DEAR CBS - IF RUSSELL DIDN'T SPOIL S20 DID HE TELL SOMEBODY WHO DID? in Survivor Sucks Forum

0 Points

DEAR CBS - IF RUSSELL DIDN'T SPOIL S20 DID HE TELL SOMEBODY WHO DID?

Started By	Comment
PrettyGoodYear1988		#121	[-]
Posts: 3141 (12/30/09 07:06 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Strangers have the best candy. Don't be tempted Remove this ad If the spoilers came from a castaway, they came from Russell, seeing as he's the only Samoa person on both S19 and S20.
fsmdud		#122	[-]
Posts: 2129 (12/30/09 07:10 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Dear Queefstain, Fuck you.
JT4ever		#123	[-]
Posts: 547 (12/30/09 11:48 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	AussieOriginal wrote: If you look back over the quotes I posted from Missyae's thread, it's all from Russell's perspective. Except not. Read this next part again. Carefully. Missyae on 5 November I dont know if it was on this board or another board but I explained how The Evil Ones idol was used - at least according to what I was told. I was told that he will play his hidden idol but it was not a situation where he felt he had to in order to save himself. I do not think you will see it played tonight. I could be wrong but the word I got was \'might as well play it - if you have it.\' To me that sounds like later down the road when he felt he was very safe and it was just played to be playing it for the cameras. According to what I was told a big move is coming next week by The Evil One. I dont know what it is but I would guess it has something to do with Jaison. There must be a connection coming soon between Dave - John - Russell. According to sources who should know - if John - Dave - or Shambo do not vote for The Evil One to win - he will probably be pretty surprised. Missyae on 6 November (re Russell playing the idol the night of Eric's boot) People out there heard the comment about \'might as well play it since you all know\' but everyone on this board knows he thought he had to play it or he wouldnt have done it. So that was him trying to save face and it was a poor acting job to say the least. Do you see the problem? Here, let me spell it out: We know that Russell thought he had no choice but to play the Idol the night Erik went home. He didn't believe that Galu were really going to vote Erik. So he had to play the idol. And his statement "Everybody knows I have it, so I might as well play it" was mere posturing. Yet the spoiler came down to missyae that when Russell played the idol, it wasn't in a situation where it really mattered. Yes, missyae heard the part about "I might as well play it," but the perspective was completely wrong. If Russell had been missyae's direct source, Russell would have explained his actual thinking. The fact that the spoiler came down from a bystander's point of view -- a bystander who didn't understand the situation enough to realize that Russell had to play the idol that night -- tells me not only that missyae's source was not Russell, but the source wasn't even one of the 12 players who participated in that Tribal Council and knew what exactly was at stake. I have no doubt that Russell gave the info to Missyae. Which doesn't make you correct.
chapera rocks		#124	[-]
Posts: 12413 (12/31/09 12:12 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Miss had no idea why Erik was voted out, and guess what? Neither did Russell. Miss was even bold enough to say "Foa Foa to this day does not understand why Erik was voted out. But now that they saw he had the idol, it makes sense to them." Well, Galu didn't know Erik had the idol. The source is obviously a Foa Foa that made the merge. Production would know that Galu didn't realize Erik had the idol. Miss had a lot of negative comments about Natalie, such as how she was attached to Russell or how she would ask if there was hotel breaks. That clearly means its not Natalie (though he tried to throw Natalie under the bus). Excusing all the other things (such as the Sham/Russell TAR thing, how Russ was contacted for another season of survivor, how Russ would be surprised if he didn't get votes from Dave/John/Shambo, S20 spoilers, how Russell feels about Natalie, how Foa Foa spoilers were very detailed such as why Ashley/Ben were voted out, whereas Galu spoilers were very vague, how Russell didn't remember the fight he and Liz had on the beach), it is clear that the source, either directly or indirectly, was Russell.
JT4ever		#125	[-]
Posts: 548 (12/31/09 12:22 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	chapera rocks wrote: Well, Galu didn't know Erik had the idol. Huh? Anyone who got to Ponderosa would know Erik had the idol. it is clear that the source It's not even clear to me that the source is a single person.
