| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
 mennonite |
|||
|
Posts: 55 (12/05/09 09:59 AM) |
Shamwow- OTTM5
Russ- CPN4 Natalie- UTRP1 Brett- INV1 John- CP4 Jaison- CPP3 Mick- UTR1 (Still don't get Mick's "super" edit) Dave- MORN3 |
||
|
mennonite |
|||
|
Posts: 56 (12/05/09 10:00 AM) |
Monica- UTR2
|
||
 MasterDarkNinja |
|||
|
Posts: 2932 (12/05/09 10:26 AM) Registered User |
Here's my current ratings after 1 rewatch, going to get in another before making them final.
Brent: INV1 Dave: MOR3 Jaison: MORP3 John: CP4 Mick: UTR3 (I'm sorry but I just can't understand the MOR's for him other then his VF numbers, it's like someone said Thursday night, casual viewers probably remember more of VF visibility 1 Natalie then they do of VF visibility 3 Mick, that means Mick was UTR this episode, not MOR, UTR3's are rare but not unprecedented, see Nick in S12) Monica: UTR1 Natalie: UTRP2 (I agree with whoever said it that her challenge visibility was enough to boost her up to a 2, she was more visible/memorable then the other 1's.) Russell: CP4 Shambo: OTTN5 |
||
|
OnlyTheHunter |
|||
|
Posts: 2094 (12/05/09 12:06 PM) Edgician |
gr said
Hi, OTH, the fact that so many people are staying up so late to discuss this episode reveals that a lot of people are finding the season intriguing - and that's a good thing.Cool. I knew you'd see Mick makes sense, and I know you've seen Natalie a while. I was really probing to see what you said about Jaison. That mirrors my thoughts exactly. He's now the person fans start to root for, and when he does go, his prior edit comes back. Edgic requires a long memory Asia song, not deciding in an immediate Asia song. (Only Time Will Tell and Heat Of The Moment. Sorry, I just watched an 80's countdown.) Natalie makes sense (subtracting the previously exculpting UTR1 episode 1 and an INV) the way you say. Mick does too. His groundwork was let someone else take the reigns, but at the same time, we know he is smart and makes the right decisions. Win, and that's an easy thing to fall back on. Only Time Will Tell. And if Mick wins, is it true The Smile Has Left Your Eyes? (Okay, I bought the Asia albums too.) Michael |
||
|
Hippochinfat |
|||
|
Posts: 388 (12/05/09 12:09 PM) |
MasterDarkNinja wrote: I agree with an UTR3 for Mick, he really didn't come off as MOR to me, especially not MOR3. Natalie though should definetly remain a 1, and I don't understand the P. Oh, and in other news Brett has beaten Christa for the record of the INV1 latest into the game. |
||
|
Brazil Luvs Ami |
|||
|
Posts: 350 (12/05/09 01:04 PM) |
I think that Monica had much more presence in the episode than Natalie, I just cannot understand why people are giving 1 for Monica e 2 for Natalie. And when I
watched I thought that Monica's speech about loyalty was very positive, while Natalie was, imo, the entire episode in the background and I cannot see a P
for her whatsoever.
Ratings: John - MORN4 Brett - INV Dave - MOR3 Jaison - CPP3 Mick - MOR3 Monica - UTRP2 Natalie - UTR1 Russell - CP4 Shambo - OTTM5 Winner - Jaison (yes, I changed my winner pick from Russell to Jaison) |
||
|
rioothello |
|||
|
Posts: 69 (12/05/09 01:32 PM) |
LOL when Mick's name came up, my Dad was all like "Who's Mick?" And he has been watching all season.
|
||
|
Shorvivor |
|||
|
Posts: 257 (12/05/09 02:22 PM) |
I also agree with UTR3 for Mick, he didn't have enough material to warrant an MOR3.
John - CPN4 Brett - INV1 Dave - MOR3 Jaison - CPP4 Mick - UTR3 or MOR2 Monica - UTRP2 Natalie - UTRP2 Russell - CP4 Shambo - OTTM5 |
||
|
danyul0911 |
|||
|
Posts: 54 (12/05/09 02:37 PM) |
Brett - INV (I love it)
Dave - MORM3 (N for the argument with Sambo, but P for his challenge display) Jaison - CPP3 (We definitely got in his head about why he chose the things he did and even for the upcoming vote next week) John - CPN4 (We understood everything as to why he did what he did, even though he came off as condescending) Monica - UTR1 Mick - UTR3 (Hidden till the end when his visibility spiked, but still a good UTR unlike a couple of earlier ones at the merge) Natalie - UTRP1 (Her getting a call out from Jeff warrants the P methinks) Russell - CP4 Shambo - OTTM5 (Shown as out of the loop and psychotic but there were parts in the beginning meant to induce sympathy) |
||
|
WhoLetTheBlTCHout |
|||
|
Posts: 253 (12/05/09 02:45 PM) I don't take hints
|
I truly advise people to REWATCH before they VOTE.
