| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
 Dr Will Hatch two point oh |
|||
|
Posts: 9387 (11/04/09 04:25 PM) Registered user |
SurvivorNinja wrote: Good friend Rupert is. TMN16-Ethan dropped a log on his foot. |
||
|
toomanynachos16 |
|||
|
Posts: 495 (11/04/09 04:41 PM) Registered User |
Really? I completely forgot about that detail...Yeesh...ASS is such a blur for me. Fair enough then, Rudy just had no chance to last long this time around,
which isn't really a fair reason to let let him back. He was one of several people who weren't gonna go far...RobC, Tina, Rich...
Also, Rupert and Rudy...did they make the right call? What do you think? If they team up with Tina-Ethan, It may be a whole new game. |
||
|
SurvivorNinja |
|||
|
Posts: 2999 (11/04/09 04:43 PM) Registered user |
I think another factor in Rudy being an early boot in ASS is the tribe he is in. If you put Rudy on either of the other tribes he could have lasted much longer
in the game.
|
||
|
Dr Will Hatch two point oh |
|||
|
Posts: 9388 (11/04/09 04:56 PM) Registered user |
toomanynachos16 wrote:I think Rupert made the right choice, but not Rudy. |
||
|
JaMalle |
|||
|
Posts: 4738 (11/04/09 10:20 PM) Registered User |
I haven't done a ranking in a LONG time.
YES: Rupert Shii Ann Ethan Jerri Big Tom Rob C Richard Kathy Jenna Lex Colby Tina Sue NO: LAMBER Rudy Rob Cesternino Jenna Alicia There's plenty of people that should have replaced the No's. The only thing good that came out of All Stars was Romber going on TAR where they're total <3. Survivor...I hate them. |
||
|
JackSparrowBauer |
|||
|
Posts: 2833 (11/04/09 10:26 PM) |
NO: wtf is wrong with you? ETA- I guess you meant Boston Rob in the no category. I was going to say...
Last Edited By: JackSparrowBauer
11/05/09 02:25 PM.
Edited 1 times.
|
||
|
JohnnyK |
|||
|
Posts: 344 (11/04/09 10:32 PM) |
JaMalle wrote: Must have meant to put Mariano in the "NO". |
||
|
sddorme.idolnoise |
|||
|
Posts: 289 (11/05/09 02:18 PM) |
I think Jenna deserved to be an all-star because she was a famous Borneo contestant but Amber didn't. I think Alicia deserved to be there too. I found it
so funny how in that reward challenge, they called Alicia the last deserving when Amber was like nothing.
|
||
|
Shambo |
|||
|
Posts: 9 (11/05/09 04:26 PM) |
I dont understand why any of these people were picked:
Jenna L Rob M Amber Alicia Shii Ann Granted, Rob Mariano turned out to be solid on all-stars, but did he stand out on Marquesas much? He could have been a threat if he hadnt helped the implosion of Maraamu. The other 4 werent even threats to win in their respective seasons. I would have rather seen them take the most deserving 3 from each of the first 6 seasons. I dont like the 2-seasons in a row thing, so include the Pearl Island castaways in the next ones. I completely understand why they wanted to milk the Rupert lovefest, but there was no reason to not include JFP, and Sandra not being physically ready to play again hurt too. With 18 castaways and 7 seasons that they had to choose from, there's no reason to only have 1 castaway from both Thailand and Pearl Islands, and having If it were solely up to me.....one from each season in each tribe, all winners included: Borneo: Rich, Rudy, Sue (2m, 1f) Outback: Tina, Colby, Jerri (1m, 2f) Africa: Ethan, Lex, Teresa (2m, 1f) Marquesas: Vee, Kathy, Sean (1m, 2f) Thailand: Brian, Helen, Jake (2m, 1f) Amazon: Jenna, Rob C, Heidi (2f, 1m) (if Heidi wouldnt agree to play, swap her out with Matt, and swap Jake out with Penny) 9 men, 9 women, 3 of each on each tribe, two winners on each tribe Saboga: Ethan, Tina, Rudy, Helen, Heidi, Sean Chapera: Brian, Vee, Rob C, Jerri, Lex , Sue Mogo Mogo: Richard, Jenna, Jake, Heidi, Colby, Kathy |
||
|
Maniacboy888 |
|||
|
Posts: 2949 (11/05/09 04:32 PM) Registered user |
Shambo wrote: So Heidi gets to be on two tribes? |
||
|
ThrowMeGabon |
|||
|
Posts: 844 (11/05/09 04:57 PM) |
From most to least deserving:
Hatch Jerri Lex Rudy Sue Rob C. Kathy Rupert Colby Tina Tom Shii Ann Ethan Jenna M. ----Should not have been on the show line----- Rob M. Alicia Jenna L. Amber Perfect world replacements: Brian for Rob M, Vecepia for Alicia, Colleen for Jenna L, Elisabeth for Amber For All-Stars 1.5, from most to least deserving Fairplay Yau man James Jonathan Eliza Ami Cirie ----Should not have been on the show line---- Ozzy Amanda Parvati Perfect world replacements: Shane for Ozzy, PG for Amanda, Courtney for Parvati The moral: Don't cast excessively undeserving people, because they will make merge and they will win the game. The least deserving All-Star always wins the game, see Big Brother.