SuperJude		#126	[-]
Posts: 16602 (12/31/09 12:25 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	JT4ever wrote: chapera rocks wrote: Well, Galu didn't know Erik had the idol. Huh? Anyone who got to Ponderosa would know Erik had the idol. it is clear that the source It's not even clear to me that the source is a single person. But what IF this info came from one person? How likely is it that independant sources would spoil the same information? It seems to come from one source, regardless of how they gained said information. I wonder if CBS is paying attention to all this. All I'm saying people is: office betting pools! -SJ™
JT4ever		#127	[-]
Posts: 549 (12/31/09 12:29 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	SuperJude wrote: But what IF this info came from one person? How likely is it that independant sources would spoil the same information? We're told former castaways keep in touch via private chats and message groups. Information could easily leak from something like that.
Captain Poop	DEAR MODS OF THIS SHITTY FORUM -	#128	[-]
Posts: 1 (12/31/09 12:30 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Move this spoiler filled thread to a spoiler section.
SuperJude		#129	[-]
Posts: 16603 (12/31/09 12:35 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	JT4ever wrote: SuperJude wrote: But what IF this info came from one person? How likely is it that independant sources would spoil the same information? We're told former castaways keep in touch via private chats and message groups. Information could easily leak from something like that. But it never, ever does. Spoilers always come from a distinct source. I'll edit anything spoiler-like in this thread, would appreciate others doing the same. -SJ™
chapera rocks		#130	[-]
Posts: 12414 (12/31/09 12:39 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Strangers have the best candy. Don't be tempted Remove this ad JT4ever wrote: chapera rocks wrote: Well, Galu didn't know Erik had the idol. Huh? Anyone who got to Ponderosa would know Erik had the idol. it is clear that the source It's not even clear to me that the source is a single person. Erik didn't tell anyone, clearly, since Foa Foa was shocked to learn he had an idol. According to missyae. And Galu didn't vote out Erik because they thought he had an idol; that is an assumption that Russell...err, the source, made. It's not even clear to me that the source is a single person. Because you love Russell. Look at all those things I just repeated that were leaked, and tell me it wasn't Russell with a straight face.
AussieOriginal		#131	[-]
Posts: 2103 (12/31/09 03:12 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	JT4ever wrote: AussieOriginal wrote: If you look back over the quotes I posted from Missyae's thread, it's all from Russell's perspective. Except not. Read this next part again. Carefully. Missyae on 5 November I dont know if it was on this board or another board but I explained how The Evil Ones idol was used - at least according to what I was told. I was told that he will play his hidden idol but it was not a situation where he felt he had to in order to save himself. I do not think you will see it played tonight. I could be wrong but the word I got was \'might as well play it - if you have it.\' To me that sounds like later down the road when he felt he was very safe and it was just played to be playing it for the cameras. According to what I was told a big move is coming next week by The Evil One. I dont know what it is but I would guess it has something to do with Jaison. There must be a connection coming soon between Dave - John - Russell. According to sources who should know - if John - Dave - or Shambo do not vote for The Evil One to win - he will probably be pretty surprised. Missyae on 6 November (re Russell playing the idol the night of Eric's boot) People out there heard the comment about \'might as well play it since you all know\' but everyone on this board knows he thought he had to play it or he wouldnt have done it. So that was him trying to save face and it was a poor acting job to say the least. Do you see the problem? Here, let me spell it out: We know that Russell thought he had no choice but to play the Idol the night Erik went home. He didn't believe that Galu were really going to vote Erik. So he had to play the idol. And his statement "Everybody knows I have it, so I might as well play it" was mere posturing. Yet the spoiler came down to missyae that when Russell played the idol, it wasn't in a situation where it really mattered. Yes, missyae heard the part about "I might as well play it," but the perspective was completely wrong. If Russell had been missyae's direct source, Russell would have explained his actual thinking. The fact that the spoiler came down from a bystander's point of view -- a bystander who didn't understand the situation enough to realize that Russell had to play the idol that night -- tells me not only that missyae's source was not Russell, but the source wasn't even one of the 12 players who participated in that Tribal Council and knew what exactly was at stake. Your counter argument there makes no sense whatsoever. Why do you think Russell would have explained his thinking? And how would you know what Russell would have explained or not? You don't. Sounds like what he said to Missyae was "I had the Idol, thought I might as well play it", and Missyae was left to piece together what took place. That's usually how it is with spoilers. We're told former castaways keep in touch via private chats and message groups. Information could easily leak from something like that. Yes, that's true. But as CR pointed out to you, just about ALL of the info was Russell related. Even to how he felt about other Survivors and things that happened in the game. Missyae just posted what Russell told him/her and in so doing made it clear to everyone that the info was coming from Russell, rather than present the info in a way that would not identify the leak. S/he would do well to read Mersaydeez's, Chillone's and Snewser's threads to see how it should be done. Last Edited By: AussieOriginal 12/31/09 03:44 AM. Edited 1 times.
chapera rocks		#132	[-]
Posts: 12416 (12/31/09 03:19 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Actually, missy got really defensive when people accused him of getting info from Russell. Even tried to blame it on Natalie.
