- Survivor Sucks
- Lions, Tigers, Survivors - Oh My!
- Survivor Spoilers
- MESS Hall Tribal Council
- MESS Hall Archive
- Survivor Speculation
- Survivor: The Future
- The Amazing Race
- Big Brother
- Big Brother - PAST SEASONS
- The Apprentice
- American Idol
- American Idol PAST SEASONS
- The Mole
- Lost
- Other Shows that Suck
- Off Topic
- Clubs that Suck. No, Really.
- The Dump
- Monster Island
- Purgatory
- FAQ
- In Memory, 9/11/01
The "What If" Game
| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
 Maniacboy888 |
|||
|
Posts: 2614 (01/01/09 01:28 AM) Registered user |
|
||
 unduli clone |
|||
|
Posts: 3814 (01/01/09 02:21 AM) Registered User |
In regards to FvF, Coby and Eliza have both said that they're pretty sure the original plan was a full-ASS season, but they changed it at the last minute to shake it up on the pre-game alliances. |
||
|
Michaelf7777777 |
Some More What If Scenario's | ||
|
Posts: 4 (12/07/09 02:31 PM) |
I know that this thread hasn't been posted in for a while but it has been interesting reading your theories about what would happen.
Heidi wins immunity
Rob wants to keep both his F2 options and sees likeable Butch as a threat so agrees to flip to the girls in return for making Butch a target (and possibly some non-game related reasons as well) Jenna 2 (Butch, Matt) Butch 3 (Heidi, Jenna, Rob C)
Final 4 Jenna wins immunity Rob sees Heidi as a jury/ final immunity threat so switches back to Matt to force a tie. However Heidi beats Rob in teh tiebreaker and the flip flopper par excellence leaves in 4th Heidi 2 (Matt, Rob C) Rob C 2 (Heidi, Jenna)
Final 3 Heidi wins immunity Heidi votes out the goat rather than her friend Matt 1 (Heidi)
Final Tribal Council Dave - Jenna Deena - Jenna Alex - Jenna Christy - Heidi Butch - Heidi Rob C - Jenna? Matt - Jenna Jenna wins Survivor Amazon: 4-3 or 5-2
What if Christy Sides with the Girls at F6 in S6
|
||
|
Pulau Tiga |
|||
|
Posts: 5757 (12/08/09 05:18 PM) Registered user |
Michaelf7777777 wrote:Nope. Rob intended to boot the girls in 5th and 4th. Matt was his goat and Butch was the easy FIC competition. With Heidi immune, Jenna goes instead. If Heidi wins F4 Immunity, Butch is a goner and Heidi goes on to win the game just like Jenna did. If Heidi doesn't pull off the F4 miracle that Jenna pulled and Matt has the necklace, her ass is grass, Rob takes Mateo to the F2 with him, and Cesternino wins according to his plan. As for your other hypothetical, I can't see any of that happening. Even if Jenna/Heidi got Christy to side with them to save her own ass, Matt wins F5 Immunity and I don't see Christy sticking with her enemies for another round now that Rob, the guy who truly turned on her, is out of the picture. Even if the girls somehow do stick together, Heidi and Jenna would take each other to the F2, no doubt. They're not gonna honor any desperate deals they had made with Christy earlier. |
||
|
AveryC |
|||
|
Posts: 88 (12/08/09 08:24 PM) |
Long wordy post ahead.
