3 just from the first impression, but I could see him getting a 2 for visibility too. I'm really hoping Brett got UTR1. All he did
was read the clue, get two arrows in the Challenge (INV1 thus far), and get that scene with Dave & John (makes him a UTR definitely, hopefully still a 1)
|
||
|
MasterDarkNinja |
|||
|
Posts: 2895 (11/19/09 08:06 PM) Registered User |
Darn it, I lost all of my thoughts during the episode I wrote up again because it told me to log in when I hit post. grrr.... Well from my memory
-The recap was all about Gelu's fall from being so strong to blowing it, rather than anyone actually making Gelu blow it -Thank you so much sprint for revealing that John would flip with your stupid 'who made a great move' question in the middle of the episode! Morons. -For being a boot target Natalie didn't get much airtime this episode, I'd guesstimate she was a 2 visibility this episode. -Lamest individual IC ever, I mean only one shot to break the tiles? -The Gelu's were really made to look like fools this episode, especially when Brent was telling them about their plan to get Foa Foa to split their votes -Did I hear wrong, or did Mick and Jaison offer to vote out Shambo to Monica earlier in the episode when the others were away on the reward? |
||
|
SFC |
|||
|
Posts: 784 (11/19/09 08:07 PM) Registered user |
Mick: UTR2 (maybe MOR)
Natalie- UTRP1-2 |
||
 SuperSmizeMe |
|||
|
Posts: 8 (11/19/09 08:08 PM) |
Initial Ratings, must look over again though:
Brett - UTR1 Dave - CP4 Jaison - MOR2 John - CP5 Laura - OTTN5 Mick - UTR2 Monica - CPN4 Natalie - UTRP2/MORP2... idk yet. Russell - OTT5 Shambo - OTTN5 (debatable NN, perhaps?) |
||
|
astroline |
|||
|
Posts: 2793 (11/19/09 08:09 PM) Registered user |
Mick finally gets shown again and people are giving him CP3's? He was in the background of the Jaison/Monica camp scene (they both spoke and were shown
more than he was, and that's a fact), he won the IC but didn't receive any confessional or after-praise/mentions of it, and had one quick confessional
about Monica... and that's enough for a CP3? He was UTR2, just like Natalie.
Russell was P again this episode I think, Monica was CP, Laura was CPN, John was N? |
||
|
BlakeB717 |
|||
|
Posts: 2335 (11/19/09 08:09 PM) Registered user |
I'm not sure how Natalie being the boot target makes her MOR. She was completely irrelevent and hidden. Kelly would have been UTR last week but she got a
complex-y confessional at the reward. Many people get booted or are boot targets and get UTR lol. I guess some people haven't read the Edgic rules!!
Regarding Mick, I think I'm going with MOR. He got a pretty complex confessional about Monica, but that wouldn't be enough. However, his answer at TC and him being the one to take immunity from Laura seemed significant enough. He was there, had some good insight, but then wasn't there. MOR2 probably. His edit continues to be quiet but about observation, which (considering this clusterfuck of a merge), isn't a bad place for a winner to be. |
||
|
TehSizzlin |
|||
|
Posts: 20 (11/19/09 08:09 PM) |
John OTTN? I thought he was very CPN.
OTT for bad strategy? Really? |
||
|
BlakeB717 |
|||
|
Posts: 2336 (11/19/09 08:10 PM) Registered user |
Shambo was kinda nasty this week.
|
||
|
Hippochinfat |
|||
|
Posts: 323 (11/19/09 08:12 PM) |
Monica N? What?
My ratings: Russell: CP5 Jaison: CP2 Natalie: MOR2 Mick:UTR2 Laura: OTT5 (Probably an N but I'm not sure yet) John: CP4 Monica: CP3 Brett: UTR2 or OTTNN5 again Dave: MOR2 Shambo: OTTM5 |
||
|
Werwanderflugen |
|||
|
Posts: 286 (11/19/09 08:12 PM) Registered user |
Quick Ratings:
Laura: CPN Brett: UTR Dave: MOR Jaison: UTR John: CP Mick: MOR Monica: CP Natalie: UTRP Russell: CP Shambo: OTT(N?) Winners: 1. Russell 2. Mick |
||
|
troynuncdicit |
|||
|
Posts: 613 (11/19/09 08:13 PM) |
astroline wrote:I would say Mick & Jaison got about equal screentime in the camp scene with Monica, but I need to rewatch. |
||
|
SFC |
|||
|
Posts: 785 (11/19/09 08:13 PM) Registered user |
Blake, isnt the pre merge when the winner is supposed to be hidden, and then they're supposed to really pick up at the merge. This episode was bad for both
him and Natalie.
