S-19 Edgic (editing and logic) in Survivor Speculation Forum

0 Points

S-19 Edgic (editing and logic)

Started By	Comment
Katy Carney		#4341	[-]
Posts: 9544 (12/03/09 08:18 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	I can resist everything except temptation. Remove this ad astroline wrote: Katy Carney wrote: Shambo was the clearest case of OTTN5 of anyone on this show ever. Katy I actually disagree. The music and the editing during the first scene with the chickens was VERY sympathetic. They would have left that out if they wanted us to just go right to how crazy she was acting with the cooking. They made sure we knew of her positive connection with the chickens. She's OTTM5. I saw that completely differently. I thought the music was mocking her, actually. She was talking about how they were her only friends and they spoke back to her.
craig		#4342	[-]
Posts: 16587 (12/03/09 08:20 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Shambo is OTTN - crazy, mean, and dumb. Look how vindictive she was at Dave for questioning her cooking. Look at the over-confident confessional after TC where she exalts in her power. And how she's made to look a fool at TC for being out of it stategically (culminating in Laura's comment). The mystery if why the episode was all Shambo and Russell, when Galu clearly had an option to tie the vote 4-4 (John voted for Mick not Dave). Good episode for Jaison - the relative position of the other 3 Foa doesn't change much.
zzzazzzazzz		#4343	[-]
Posts: 1038 (12/03/09 08:20 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	The Purple Parrot wrote: Mick was INV up until the segment before TC. I had gotten my hopes up... Jaison had a better episode tonight than Mick. Much more insight. I agree, Mick had nothing for up to 3/4 of the episode. He got a couple of sentences in with Jaison and Russel, each seperate occasions. Then he got that insightful TCQ. I would say MOR3 for him, but then again, I can see some people giving him UTR2.
The Purple Parrot		#4344	[-]
Posts: 11880 (12/03/09 08:20 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Yeah, I definitely thought the chicken scene made her look like a looney.
SFC		#4345	[-]
Posts: 836 (12/03/09 08:22 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	They made her looney yes (OTT) but it was a positive looney. (P) Followed by all the negativity OTTM
Hippochinfat		#4346	[-]
Posts: 381 (12/03/09 08:22 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Jaison had a great episode, but to me, especially from the recap it seems like he's getting a redemption arc, someone who will be voted off near the end and will have learned from the experience. If I had to order the winner possibilities it would be: Mick Jaison Russell Natalie had a terrible episode tonight, and she was disqualified in my eyes a while ago.
Shred		#4347	[-]
Posts: 365 (12/03/09 08:23 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	I hope Brett wins this season to see what you would all say
Jedijake		#4348	[-]
Posts: 6016 (12/03/09 08:23 PM) MESS member Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Jaison looks like a classic winner with a redemption/growth story attached. Forget about all of the things that may have happened before the merge, what a story he actually does have. Natalie-wow, oh wow-to think that any of us considered her to have a shot at all was pretty embarrassing.
Kitty Pryde1		#4349	[-]
Posts: 10957 (12/03/09 08:25 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	While I still think Jaison is MUCH better than Mick as a pick, this episode was far better than the triple UTR Mick got in the past three episodes. But still, this episode looks great for Jaison compared to the others.
zzzazzzazzz		#4350	[-]
Posts: 1040 (12/03/09 08:27 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	I can resist everything except temptation. Remove this ad I don't know, I really think that Jaison is the most viable right now. Even though he had a roller-coaster ride of a tone history, he's been getting consistant airtime. I'll still admit that I think Mick still has a great shot, even with the string of UTR. Russel, in my opinion, is the dark horse. Jaison Mick Russell
SFC		#4351	[-]
Posts: 837 (12/03/09 08:28 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Also quick question, why the hell was Natalie the Sprint Player of the week canidate, she was UTR1 this episode for cryin out loud. Jaison is now the #1 pick edgically
OnlyTheHunter		#4352	[-]
Posts: 2088 (12/03/09 08:28 PM) Edgician Reply Quote More Recent Posts	love ya Jedi, but Jaison looks like a classic winner with a redemption/growth story attached. Forget about all of the things that may have happened before the merge, what a story he actually does have No, redemption is needed because the edit killed him early. He has a great story, but it's not Edgic to forget about the pre-merge. But I'm sure you know that. I agree, it was nice to see him win something. I was prepared to see Dave win the IC and Jaison to crumble in a ball. Michael
Joss Wolfe		#4353	[-]
Posts: 1199 (12/03/09 08:29 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	1. Shambo was crazy acting with the chickens. WTF? you speak chicken now? 2. Shambo was crazy in her cooking. 3. Shambo was completely batshit, Jan insane with her psychic power dream 4. Her psychic power dream was proven false when she so adamantly demonstrated her cluelessness at Tribal council. Shambo was a textbook OTTN5 (Idiot edition) Any sympathy shown for Shambo would be the kind of sympathy you have for a 3 legged, blind dog that keeps humping out the inside of a toaster, time and time again despite electrocution.
Kitty Pryde1		#4354	[-]
Posts: 10959 (12/03/09 08:29 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	The only positive thing about Natalie was that she got a lot of credit for hanging in there with Dave and Jaison.
SFC		#4355	[-]
Posts: 838 (12/03/09 08:30 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	And the shower scene, but yeah abysmal episode.
McPhever224		#4356	[-]
Posts: 443 (12/03/09 08:31 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Kitty Pryde1 wrote: The only positive thing about Natalie was that she got a lot of credit for hanging in there with Dave and Jaison. But that's the only thing we were really seen of her, so aren't we left with a positive impression of her, I mean correct me if I'm wrong, but that's how I look at tone.
OnlyTheHunter		#4357	[-]
Posts: 2089 (12/03/09 08:33 PM) Edgician Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Natalie got the music at the shower scene. It was funny, actually. That's visibility with no characterization. Except that everyone would have their eyes on her at the moment. No way the show would exculpt that. Susie was olay in the bath, but...this was Darrah territory. I was hoping she'd bid on the next item, and have to come get it. Alas. About the only mistake the edit made was overdoing the "Dave is gone" with too much time left. I knew then it was a decoy. TC was again, the audience knows...and John dooooooooeeesssn't. Oh snap! Michael
Warrior		#4358	[-]
Posts: 2994 (12/03/09 08:45 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts
craig		#4359	[-]
Posts: 16589 (12/03/09 08:48 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Also quick question, why the hell was Natalie the Sprint Player of the week canidate, she was UTR1 this episode for cryin out loud. Because normal people give more weigfht to challenge visiblity than edgic does. Her placing 3rd in a strength based IC and getting complements frrom Probst is more impressive than a guy winning the challenge. Bet that moment and the shower scene were more memorable for the average viewer than anything MOR3 Mick said. Natalie is UTRP1 again. Last Edited By: craig 12/03/09 08:52 PM. Edited 1 times.
astroline		#4360	[-]
Posts: 2856 (12/03/09 08:50 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	I can resist everything except temptation. Remove this ad Thanks, Warrior. Initial ratings. AIGA Brett -- INV1 Dave -- MOR3 Jaison -- CPP3 John -- OTTN4 Mick -- MOR3 Monica -- UTR1 Natalie -- UTRP1 Russell H. -- CP4 Shambo -- OTTM5 Winner's list... 1. Russell H.

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

S-19 Edgic (editing and logic)