There's been a lot of discussion about what if seasons which Final Threes were actually Final Twos of late, many of whcih are inaccurate representations. What people forget is that in the change to a Final Two the immunity challenge order is altered. The Final Four challenge is now held at three, and the Final Five Maze challenge is moved to Four to reflect other seasons. Thus a new immunity challenge is introduced at the Final Five, or somewhere else previously. If we look at Cook Islands there are two possible boot choices: Ozzy or Adam. I fully believe that Ozzy was out if he lost immunity to five, so we have two outcomes at this point: Ozzy gets immunity or he doesn't. If he does then we get what happened in reality. Adam out at five then Ozzy wins the Maze challenge, where Sundra loses at fire. Plus he wins the Final Three immunity. The question is whether he takes Becky or Yul. He thought he had Nate, Parvati, Adam and Sundra guranteed at this point, so it actually wouldn't suprise me if he took Yul over Becky. He'd lose to either if them however. If Ozzy does get voted out at five things are more complicated. It's unclear who out of Yul or Adam was ahead in the Maze challenge puzzle and either could've won. if Yul wins Adam is obviously gone. If Adam wins then Sundra goes whether Adam votes with her or not. Without Adam being there Sundra wins the final immunity and could take either person. I think it's unlikely Adam had a chance at that Final immunity, so I can safely say Yul would win it and take Becky. So we have several possible scenarios. Ozzy/Yul, Ozzy/Becky, Sundra/Yul, Sundra/Becky and Yul/Becky. Yul would win all three of his, Becky would beat Ozzy and Becky/Sundra is too close to call. Fiji is far less complicated. Boo is gone at five unless he wins immunity, in which case Dreamz goes. Either way Yau Man wins the Final Four Maze challenge where the remainder of Boo/Dreamz goes, and the Final Three immunity against Earl/Cassandra. Yau either takes Cassandra and wins easily, or takes Earl out of friendship and could lose. So Fiji gives us a Yau Man/Earl or Yau Man/Cassandra Final Two. The former would be close whilst Yau Man easily wins the latter. China's easy too. Denise/Peih Gee are interchangably fourh/fifth while Amanda wins the Final challenge and takes Courtney, who probably beats her. Gabon is hard because it's unclear whether Bob could've been voted out at five by Ken/Matty/Susie. If he is then Susie wins; if he isn't then Matty wins. So our possible winners are any of the Aitus in Cooks, Yau or Earl in Fiji, only Courtney in China and either Matty or Susie in Gabon. Unless I've made in error somewhere. |
||
|
Cyberball2072 |
|||
|
Posts: 591 (12/08/09 09:11 PM) I love ShiiAnn |
What If.......in Season 3, Brandon Quinton decided at the last moment....."You know what, I am NEVER going to have a better chance at winning a million
dollars then if I have Frank and Kelly with me at the end, so I am going to put aside my personal animous of Frank aside and go on winning this game and vote
out LEX on day 24......"
and the impact it would have had, not only on AFRICA, but on ALL STARS as well. |
||
|
Michaelf7777777 |
What if Earlier Seasons were Final 3? | ||
|
Posts: 6 (12/09/09 12:45 AM) |
Note: This will require losing an immunity challenge which will usually be the Final 5 one but in some cases may be other immunity challenges.
|
||
|
ilovekelly752 |
|||
|
Posts: 563 (12/09/09 01:17 AM) |
What if Amanda didn't find the idol in Mcronesia?
Amanda goes home 4-2. Erik wins immunity, and doesn't feel like he's in the minorty, so he doesn't try to make deals with anyone he can, so Natalie doesn't lose trust in him. Natalie is in the perfect position, the same position Parvati was actually in at this point. The only person Natalie doesn't habe that close of an alliance with is Cirie. She gets the fans to vote out Cirie, and makes a deal with Parvati that the girls' alliance with reunite to get Erik out next. Cirie goes home 4-1. Natalie and Alexis feel loyal to their alliance with Parvati that she made with them during the switch. The odds are 3/4 that Erik does not win immunity. Erik goes home 3-1. If Alexis wins immunity, Parvati's out. If Parvati wins immunity, Alexis is out. If Natalie wins immunity, it's a toss up, but I think Parvati would be able to convince Natalie that Alexis would have the bitter votes over Natalie, but Natalie would have them over Parvati, so I think it's slightly more likely that Alexis would go then Parvati. Alexis goes home. I really have no idea how the votes would go, but here is some speculation. Eliza- Parvati Ozzy- Natalie Jason- Natalie James- Natalie Amanda- Parvati Cirie- Parvati Erik- Natalie Alexis- Natalie Natalie wins 5-3. |
