Marisa: CPP
Mike: OTT
Betsy: CPP
Ben: OTTN
Yasmin: MORN
Ashley: MOR
Russell S: CP
Elizabeth: MOR
Erik: MOR
Kelly: UTR
Laura: MORN
John: CP
Dave: MOR
Monica: MOR
Shambo: OTT
Jaison: MOR
Brett: UTRP
Mick: MOR
Russell: CPN
Natalie: UTRP
Holy MOR.

| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
fsmdud |
|||
|
Anywho, my season Edgic ratings, tough ones in bold:
Marisa: CPP Mike: OTT Betsy: CPP Ben: OTTN Yasmin: MORN Ashley: MOR Russell S: CP Elizabeth: MOR Erik: MOR Kelly: UTR Laura: MORN John: CP Dave: MOR Monica: MOR Shambo: OTT Jaison: MOR Brett: UTRP Mick: MOR Russell: CPN Natalie: UTRP Holy MOR. |
|||
Jedijake |
|||
|
Perhaps each of those statements should now begin with "If the winner is a male...".
|
|||
chapera rocks |
|||
|
Marisa - CPP (I would go MORP, but the chart has CPP)
Mike - MOR Betsy - CPP Ben - OTTN Yasmin - OTTN Ashley - MORM Russell S. - OTTM Liz - MOR Erik - MOR Kelly - UTR Laura - MORN John - CP (Tough one, but MOR and UTR just aren't right) Dave - MORN Monica - MORN (Going by the chart, but MORM if her final episode was CPP) Shambo - OTTM Jaison - MORM Brett - UTRP Mick - MOR Russell H. - CPN Natalie - UTRP |
|||
AveryC |
|||
|
My overall ratings:
Marisa; Easily CPP. Mike: I could understand OTT but he didn't make enough of an impact for that. He's MOR. Betsy: She's CPP too. A very well developed and likeable early boot. Ben: It's never happened before, but he is OTTNN. How would that be represented on the chart? Bolded? Yasmin: Two OTTN's and two Vis 1 episodes. Like JP in Cook Islands she rounds out to MORN. Ashley: MOR is fairly clear here. I don't think she really earned tone. Russell S: A tricky one. I could see CP or OTT, and tone is very unclear. I think CPM fits best. Liz: I think her irrelevance at the reunion sums up her edit. Originally MOR but I actually think she's UTR. Erik: Several high Vis episodes and several UTR episodes. MOR fits best, maybe M? Kelly: Obvious UTR. Poor Kelly. Laura: In ten episodes, irrelevant in 5 and very visible and N in the other half. MORN. John: He had 3 INV1's. If Boo gets UTR, then John gets UTR too. Dave: Underutilised in general, but enough to make MOR. Monica: Another hard one. I'm open to suggestions, but going with UTR for now. Shambo: A clear OTTM. Jaison: No idea. MORM? Brett: UTRP, just enough for P. Mick: A very MOR edit. Russell H: I have him as being more OTT than the actual chart, but he still gets CPN. Natalie: She's more memorable than people like Mick, but is still UTRP. |
|||
cantthinkofaname |
|||
|
I'm currently working on the overall rating tally chart
|
|||
cantthinkofaname |
|||
For basically the same reason Laura is N, John should be CP, he was CP in all but 1 of his prominent episodes and to whoever said that we're not supposed to hate Monica: Yet some people do, hence the non-unanimous N rating. I'm not saying that's the specific and only reason for people rating Monica N though.
Last Edited By: cantthinkofaname
12/23/09 10:04 PM.