AussieOriginal		#133	[-]
Posts: 2105 (12/31/09 03:51 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	When he first started the thread he got very pissed off, even when people were trying to explain to him what the repercussions of posting false spoilers were. He threw a hissy fit and took off, then came back, called everyone assclowns - lovely behaviour. Contrast that with Mersaydeez's thread - spoiler legend.
Miles Edgeworth		#134	[-]
Posts: 3093 (12/31/09 04:06 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	If these s20 spoilers were from russel like everybody claims. Explain why the person who posted the bootlist (which was first survivor united btw) knew the dynamics of a tribe that russel wasnt on. .........................................................,..THe more I think about it people giving away who they voted for could easily be explained, since shambo and erik both revealed their votes at ftc.
marlsj		#135	[-]
Posts: 21 (12/31/09 05:07 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	JasonSiskaRulz wrote: Anyone else stoked about another season of Russell? No.
JT4ever		#136	[-]
Posts: 550 (12/31/09 10:32 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	chapera rocks wrote: Erik didn't tell anyone, clearly, since Foa Foa was shocked to learn he had an idol. According to missyae. And Galu didn't vote out Erik because they thought he had an idol; that is an assumption that Russell...err, the source, made. I personally find it hard to believe Erik didn't tell anyone at Ponderosa about his idol. But then Erik is an idot, so who knows? Anyway, that's neither here nor there. More to the point is this: missyae's source made their "Foa Foa to this day does not understand why Erik was voted out. But now that they saw he had the idol, it makes sense to them" statement when Erik found the idol, which was a few episodes before he was actually voted out. However, when Erik's boot came, Russell and Foa Foa knew exactly why Erik was voted out: because Natalie went to tell the hot girls about Erik's plan to use Monica as a bounce target against Russell's idol. So if I am to believe that missyae's source once assumed Erik was voted out because of the idol, how can I believe that source was in fact Russell? AussieOriginal wrote: Your counter argument there makes no sense whatsoever. Why do you think Russell would have explained his thinking? And how would you know what Russell would have explained or not? You don't. And how would you know that Russell would have simply described the mechanics of his actions and statements without conveying their meaning? Sounds like what he said to Missyae was "I had the Idol, thought I might as well play it", and Missyae was left to piece together what took place. That's usually how it is with spoilers. But this spoiler doesn't simply involve partial information. It is a fundamental misrepresentation of a key moment in the game, the kind of misrepresentation someone would make who saw footage of that TC without understanding what led up to the idol play. I find it as plausible that Russell would have described his idol move that way as you apparently find the possibility that missyae's source is not Russell. But as CR pointed out to you, just about ALL of the info was Russell related. Sure, it's not lost on me that missyae's spoilers were heavily centered around Russell, but that comes with the territory in the season of Survivor: Russell. Moreover, the gaps and inconsistencies I've spotted make me think the source isn't Russell himself. Given the amount of Russell footage the editors showed us this season, I don't find it hard to believe that post-production folks got exposed to a lot of Russell. Just for argument's sake, I can imagine some low-level peon assigned to transcribe footage blabbing about the things they saw, without the full understanding of someone who was actually there or someone who's editing the footage together.
