
| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
Hippochinfat |
|||
|
Posts: 378 (12/02/09 05:30 PM) |
|
||
GoHomeAndEatYoRice |
|||
Survivor2345andbeyond wrote: And, Cristy was asked to do FvF, but didn't do it. |
|||
Shambo |
|||
|
On one hand, I would love to see Brian H play again....but it may be a good thing in that he cant top his complete dominance from Thailand. I havent heard
anything saying that he wouldnt come back, just that he'd want to be well compensated for a second time regardless of finish.
|
|||
Pulau Tiga |
|||
Survivor2345andbeyond wrote:Randy, Russell, and Rob M all fill a similar demographic. Same goes for Parvati/Danielle, Rupert/James/JT, Amanda/Candice, and Sandra/Courtney. There was a space to cast Terry, especially as the villain foil to Tom. Anyway, Christy, Gervase, and Kelly are all very understandable exclusions from every All-Star season ever. Gervase might have had a shot, but there were far more likable personalities from back in the day. By this point, he's forgotten. Kelly's nothing but a Survivor footnote, the flip-flopper who lost to Rich. And Christy was a novelty in Amazon, but left no lasting mark on the franchise. As for Sean Rector, I think he might have been a good choice for ASS had there been room for him, but now I don't think he's memorable enough to warrant a spot (especially since Rory would be a better choice for the obnoxious older black man, given that Sean himself has gotta be about 40 by now). And Todd's a caricature we've seen far too many times on the show who would easily be replaced by someone with more of a following (Rob C, Fairplay, or Kenny, for example). I agree though that Shane is an odd character to not bring back. He and Judd were wonderful villains and I'm surprised they have't been considered. I get why it'd be hard to fit in Ian, Mike, or Twila, but they'd both be interesting to see play again (and likely maintain enough of a residual fan base from their first performance on the show). Aside from Terry who I've previously mentioned, I would have expected to see Peih Gee for her underdog story in China, Brian for the next best thing to Rich and his infamy, Courtney Marit for her insanity, Dreamz for his unpredictability, Crystal for her loudness, Corrinne for her bitchiness, or Shambo for her...whatever it is Shambo possesses. And dammit, they should be busting their asses to get Colleen back! |
|||
sddorme.idolnoise |
|||
GoHomeAndEatYoRice wrote:THANK GOD |
|||
Maniacboy888 |
|||
sddorme wrote: Why? Your hatred makes no sense |
|||
sddorme.idolnoise |
|||
Maniacboy888 wrote:I think it's mostly because she's overrated. She sucked at strategy and she sucked in challenges and yet people like her. It doesn't make any sense. But if she was on, she'd leave first. |
|||
Maniacboy888 |
|||
|
I think 90% of sucks feels the same way about Monica
|
|||
sddorme.idolnoise |
|||
Maniacboy888 wrote:We're not really speaking about Monica right now, if that's your argument defending Christy then... |
|||
Maniacboy888 |
|||
|
I'll argue why Christy should have come back * The Ultimate Survivor underdog. Do you how hard she had it coming into a game about social mobility when she
could only hear. She easily had America's heart, thats not being overrated, its being loved. Especially when she was shunned to the older women when Jenna,
Heidi and Shawna were rude to her. She is one of the Amazon's most remembered and loved players and she would have been a extremely smart person to bring
back in future seasons. Sucked in challenges? Since when did that decided whether or not your an all star? Its all about being a character.
|
|||
novaya |
|||
Survivor2345andbeyond wrote: 1. Shane is absolutely obnoxious and one of the more unbearable elements of Panama. Plus his blog is kinda weird and psychotic. No. 2. Ian I can take or leave. Both Ian and Katie annoyed the piss out of me, but then again I'm not a Palau fan in general so I'm biased. Meh. 3. ITA on Twila. No arguments there. Yes. 4. Eh, with Skupin I feel that his story arc is closed. I kind of prefer it that way, rather than "He fell in a fire: give him another chance!" Ruins the ~magic~ of that epic moment. No. 5. Christy is a worthless stuntcast and I despised her in Amazon. It's like bringing back Chad from Vanuatu because he had one leg~~!! and little else. No. 6. I agree with Gervase, but mostly just as an appropriate S1 representative out of others that have not yet returned. Little more. Yes. 7. Sean was a shitstain on Marquesas and I wanted to smash my TV with a banjo every time he was on it. Worthless. Neleh, Vecepia, and John are all far better reps. No. 8. For Kelly, see Gervase. But I'd prefer Gervase tbh. Meh. 9. Todd is a HELL yes for me. Yes. So I agree with 3 of your 9. My 9 would be: 1. Gervase Peterson (S1) 2. Elisabeth Hasselbeck (S2) 3. John Carroll (S4) 4. Brian Heidk (S5) 5. Lydia Morales (S11) 6. Twila Tanner (S9) 7. Terry Deitz (S12) 8. Peih-Gee Law (S15) 9. Crystal Cox (S17) |
|||
sddorme.idolnoise |
|||
Maniacboy888 wrote:So because of her disability, she's good? That's retarded. And Christy was against Jenna, so Heidi and Shawna went against them. I have some respect for her, but she just sucked at the game. I didn't say she needed to be strong, but for some people like Ozzy, the only reason to like him is his strength (which is retarded). |
|||
sddorme.idolnoise |
|||
|
Elisabeth was invited back for all-stars, but declined.
|
|||
ThrowMeGabon |
|||
|
And she'd never go starve for a month at this point...she hit the reality show jackpot with The View.
|
|||
Shred |
|||
|
Christy would have been hilarious in Micronesia
|
|||
Mondogecko |
|||
|
Sean and Shane would just add so much drama and entertainment to any season you put them on. Casting dropped the ball big time on these 2.
|
|||
MajorTom |
|||
|
Sierra, Crystal, Peih-Gee, Todd, Colleen. Aside from that don't care, but I was sure I'd see these people again. But gee, seeing Cirie, Amanda, Parvati and James again for the thousandth time makes up for it...
DILORENZOWNAGE
|
|||
ElisabethNelehHeidiRok |
|||
|
Posts: 1628 (12/02/09 11:01 PM) Registered User |
Borneo-Kelly, Gervase, Colleen Australian Outback-Rodger, Elisabeth Africa-Kelly Marquesas-Sean, Neleh Thailand-Brian, Helen, Penny Amazon-Heidi, Christy Pearl Islands-Christa Vanuatu-Chris -even though I loathe him Palau-Katie, Jenn? Guatemala-Judd, Rafe, Jamie, Cindy, Danni -very underrated season Exile Island-Terry, Sally Cooks-Nobody Fiji-Stacy, Earl China-Jaime, Peih-Gee, Todd Micronesia-Alexis Gabon-Ken, Crystal Tocantins-Steven, Sierra, Taj Samoa-Natalie |
||
SirCrocodilep |
|||
Shred wrote: |
|||
JLK Name |
|||
|
In the OP's list, I agree with:
Sean Rector - Sean was funny as hell! Thats why I entertained Marquesas so much it wasn't a great season but it was fun! Christy Smith - She was my favorite in S6, and my first favorite from Survivor and she was a star of her season, it would be weird if she was in S16 because S6 was so long ago but she should be in ASS3 Twila - Well she didn't accept the offer to be in S16 Shane - Like Judd, he's an All-Stars-snubbed |
|||