"John, you can remain selfish and keep your pie, or you can share four pieces of pie with your tribe members."
So basically, you take it for yourself, and everyone votes you off the next TC.
And if you share it, no one would take you to the finals.

| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
gwu12crh |
Reappearance of the Guatemala Car Twist HATRED |
Lead | |
|
"Cindy, you can take the car for yourself, or you can give everyone here a car."
"John, you can remain selfish and keep your pie, or you can share four pieces of pie with your tribe members." So basically, you take it for yourself, and everyone votes you off the next TC. And if you share it, no one would take you to the finals. |
|||
JVJrule |
|||
|
Um. They did this in Micronesia with Jason Siska and the candy so that people would not vote him off. It worked since Ozzy left that episode. I'm not sure
about Natalie (S16) and her cake though if Jeff gave her the opportunity to share.
|
|||
JackSparrowBauer |
|||
|
Then Russell started going Rafe in his confessionals "John should've gave the pie blah blah blah"
|
|||
dashbrdparadise |
|||
|
Wow, Survivor's budget has gone down.
|
|||
Quiddity |
|||
JackSparrowBauer wrote:At least he didn't act like being given the car was his right and John's obligation like Rafe was with Cindy. |
|||
JackSparrowBauer |
|||
Quiddity wrote: Agreed. Rafe started to kill his own game with that move. hopefully Russell shot himself in the foot, too and will get out next week. |
|||
VTRealityAddict |
|||
|
Um...pie does not =a car. even REALLY good pie.
That being said John is still an idiot for not sharing. |
|||
Shred |
|||
|
Cindy is right for keeping a car
John is 0_0 for not sharing. |
|||
Double Edged Sword |
|||
|
There's a chance that John would have gotten to keep his pie if he gave the four others the whole pie. (Think Matt in Amazon)
|
|||
Apprentice Talker |
|||
|
The last car twist was in Fiji when Yau-Man did not took the car and gave it to Dreamz.
|
|||
SPunKeeMonKee |
|||
|
I don't think it had an impact at all. It was just pie, I bet everyone forgot about it after it happened.
|
|||
gwu12crh |
|||
|
True.
But John still got voted off à la Cindy. |
|||
TequilaVaquero |
|||
|
People voted John off because of strategy. Him eating the pie had no bearing on that, whether he gave them the pie or not, they would have voted him out if
necessary/advantageous.
|
|||
JaMalle |
|||
Quiddity wrote:Yeah, Russel wasn't a douchebag like Rafe. Rafe took the moral high ground due to Danni's influence. Russel said the obvious: when you have a choice to please others, don't pass that chance up just because you want to be a selfish douchebag. Believe me, Russel would NOT have wanted to give away the pie, but he sure as hell would have. I think these twists are better on a scale like this where it's food. I think Cindy's twist was a tad bit unfair however... I would have still given the cars away though. |
|||
TequilaVaquero |
|||
|
But hell, at least Cindy walked out of there with a car. Imagine if she gave away the cars, didn't get one for herself, then got voted out. She would be
considered the stupidest bitch to play the game.
Remember when Rob gave up his video in ASS so everyone could get their letters? Everyone said "It was just him kissing our ass." |
|||
Maximus20 |
|||
JaMalle wrote:Agreed |
|||
Shred |
|||
TequilaVaquero wrote:If Cindy would have gave the cars away Lydia would have left. There is no way moral Rafe would have voted Cindy off after that. Cindy could have won the next immunity, Danni would have left and won the last immunity and then Rafe would go home. Cindy could have won. Oh well she still had every right to keep that car. |
|||
Apprentice Talker |
|||
|
I remember back in Guatemala. Six cars arrive at the Survivor Auction site where they gave in each contestant.
|
|||