chapera rocks		#137	[-]
Posts: 12417 (12/31/09 12:03 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	If these s20 spoilers were from russel like everybody claims. Explain why the person who posted the bootlist (which was first survivor united btw) knew the dynamics of a tribe that russel wasnt on. .........................................................,..THe more I think about it people giving away who they voted for could easily be explained, since shambo and erik both revealed their votes at ftc. Are you dumb? Missyae's spoilers are from Russell. Survivor's Unite's spoilers aren't. I personally find it hard to believe Erik didn't tell anyone at Ponderosa about his idol. But then Erik is an idot, so who knows? Anyway, that's neither here nor there. I do to. But that's not even the point; Foa Foa didn't know about Erik's idol until it aired on TV. Russell never hung out with Erik post show, Mick did. So it's probably not Mick either. Russell didn't, so it's understandable that he wouldn't realize that Erik had the idol. The point is: Galu didn't know about Erik's idol while they were still IN the game. Therefore, that is not the reason that they blindsided them. But the source assumed they blindsided Erik because of the idol; therefore, the source isn't anyone from Galu. And it probably isn't production, since they'd know a detail like that, and all the spoilers had details about Foa Foa and not Galu. More to the point is this: missyae's source made their "Foa Foa to this day does not understand why Erik was voted out. But now that they saw he had the idol, it makes sense to them" statement when Erik found the idol, which was a few episodes before he was actually voted out. However, when Erik's boot came, Russell and Foa Foa knew exactly why Erik was voted out: because Natalie went to tell the hot girls about Erik's plan to use Monica as a bounce target against Russell's idol. Exactly, it proves the source is from Foa Foa. First of all, missy said "Foa Foa to this day does not understand...", well obviously they must be connected to someone from Foa Foa. This disproves your low level production person, unless they keep tabs on the contestants and asks them what they think of the show. And because they didn't know why Galu voted out Erik (Something the Galu members would know), it can't be someone from Galu. So if I am to believe that missyae's source once assumed Erik was voted out because of the idol, how can I believe that source was in fact Russell? Explained above. It has to be someone from Foa Foa. It cannot be Natalie, since missy wouldn't give up his source (and threw Natalie under the bus) and the spoilers trash Natalie. It can't be Mick by your logic because Mick hung out with Erik quite a bit and would theoretically know about the idol. And do you really think a lawyer would breach contract so heavily or was it someone who's perspective is told through the story, and who can't keep his mouth shut to save his life? And how would you know that Russell would have simply described the mechanics of his actions and statements without conveying their meaning? And how do you know he wouldn't? That's a minor detail that could be explained by Russell's ego repeating the statement he made and letting people interpret it. Furthermore, Missy STATED they did not know what the statement meant, but that they assumed it meant ____. Most of the spoilers were from Russell's perspective. How would someone know that Russell and Shambo were offered a spot on the Amazing Race? How would someone from Samoa know Russell was offered another spot on a future season? How would someone from Samoa know how Russell felt about Natalie, or the votes he felt he had? Or how would someone from Samoa know S20 spoilers almost immediately after filming? How come missy didn't show up with info until just after the S20 cast returned to the states? RUSSELL! Sure, it's not lost on me that missyae's spoilers were heavily centered around Russell, but that comes with the territory in the season of Survivor: Russell. Moreover, the gaps and inconsistencies I've spotted make me think the source isn't Russell himself. You've spotted one gap which isn't really even a big deal. How do you explain everything else? It's not that the spoilers center around Russell, it's that they are from Russell's perspective. Last Edited By: chapera rocks 12/31/09 12:07 PM. Edited 2 times.
SuperJude		#138	[-]
Posts: 16605 (12/31/09 12:45 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	So Russell told somebody or the spoilers were released to FRAME RUSSELL for the crime? I just want to know why a contestant can decide they are above and beyond the rules just because they think they should have won. I still have no proof that Russell didn't decide to tell somebody who then came here and posted said information. -SJ™
chapera rocks		#139	[-]
Posts: 12419 (12/31/09 01:29 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	SuperJude wrote: So Russell told somebody or the spoilers were released to FRAME RUSSELL for the crime? I just want to know why a contestant can decide they are above and beyond the rules just because they think they should have won. I still have no proof that Russell didn't decide to tell somebody who then came here and posted said information. -SJ™ Look at all the things I posted; not only are they all from Russell's perspective, but all the game things have come true. From his perspective at least. It was Russell. And he can't keep his mouth shut because he gets off on people praising him for his game, which really in all honesty, wasn't that great. It was good, but no where near survivor's greats.
SuperJude		#140	[-]
Posts: 16609 (12/31/09 01:42 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Strangers have the best candy. Don't be tempted Remove this ad Oh chaperarocks, I've read it all twice. I'm just trying to be careful here in what I say because this went from a kind of random thread to me stumbling onto a real issue. Put it this way, Anti posted in this thread, in the Sucks forum, which illustrated that this was valid subject matter. So the issue for me was that I thought Russell and his wife had posted these spoilers. They didn't, wasn't them. Next question became did Russell tell somebody who then posted this info? This looks like a distinct possibility at the moment, especially the way you present all that info together, CR. So then, why is Russell allowed to behave however he wants and spoil seasons of Survivor, if that's indeed what happened? Isn't CBS afraid that fans won't watch because they already know their favorites don't win? -SJ™ Last Edited By: SuperJude 12/31/09 02:08 PM. Edited 1 times.

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

DEAR CBS - IF RUSSELL DIDN'T SPOIL S20 DID HE TELL SOMEBODY WHO DID?