| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
WylDawg |
|||
|
It's really after the China finale that Amanda became the laughing stock of Sucks.
|
|||
Mikester |
|||
|
The only time I disliked Amanda was when she became part of Ozzmanda.
|
|||
unduli clone |
|||
|
Losing in second place and losing in eighteenth still = losing Amanda's benefited from the post-Palau emphasis on the physical pre-merge and the fact that she has large man hands, so she easily escapes the "weak female" pre-merge slaughter and waltzes through the "strong male" post-merge slaughter. she still sucks |
|||
Belligerent Ghoul |
|||
|
Blue = Best color ever! <3
Katie <3 |
|||
JackSparrowBauer |
|||
|
Amanda should've been higher. The amount of hate she gets here is ridiculous and most of it isn't even true. Like you said, she's obviously a
competent player, but when people bash her gameplay and praise Courtney's non-existant gameplay, it makes me want to vomit. And I don't even like
Amanda that much.
|
|||
tomash |
|||
|
Amanda is alright. She's a bit boring, but she doesn't really deserve all the hate she gets. |
|||
unduli clone |
|||
|
tbh, I don't think that the Courtney fans ever acknowledge any legitimacy about her gameplay other than somehow earning more jury votes than Amanda. Most seem to like her merely because she was snarky, and not because she had game (which she didn't). Likewise, the Amanda haters mostly bash her for her FTC performances and leeching on to Ozzy, which are both pretty legit sources of hatred. The rest of her gameplay generally goes unblemished by Sucks. |
|||
tomash |
|||
|
Amanda's FTC performances is probably the thing I like the most about her. Meltdowns <3 |
|||
WylDawg |
|||
|
6. Tom Westman (Survivor Palau)
Well, you all knew this one was coming. To be fair, a lot of people seem to be coming around to Tom on this board as of late, which is both surprising and refreshing. But there are still a good number of fanboys who are butthurt over his domination and cry every day that he was a chauvinist, homophobic bully and the worst winner ever. Really? Let's debunk all of these one by one shall we? Chauvinistic: How? When? Where? When did Tom ever looked down on women? A lot of his allies were women and he even complemented some of them. And interestingly enough, the women talked about forming an all-female alliance against him, so how come they don't get any flack? Tom never created a boys' club like Terry did. Maybe people making these allegations are refering to his oozing machismo. Sorry but he can't really help it. Like Bobby Jon perfectly said, Tom is a man amongst men. Homophobic: Why? Because he didn't become BFF with Coby? Maybe some of you failed to notice, but Coby pretty much went out of his way to be the loner on Koror by constantly playing victim. He was the one who immidiately showed disdain for Tom because of course he assumed Tom was a grown jock, like the ones who made his life a living hell in high school. Sad to say, but that's his problem. There might've been instances when Tom spoke poorly of Coby, but clearly most of the tribe did too as he got on everyone's nerves. Katie didn't get along with Coby either, does that make her a homophobe too? Bully: Because he made poor Ian quit? Again, that's Ian's problem, not Tom's. If Tom's mind games were sucessful in getting him the win, then more power to him. If you think he was condescending towards other people, it either means you probably have no spine and strong people like Tom make you want to go cry to mommy. Once again, that's your problem, not Tom's. There's no such things as bullies unless you let yourself bullied. May I remind you he won 6 to 1? If he's such a tyrant bully, seems to me like the jury would've told him to fuck off, not give him a near-unanimous win. And finally, worst winner ever: You frickin' kidding me?? Tom's game was near perfect. He took the steering wheel, never let go of it and got people to actually respect him for doing so. Clearly that's not a popular strategy with Sucksters, but it doesn't make it any less valid and it's actually pretty hard to pull off. Then of course you have those losers here saying he was "playing against a bunch of idiots" Newsflash: A LOT of winners were playing against a bunch of idiots, kudos to them for cashing in on it. What are they supposed to do, just let themselves voted out because that would make them unworthy? I don't think the Palau cast was THAT stupid to begin with. If Tom looked like he cakewalked to the end, maybe it's because he's just that damn good. You don't have to like him, but calling him a lousy winner is really of the dumbshit statements you can make here. |
|||
Katy Carney |
|||
|
I didn't even know people hated Tom.