Last Edited By: ThrowMeGabon
11/05/09 05:14 PM.
Edited 1 times.
|
||
|
Shambo |
|||
|
Posts: 11 (11/05/09 06:06 PM) |
Colleen and Elisabeth were 2 who apparently were offered a spot and declined. There are still about 25 other castaways they could have offered before settling
on Amber, Alicia and Jenna Lewis though...
and in my above post, swap out Heidi in Mogo Mogo for Teresa. |
||
|
Katy Carney |
|||
|
Posts: 9569 (12/06/09 05:35 PM) |
If you look at both seasons as equals instead of placing some ridiculous amount of importance only on their first season and then discounting anything else,
the All-Stars who were least important are as follows:
Shii Ann Alicia Big Tom Rudy James Now obviously some of these people are popular (Rudy and James, especially) but none of these people were principal stars on either of their seasons. Second-tier names AT BEST. People who bitch about Romber and to a lesser extent Parvmanda and to an even lesser extent Jenna Lewis are missing the bigger picture. Even if they weren't legendary STARS when they were cast for their second season, they certainly are now. Deal with it. |
||
|
KMKinCB |
|||
|
Posts: 20 (12/07/09 05:16 PM) |
Deserved to be there?
|
||
|
badfanfic |
|||
|
Posts: 15 (12/08/09 04:24 AM) |
YES;
|
||
|
ElisabethNelehHeidiRok |
|||
|
Posts: 1670 (12/08/09 08:20 PM) Registered User |
In all fairness I think that Sue, Rudy and Jenna L all for sure deserved to be there because they were the guinea pigs that hadnt seen it before and didnt
know what they were doing strategically. I know a lot of people dont like Jenna as a person because she is annoying but honestly she played a good game in
All-Stars and was probably the best "player" on Pagong in Borneo.
Best Possible All-Stars Chapera: Sean Rector, Brian Heidik, Rob Cestrinino, Susan Hawk, Heidi Strobel, Elisabeth Hasselback Mogo Mogo: Colby Donaldson, Lex Vandenberg, Richard Hatch, Kathy Vavrick O'Brien, Jenna Morasca, Colleen Haskell Saboga: Ethan Zohn, Rudy Boesh, Rupert Boneham, Jerri Manthey, Tina Wesson, Neleh Dennis
Last Edited By: ElisabethNelehHeidiRok
12/08/09 08:25 PM.
Edited 1 times.
|
||
|
Shred |
|||
|
Posts: 499 (12/08/09 08:22 PM) |
Colleen was the best player in Pagong she was the one who tried to get Hatch out and she almost did.
|
||
|
ElisabethNelehHeidiRok |
|||
|
Posts: 1671 (12/08/09 08:26 PM) Registered User |
Shred wrote: She really didnt play the game at all, she could have used her charm to get Kelly and Sean over when Gervase and Jenna were still in the game. I also truely believe that she could have beaten Kelly on the endurance immunity challenge that eventually sent her home, she gave up. |
||
|
Maniacboy888 |
|||
|
Posts: 3206 (12/08/09 09:17 PM) Registered user |
ElisabethNelehHeidiRok wrote: She did not give up, she cried after loosing that one according to cast interviews. |
||
|
Cyberball2072 |
|||
|
Posts: 594 (12/09/09 05:48 AM) I love ShiiAnn |
I've always wished they had done ALL STARS at 3 tribes of 8 each. That way, each tribe would probably think there was only one opposing tribe out there and
would have had the surprise of seeing 3 tribes out there all the more.
Tribe 1- The Winners/Runner Ups Richard Hatch Tina Weston Colby Donaldson Jenna Morrasca Ethan Zahn Kelly Wigglesworth Matt Von Erstad (insert female winner/runner up) Tribe 2- The Jury Lex Vandenberg Jerri Manthey Rob Cesterino Heidi Strobl Rupert Boneham Kelly Goldsmith Rudy Boesch (insert female that made jury) Tribe 3- Didn't make Jury/Merge Mike Skulpin Lindsay Richter Jeff Varner Shii Ann Huang Rob Mariano Gina Crews Hunter Ellis (insert female that did not make jury/merge) Personally I think it would have been much more interesting. At the start, only the TC winner would get Immunity. The two losing tribes would have to go to a double tribal council where one person gets voted out of each tribe to help attrite things at least untill some sort of merge happens. |
||
Message board courtesy of Survivor Sucks member support.
Benevolent dictatorship courtesy of Survivor Sucks Admin Idoits.
