
| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
Kubin |
|||
|
|
|||
qwerty |
|||
|
An Second Chance season could go either way, being very entertaining or being very boring. To me, a Second Chance season should not just consist of non-jurors
and instead including castaways that were voted off due to being outnumbered in the merge, twists or even a hidden immunity idol.
Borneo None Outback Africa None. Marquesas Hunter: Hero-like survivor, wanted to play a honest game. Unfortunately, he was a victim of Boston Rob's plan. Thailand Robb: Huge character Amazon None Pearl Islands Darrah: The jury twist really screwed him. He is a strong physical threat and will be fun to see how he will be take out. Vanuatu Dolly: Tried to play the game. Palau None Guatemala Amy: I read her blog and found her quite interesting, would love to see her play. Panama None. Cook Islands Cao Boi: Everybody loves a little of Cao Boi, right? Billy: Big Billy was a funny character, would make a great choice for Survivor as he will help them market. Flica: Her personality stands out and would most likely have someone she doesn't like. Fiji Michelle: People says she an All-Star, but I don't think so. Pretty much screwed by a twist and she knows the game. China Dave: A huge character that people love to hate. Aaron: Aaron proved to be a huge physical threat, but was screwed by the Tribal Swap. Micronesia Jason or Erik: Jason was outnumbered by the merge and proved to be a great threat, although he did not play the idol and paid the price. Erik on the other hand gave away his necklace and screwed himself. Alexis: She was voted out due to the Hidden Immunity Idol, some may consider her an All-Star, but she isn't Gabon Michelle: She seems like a really interesting character, and a Second Chance season couldn't do without some bodies? Ace: He was played but he also played the game quite well. Tocantins Joe: He was removed due to an injury. I was really interested to see him playing, considering that he wasn't really part of the Jalapao's alliance Carolina: Huge character Samoa Marisa: Being outspoken and, somewhat, intelligent, pretty much screwed her Samoa Betsy: She can read character well and will make a great "sidekick". Ben: Crazy personality and is valuable to the tribe since he knows how to "survive". This leaves us with a cast of 20. I would divide the tribe into two tribe; Tribe One 1) Ben (M) 2) Marisa (F) 3) Michelle (Fiji) (F) 4) Ace (M) 5) Billy (M) 6) Dolly (F) 7) Aaron (M) 8) Kimmi (F) 9) Jason or Erik (M) 10) Aaron (M) Tribe Two 1) Darrah (M) 2) Michelle (Gabon) (F) 3) Betsy (F) 4) Hunter (M) 5) Cai Boi (M) 6) Alexis (F) 7) Carolina (F) 8) Amy (F) 9) Joe (M) 10) Flica (F) For replacements: It could be Spencer or Sydney from Tocantins |
|||
tullfan2 |
|||
|
My Second Chance Cast (although also rans is a better name for the season's theme since any returning player is getting a second chance to play even if
they won their first time):
Criteria for selection: - no one from seasons earlier than All Stars (eliminates the risk that the contestants changed too much and are too different - eg. does anyone expect Robb Zbacnik to be as immature 8 years after he played the first time or Gina Crews to be as attractive as she was 8 years ago?). - no contestants that appeared in more than 7 episodes - contestants are selected because they were big characters or they were screwed over by a twist or were medevaced/injured or because they are eye candy or because they played hard in challenges. Men: Russell Swan Ace Joel Anderson Cao Boi James Miller Rocky Aaron Spencer Jeff Wilson Joe Women: Angie Sydney Amy Mia Flica Wanda Sherea Jacquie Marisa female from season 21 (I could pick timber Tina but already have Amy (who replaced her on S11) and Wanda) |
|||
ssseeeaaann |
|||
|
Might as well include Paloma and Jessica de Ben on your lists, they are friends with Erika Shay.
|
|||
sddorme.idolnoise |
|||
ssseeeaaann wrote: Paloma may deserve another chance |
|||
chapera rocks |
|||
|
Russell S. will not be on. He has a predisposition to low blood pressure.
|
|||
Jho |
|||
|
Posts: 452 (12/05/09 10:57 AM) Registered User |
qwerty wrote: Lol what? |
||
ElisabethNelehHeidiRok |
|||
|
Posts: 1648 (12/05/09 11:20 AM) Registered User |
I see a Second Chance looking like this
Men Mike Skupin (Australian Outback) Silas Gaither (Africa) Hunter Ellis (Marquesas) Jeff Wilson (Palau) Cao Boi Bui (Cook Islands) JP Calderon (Cook Islands) Dave Cruser (China) Joel Anderson (Micronesia) Ace Gordon (Gabon) Ben Browning (Samoa) Other Possibilities: Jonathan Libby, Mikey B, Robb Z, Spencer, Russell S Women Kimmi Kappenberg (Australian Outback) Gina Crews (Marquesas) Nicole Delma (Pearl Islands) Dolly Neely (Vanuatu) Wanda Shirk (Palau) Tina Scheer (Exile Island) Flicka (Cook Islands) Ashley Massaro (China) Tracy Wolf (Micronesia) Sydney Wheeler (Tocantins) Other Possibilities: Amy O'Hara, Betsy Bolan, Lindsey Richter, Kim Mullen, Jacquie Berg |
||
Shred |
|||
ElisabethNelehHeidiRok wrote:THIS list But I live Flicka but I don't see her being cast. Poor Russell Swan |
|||
SomeGoodBubbles |
|||
|
I think i could see them starting out the game with Johnathan L. and Wanda S. from Palau getting to be the tribe leaders and choosing their own tribes. Since a
tribe selection took them out of the game without having to be voted out it might be appropriate that they get to build there tribe on a Second Chance edition
|
|||
SirCrocodilep |
|||
|
I personally believe that 2nd Chance castaways will possibly be the most cutthroats of them all.
|
|||
Ahora |
|||
Shred wrote:Well, I do remember Probst did say that he would love for Flicka to play again, so never say never. |
|||
cindidindi76 |
|||
|
Good lord, how many threads about a "Second Chance" edition do we need?
|
|||
Shred |
|||
Ahora wrote:Really? Oh I would love to see her again. She is such a underrated character on the show. And if they just had booted Ozzy in her tribal she would have been in the final 4. Well maybe, Ozzy did help win those challenges for Aitu. |
|||
sddorme.idolnoise |
|||
cindidindi76 wrote: |
|||
SirCrocodilep |
|||
|
A lots.
|
|||
Fokkerdr1 |
Sorry | ||
|
Sorry to destroy this thread. It will be an all original cast.
http://www.cbs.com/casting/survivor/Application.pdf |
|||
ElisabethNelehHeidiRok |
|||
|
Posts: 1654 (12/06/09 10:58 AM) Registered User |
So? Doesnt mean a thing. |
||
Fokkerdr1 |
|||
|
^There is a very clear desclaimer on the new app. IN BIG BLACK LETTERS JUST FOR PEOPLE LIKE YOU,
that says it's not an Allstars application for season 21 and 22. |
|||
Chinchilla23 |
|||
|
2nd chance edition (to qualify you did not make final 10 merge) should include these 20 players:
|
|||