|
|||
WylDawg |
|||
|
5. Penny Ramsey (Survivor Thailand)
A lot of you are probably going WTF? at this old school entry, probably because you joined Sucks several years after Thailand. So in case you weren't here, let me get you up to speed. Penny was hands down the most hated castaway in Survivor history. She was called the anti-Christ and had hate thread that would make your head spin. Although that thread grew into a classic entitled "Penny, wipe that smirk off your face you nasty c.unt) Now, do I like Penny? Not really, not as a person at least. She was a bit too catty and bitchy for my taste and not in a Courteney Yates kinda way. But really she didn't bother that much. Most of her hatred was from the legions of ShiiAnn fans at the moment. I like ShiiAnn, but her fans here at the time were the most rabid and delusional bunch ever. Calling ShiiAnn a great strategist and whatnot. They subsquently called Penny a racist c.unt because of her clashing with ShiiAnn, which really made my blood boil. Half of them didn't seem to realize that most of SookJai despised her, but Penny was the one who got branded a racist because she was her biggest enemy and was from the south. Some of them even called her a redneck version of Elisabeth Filarski, which is REALLY fucking ironic when you think about it. Then All-Stars came along, and once again 75% of the cast could not stomach ShiiAnn, including fellow minority Alicia, so her fans finally STFU about the racist allegations and realized that ShiiAnn had no social skills. But by then, the damage was pretty much done. I think Penny was actually a great character. Definitely the best female vilain since Jerri. She had all of SookJai wrapped around her finger. She gave people the impression that Jake and Ken were the leaders, but clearly she was the one calling the shots as many Sookies realized once they got booted. I actually wouldn't mind more Pennys on Survivor. |
|||
WylDawg |
|||
Katy Carney wrote: You probably weren't here during Palau and missed the tons of "How can they let that sexist, homophobic bully prick walk all over them??" posts. I'm pretty sure I've seen similar posts pop up when his name came up on the new All-Stars list as well. |
|||
JackSparrowBauer |
|||
|
Tom is definitely unfairly hated.
Penny was definitely a good character, and I WANT to like her, but I don't know what it is about her that I didn't like. Maybe it was her edit? I don't know. Rob C needs to show up on this list. |
|||
Katy Carney |
|||
|
Penny's legend as an evil cunning diva >> the reality of Penny, who was pretty boring imo. She's still prob my fav in all of Thailand just
because I like her character type.
|
|||
JackSparrowBauer |
|||
Katy Carney wrote: Yeah, that's exactly how I feel. Penny's one of those people that I have trouble putting a finger on how I feel about them. |
|||
Thailandsurvivor |
|||
Katy Carney wrote: I hate Tom. It's comes more from my hatred for Koror, but I never liked how he bullied people, especially Caryn. |
|||
survivorisdabest |
|||
|
AMANDA <3
|
|||
tomash |
|||
|
Tom and Kororownage <3 I don't really care for Penny one way or another, but she's definitely >>>>>>>> Shi Ann. |
|||
GauchGauch |
|||
|
I like Tom and I don't think he's hated. I have the impression people learned to appreciate his win (that's my case).
When I first watched Thaïland, I thougth Penny would be a huge villain, seeing how people were hating her. I was disappointed. Well, I hated her because Shii Ann was my favorite, but she was not really that bad. |
|||
WylDawg |
|||
|
4. Maggie Ausburn (Big Brother 6)
The following post is not to defend Maggie as a person, as I found her to be a two-face hypocritical twat, but to defend Maggie's gameplay. Every year on the BB board there are 38 "Rank the winners" thread and people always shove Maggie in last place or close. Now, you don't have to like, but calling her a shitty winner is borderline retarded and clearly comes from butthurt Janelle/Sovs fan. I was a HUGE Sovs fan BTW, I think I've made that pretty clear, but I'm also the first one to admit they were extremely retarded in their gameplay. But apparently I'm the only who sees this. The fact is Maggie played one of the best games of Big Brother, if not THE best. She gathered up a crew of misfits who didn't even like each other, turn them into a cult and got them to take bullets for her one by one, eventually going to the final 2 with the most obnoxious of the bunch and finally winning. All this despite America and Grodner's attempts to stop her by throwing Kaysar back in the game, which she sent him back with a huge FU to America. Now granted, it wasn't all her work per se, but let's face it, J-Blow, Ivette, April and Beau were her tentacles and Maggie was the mother fuckin' brains. She totally capitalized on the Sovs' stupid emotional gameplay of constantly seeking revenge against the last person who kicked one of their own out. She got all of them, including her own allies out of the house one by one with barely any blood on her hands, because her puppets did her dirty work for her by kamikazing themselves into the Sovs. So Janelle fans can feel free to still hate her as they please but if you still can't admit what an awsome game she played because your feelings are hurt, then you're a full fledge idiot. |
|||