Edited 1 times.
|
|||
astroline |
|||
|
Thanks cantthinkofaname, but I rated Laura as CPN overall, not MORN.
|
|||
cantthinkofaname |
|||
astroline wrote:noted. it'll show in the next update to the chart once more people voted. |
|||
Werwanderflugen |
|||
|
Final Ratings:
Marisa - CPP Mike - MOR Betsy - CPP Ben - OTTN(N) Yasmin - OTTN Ashley - MOR Russell S. - CPM Liz - MOR Erik - CP Kelly - UTR Laura - MORN John - CP Dave - MOR Monica - MOR Shambo - OTTM Jaison - MORM Brett - UTRP Mick - MOR Russell H. - CPN Natalie - UTRP Also... I strongly agree with unduli_clone's suggestions for revised guidelines: (I added some of my own, which I bolded) Observations (In new order)
Last Edited By: Werwanderflugen
12/24/09 12:12 AM.
Edited 1 times.
|
|||
CrystalOwnage |
|||
|
Final Ratings:
Marisa - CPP
Mike - OTT Betsy - CPP Ben - OTTN Yasmin - MORN Ashley - MORM Russell S. - OTTM Liz - MOR Erik - MOR Kelly - UTR Laura - MORN John - CP Dave - MOR Monica - UTRN Shambo - OTTM Jaison - MORM Brett - UTRP Mick - MOR Russell H. - CPN Natalie - UTRP |
|||
ndralcasid |
|||
|
As a Monica fanboy, she's definitely N overall.
I have more issues with her overall rating. She's definitely MORN at least. |
|||
BlakeB717 |
|||
|
As someone who really ended up not being a fan of Monica, I think she was UTRneutral. At least UTR. She was only shown when she was the boot target or
narrating a reward. She was inconsequential to the story unless they needed to show her. That's UTR: under-utilized.
|
|||
cantthinkofaname |
|||
ndralcasid wrote:Season Rating Averages From most to least (INV=1, UTR=2, CP=3, MOR=4, OTT=5) 2.93 Monica Padilla 2.72 Laura Morett Looking at the rating averages, Monica does deserve MORN if Laura gets MORN too. |
|||
Katy Carney |
|||
|
She had more CPs and MORs than she did UTRs.
|
|||
bryanpasa |
|||
|
Final Ratings:
Marisa - CPP
Mike - OTT Betsy - CPP Ben - OTTNN Yasmin - MORN Ashley - MOR Russell S. - OTTP [designed as a GREAT LEADER.] Liz - MOR Erik - CP Kelly - UTR Laura - MORN John - CP Dave - MOR Monica - CP Shambo - OTTM Jaison - MORM Brett - UTRP Mick - MOR Russell H. - CPN Natalie - UTRP |
|||
McPhever224 |
|||
|
Posts: 537 (12/24/09 09:20 AM) Registered user |
Hey cantthinkofaname awesome job with the chart! But I had Yasmin as MORN not a decision between two ratings.
|
||
Hippochinfat |
|||
|
Posts: 552 (12/24/09 09:32 AM) |
That was me with the decision between OTTN/MORN
|
||
getting real |
|||
|
For all the teeth-gnashing about the season, this is the first time in a long time that the thread has gone close to 300 pages. Come on, FLF and Warrior. Get us over the line with your thoughts on the season. Happy Christmas, everyone... |
|||
Jedijake |
|||
|
Have to say this. I think that as long as Survivor survives, nice people are going to win. Not all of these nice people are going to be JT's and
TomW's. Some more may even be females (imagine that!).
Therefore, CBS, SEG, or whoever will need to get used to the fact that normal, nice people are more respected these days than snakes and swindlers. So, they may want to focus more on those nice people and give them stories, show their darker sides when possible, and give more than 30 confessionals. Hiding someone from the viewers doesn't change the outcome of the game no matter how much Burnett and Probst would like. |
|||
Kitty Pryde1 |
|||
|
Final Ratings:
Marisa: CPP Mike: OTT Betsy: CPP Ben: OTTNN Yasmin: OTTN Ashley: MOR Russell S.: OTTP Liz: MOR Erik: CPM Kelly: UTR Laura: MORN John: MORN Dave: MORN Monica: MORN Shambo: OTTM Jaison: MORM Brett: UTRP Mick: MOR Russell H.: CPN Natalie: UTRP |
|||