
| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
JaimeCat22 |
|||
|
She didn't even make her own winning jury speech. Erik had to do it for her. If that doesn't symbolize her entire game, I don't know what does.
|
|||
kishuu |
|||
JaimeCat22 wrote: If Mick won the exact same way, with Erik making the speech for him, you would be going about gloating instead. Double standard much? |
|||
PJMichaelangelo |
|||
WylDawg wrote:Well, they had their option, but if they weren't going to vote for Russell then they were going to vote for who they liked more out of Natalie or Mick. I don't think anyone disputes that of the three, Natalie had the best social game. What we're disputing is that, if it hadn't been for Russell, Natalie wouldn't have been around long enough to play that social game. She freely admitted her strategy was to hitch herself to the Russell bandwagon. So if that bandwagon had been derailed, she would have been gone. Social game or not, remember she was #2 on the Galu boot order right behind Russell. If Russell doesn't make the moves he made then she would have never sniffed the final TC. And the strange thing is, had Natalie made the final TC with anyone but Russell, I would have felt she was the most deserving of the win. Compared to Mick and Jaison, who were beyond worthless, she would have been a great winner. But when she's in the final TC with the person who's basically 100% responsible for her getting there, then it becomes a bitter pill to swallow. |
|||
novaya |
|||
JaimeCat22 wrote: No. Shambogre probz being like "OMG RUSSELL ^_^" sealed the deal since she's such a skankwench and no one on Galu would buy into her bullshit. It was like Sue/Colleen+6. Stop hating on Natalie for winning and ascending into SurvivorGoddess Status since your Ick got 0 votes. SO pedestrian of you. |
|||
Flav4 |
|||
|
Ratalie who?? A forgettable winner.
|
|||
Mikester |
|||
|
The Russell fans and their meltdowns have been nice, but I think it's the Mick fans that are really making my night. It's hilarious how bitter they are
towards Natalie winning, as if Mick was ever going to get more than 0 votes.
|
|||
novaya |
|||
Mikester wrote: THIS. Mikester <3 |
|||
LOLABINGO |
|||
|
You seriously think the jury didn't have conversations about possible winners while at Ponderosa? Hell we SAW some of those conversations, and it's
easy as hell to decide in advance how the vote will go.
Two jurors flat out announced their vote moments before voting. They knew. |
|||
JaimeCat22 |
|||
|
Hopefully the public outrage over this outcome (with viewers choosing Russell as the player of the season) will cause Survivor to stop casting recruits in
future seasons. The viewers have spoken.
|
|||
WylDawg |
|||
|
What really didn't help was the over the top pimping of Russell, calling him the best player ever and whatnot. I almost can't blame him and his fans
for being butthurt right now. Maybe if CBS would've simmered down a little bit on the Russell fever, his loss would be easier to take and Natalie's win
would be more comprehensible.
Both Natalie and Russell were some of the very few applicants this season. Thus applicants rule. |
|||
Thailandsurvivor |
|||
|
No one will ever top Jenna Morasca as the worst winner ever.
With that said, Natalie is just as good a winner as Russell or Mick. Unfortunately, I'm indifferent to all three of them. |
|||
kishuu |
|||
JaimeCat22 wrote: The irony in this all is that Russell is a recruit too. |
|||
CrystalOwnage |
|||
Thailandsurvivor wrote: Bullshit. |
|||
kishuu |
|||
kishuu wrote:Okay fine, this is my mistake. I'm quoting it here. But the irony of it all he's not a fan like you're claiming anyway. He only watched one season. |
|||
Flav4 |
|||
|
Russell is probably the smartest disguise recruit of them all. He PWNED everybody except for RATalie.
Last Edited By: Flav4
12/21/09 12:53 AM.
Edited 1 times.
|
|||
Jane Drama |
|||
|
Natalie, yeah right. The joke's on us.
|
|||
chel87 |
|||
|
Not the worst winner ever- not even my second or third choice but how anyone can make that statement obviously hasn't seen the season that Jenna Morasco
won.
|
|||
Flav4 |
|||
|
Who is the best winner??
|
|||
CAPSattack |
|||
|
Posts: 7304 (12/21/09 12:59 AM) |
Flav4 wrote: YOUR MOM |
||
Kenscookie |
|||
Mateui wrote:Exactly. Even the argument that she was brilliant in that she aligned herself with someone who would do the dirty work and take her to the end falls flat, because as we all saw, she wasn't the only one who RUSSELL CHOSE to make an alliance with. She just lucked out that he cut his other alliances and kept her around. The social aspect of the game is certainly valid, but it's nothing without a strategic mindset. She didn't have to think, because she just latched on to Russell and let him make the decisions. Natalie is exactly the same as Amber, because Amber also would have gotten nowhere in the game without Rob. Natlaie may have won the million (and surely doesn't give a crap what anyone thinks of her "gameplay"), but it doesn't change the fact that she was just a leech. |
|||