Right now, my rankings are Brett - UTR Dave - MOR Jaison - MOR John - CPN Laura - I really dont know Mick - UTR Monica - CP Natalie - UTRP. Russell - OTT (I could see CP, but no tone this time) Shambo - OTTM Winner Pick 1 Russell 2 Natalie 3 Jaison 4 Mick |
||
|
BlakeB717 |
|||
|
Posts: 2337 (11/19/09 08:14 PM) Registered user |
SFC wrote: The content of his confessionals have been consistent. Winners have consistency. |
||
|
Mypoody2 |
|||
|
Posts: 10645 (11/19/09 08:16 PM) Registered User |
BlakeB717 wrote: This was clearly Shambo's "sugar" episode. Very similar to what they did with sugar last season. She was the favorite and then they gave her one episode of showing her bad side when she booted Randy. The exact same thing as Shambo/Laura. From now on expect them to build up Shambo as the hero. This is what Survivor does, they do it so the edits are dynamic, not just positive or negative for everyone, everyone gets a good episode or a bad episode. Doesn't mean they want everyone to hate Shambo, its just their way of showing both sides of the story. Kind of like what they did with Rupert in Pearl Islands when he was screaming about the extra vote. I love that Survivor is dynamic and lets people form their own opinion outside of their preformed storyline by showing Shambo's bad sides as well... |
||
|
SFC |
|||
|
Posts: 786 (11/19/09 08:20 PM) Registered user |
BlakeB717 wrote: Winners also have recognition from the fans. We knew who Bob was at this point despite being UTR, we knew who JT was. And despite her UTR edit we know more about Natalie then we know about Mick. Who Is.... Brett.... No Idea Dave..... That Other Guy with the goofy face John: The Smart Galu Monica: Shambo's Rival Shambo: The Outsider of Galu who finally found a place Jaison: The Guy who got his second wind Mick.... We know he was a doctor as stated in Episode 1, but that was it, no reinforcement of it. Natalie: Russell's Sidekick and Socialite Russell: Mastermind who controls the game. |
||
|
panurge46 |
|||
|
Posts: 1542 (11/19/09 08:21 PM) Registered user |
MasterDarkNinja wrote: Mick and Jaison offered to vote out John to get Monica on their side. First impressions of the episode: No matter whatever rating you give her, Natalie not getting a confessional defending herself or telling us how she feels to see her cuddle-buddy Laura voted out is something to consider in analyzing her chances. It's another question mark. Will we get an answer next week?
Last Edited By: panurge46
11/19/09 08:24 PM.
Edited 1 times.
|
||
|
MasterDarkNinja |
|||
|
Posts: 2896 (11/19/09 08:21 PM) Registered User |
At first I thought Natalie was MOR, but thinking over the episode again I'll have to agree with those arguing she was UTR instead. I mean she got like
nothing after the reward from what I could remember, despite being a boot target.
I think Mick was probably MOR2, but I could still change my mind and go with UTR, I have to rewatch the episode to decide on this. I'm glad I wasn't the only one who thought that Shambo seemed N this episode, especially her cheering when Laura was eliminated from the IC, that really screamed N to me. I'm a bit unsure on Russel's tone, he was probably neutral this episode, but may have earned a M.. |
||
|
astroline |
|||
|
Posts: 2794 (11/19/09 08:22 PM) Registered user |
Even Danni's first 3 post-merge episodes were better than Mick's (MORP2/UTR2/MORP3). Mick's are UTR2/UTR1/MOR2(?) That's on par with Vecepia,
who is the most forgotten winner ever from 8 years ago and a woman. And he's only had 1 confessional in each. That's almost low as Parvati, who is also
a woman and one of the most notoriously low confessional-wise female characters ever. This was Mick's 3rd weak post-merge episode in a row, if you're
saying a MOR2 is enough to put him back on our lists, it's not. Russell is the most obvious winner ever, and this was another great episode for him. 10
episodes in and I still fail to see what Mick could say to the jury to get him votes over Russell or Natalie, not to mention BOTH of them. Like I've said
for weeks and weeks, Russell is the "distraction" but Mick is the "Edgic distraction", and in this case, the regular
"distraction" has a much more well-suited edit AND logic to be the winner.
|
||
Message board courtesy of Survivor Sucks member support.
Benevolent dictatorship courtesy of Survivor Sucks Admin Idoits.