||
|
cantthinkofaname |
|||
|
Posts: 1614 (12/09/09 01:51 AM) Registered User |
Kathy 2 (Neleh, Paschal)Why the change to voting for Paschal and Neleh drawing the rock? |
||
|
SurferZ |
|||
|
Posts: 17 (12/09/09 03:53 AM) |
|
||
|
Michaelf7777777 |
|||
|
Posts: 7 (12/09/09 03:55 AM) |
I was thinking that Kathy and Vecepia originally targeted Neleh as a Final 3 immunity threat over a weak Paschal but that this time (With a final 3) Paschal
would be the target as a bigger jury threat (Hasn't annoyed as many people and is a judge so should be able to come up with a coherent and persuasive
arguement) buit if they really originally targeted Neleh as annoying then yeah the vote changes to annoying but that doesn't necessarily change who draws
the purple rock (In all honesty if I wasn't so lazy I'd of come up with jury votes for whomever drew the purple rock)
|
||
|
Michaelf7777777 |
With Regards to Erik | ||
|
Posts: 8 (12/09/09 04:10 AM) |
With regards to Erik not giving up immunity then Natalie is voted out (either 3-2, 4-1 or 3-1-1)
I think Erik has a good chance of winning the final 4 immunity challenge. If not he'd be voted out with nothing changing resultswise from original. However if Erik wins immunity then I can see him and Cirie teaming up to force a tie by targeting Amanda (Although I think Amanda probably wins the fire challenge. I don't see the final 3 immunity challenge suiting Erik, so Amanda will probably still beat Parvati at it which will leave her with a head vs heart decision. If he follows her heart and votes out Erik then she loses 5-3 as she did originally. However if she follows her head and votes out Parvati then she should win even if Parvati votes for Erik out of spite (I see Ozzy, James, Cirie and Jason as Amanda locks in this scenario and she's more likely to get the votes of Eliza and Natalie in my opinion. Best scenario for Amanda vs Erik in F2 is 7-1 (Eliza and Natalie side with her, Parvati doesn't feel betrayed) Best scenario for Erik in F2 against Amanda 4-4 draw (Parvati feels betrayed enough to vote for him, Eliza and Natalie both side with him over Amanda (which is unlikely but possible in my opinion) |
||
|
XtremeInnovator420 |
|||
|
Posts: 2543 (12/09/09 08:31 AM) Registered user |
I've always wondered what if the fans voted for Parvati at Final 6 instead of Amanda?
|
||
|
burberrylad |
|||
|
Posts: 976 (12/09/09 09:03 AM) Registered user |
Parvati would have gone at Final 6
It would have been an Alexis/Natalie final 2 |
||
|
XtremeInnovator420 |
|||
|
Posts: 2544 (12/09/09 09:08 AM) Registered user |
Yeah, I mean I figured Natalexis would likely be the F2, was just wondering in what order the whole F5, F4, F3 boots would've gone. Though...I'd
imagine Cirie goes at 5, Amanda at 4, and Erik at 3.
|
||
|
burberrylad |
|||
|
Posts: 977 (12/09/09 09:40 AM) Registered user |
Erik wins immunity at F5.....Amanda goes as she is physical/jury threat
Erik probably wins immunity at F4...........Cirie voted off as last favourite I think one of the girls would have won the final immunity challenge and voted Erik off. Eliza- Alexis Ozzy- Alexis Jason- Natalie James- Who Knows Parvati- Natalie Amanda- Natalie Cirie- Natalie Erik- Alexis I'm not sure who would have won. I think Natalie may have just clinged it |
||
|
srvivrfreakevelrich |
|||
|
Posts: 2878 (12/09/09 10:37 AM) Admin |
What if: Kelly and Sean team up with Gervase and Colleen at Final 7?
|
||
|
Ahora |
|||
|
Posts: 720 (12/09/09 12:13 PM) |
ilovekelly752 wrote:Cirie said that if Amanda didn't have the idol, she would have forced a tie. |
||
|
XtremeInnovator420 |
|||
|
Posts: 2546 (12/09/09 12:51 PM) Registered user |
Then when they went to rocks, isn't there a 67% chance that Cirie or Parvati go home as opposed to Natalie? Which...brings up 3 entirely different
"what if?" scenarios right there.
|
||
|
burberrylad |
|||
|
Posts: 979 (12/09/09 01:13 PM) Registered user |
What if Mookie, Edgardo and Alex decided to keep Lisi instead of Dreamz pre merge
|
||
- Survivor Sucks
- Lions, Tigers, Survivors - Oh My!
- Survivor Spoilers
- MESS Hall Tribal Council
- MESS Hall Archive
- Survivor Speculation
- Survivor: The Future
- The Amazing Race
- Big Brother
- Big Brother - PAST SEASONS
- The Apprentice
- American Idol
- American Idol PAST SEASONS
- The Mole
- Lost
- Other Shows that Suck
- Off Topic
- Clubs that Suck. No, Really.
- The Dump
- Monster Island
- Purgatory
- FAQ
- In Memory, 9/11/01
Message board courtesy of Survivor Sucks member support.
Benevolent dictatorship courtesy of Survivor Sucks Admin Idoits.