|
||
|
CrystalOwnage |
|||
|
Posts: 5485 (12/05/09 03:33 PM) |
Final Ratings:
Brett- INV1 Dave-MOR3 Mick- UTR3 (this is actually the perfect rating for him...Didn't think of it because it's such an odd rating) Jaison-CPP4 Russell-CP4 John-CPN4 Natalie-UTR2 Shambo- OTTN5 Red=ratings that changed from last time |
||
|
astroline |
|||
|
Posts: 2863 (12/05/09 03:47 PM) Registered user |
I don't see the UTR's for Mick. Sure it wasn't the most narrative or insightful MOR ever, but he definitely came into his own at the end and was a
focal point in both important conversations between himself/Russell and himself/Jaison. Either way, I don't think it was a good episode for him. He was
made to look like a coattail rider of Russell's and Jaison had to tell him why his opinions on Shambo were wrong, and we saw that Jaison was right and Mick
was wrong with no evidence to back it up.
Final ratings (after doing Spanish homework all day, I'm surprised I'm not typing in Spanish right now). AIGA Brett -- INV1 Dave -- MOR3 Jaison -- CPP3 John -- CPN4 Mick -- MOR3 Monica -- UTR1 Natalie -- UTRP1 Russell H. -- CP4 Shambo -- OTTM5 Winner's list... 1. Russell H. (for the 6th week in a row) Eliminated -- Everyone else but maybe Monica and Jaison |
||
|
ZombieLinda |
|||
|
Posts: 9059 (12/05/09 03:49 PM) |
Polly Sue deserves an unprecedented UTRPP. She wasn't shown much, but all of her scenes were all, "HEY AMERICA LOOK AT THIS CUTE THING NATALIE IS
DOING!!!!!" Truly unique.
I honestly don't think she talks strategy much, even in her confessionals. All of her voting confessionals are super generic and she always says "just sticking with the plan! this is what my alliance wants!" so it's not like she could really get tons of airtime showing her thought process. Even without much airtime, she gets just enough to be known by the general public. She's easily in most people's top 3 favorites, and that's assuming they like both Russell AND Shambo. The editors edit for the masses, not edgictards. ^_^ There really isn't a clear cut *winners edit* this season (that is until we see who wins and adjust our opinions on the editing accordingly) but I maintain Polly's season premiere winners quote just came 3 episodes late. <3 
|
||
|
zzzazzzazzz |
|||
|
Posts: 1046 (12/05/09 03:49 PM) |
I think Natalie's definitely UTR1. She was literally in the background the whole time, except for that Auction bid and her immunity challenge performance. But the time spent on both weren't long at all and she was totally ignored during a camp. Maybe a "P" for Jeff's compliment, but other than that, it's straight up UTR1. |
||
|
astroline |
|||
|
Posts: 2864 (12/05/09 03:56 PM) Registered user |
And here's my updated chart, and yeah ZL I agree that Natalie was UTRP for sure.
|
||
|
ZombieLinda |
|||
|
Posts: 9061 (12/05/09 04:05 PM) |
NOT UTRP. UTRPP!
|
||
|
cantthinkofaname |
|||
|
Posts: 1601 (12/05/09 04:43 PM) Registered User |
mennonite wrote:....seriously? |
||
|
cantthinkofaname |
|||
|
Posts: 1602 (12/05/09 04:46 PM) Registered User |
Hippochinfat wrote:X |
||
|
cantthinkofaname |
|||
|
Posts: 1603 (12/05/09 04:50 PM) Registered User |
Shorvivor wrote:rating and visibility are separate. So whether you think Mick is UTR or MOR, he's a 3 for both or 2 for both |
||
|
getting real |
|||
|
Posts: 1946 (12/05/09 05:07 PM) Registered User |
Zombie Linda said:
The editors edit for the masses, not edgictards. ^_^Concisely, if not elegantly, put. 
Thank you for your epic Amanda Micronesian offering, BTW. The most laughs I've ever had from a satire of a reality show! |
||
Message board courtesy of Survivor Sucks member support.
Benevolent dictatorship courtesy of Survivor Sucks Admin Idoits.
