
| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
AlexDSSF |
Best format for a reality show contestant: Got Talent, Idol, or X Factor? |
Lead | |
|
Which format do you think is best for an aspiring singer: Idol, X Factor, or Got Talent? I know that all three have their pros and cons, but what do you think?
|
|||
maadx |
|||
|
Posts: 6291 (01/06/10 05:44 PM) Registered user |
FIRST!
|
||
MakePaulaCry |
|||
|
X factor.
And I base my answer on absolutely nothing. |
|||
MikiBoi |
|||
|
X FACTOR
|
|||
suckshardcore |
|||
|
Fuck X-Factor. Idol.
Either way its clearly not Got Talent. That said I don't think the format matters much, its a person by person thing. I think if someone's going to be successful post-show they'll be successful regardless of the format. X-Factor hasn't come to America so it remains to be seen if it will produce as many success (or failure) stories as Idol but in Britain even though Pop Idol's long been canceled Will was successful, Michelle wasn't and some X-Factor contestants are successful and I'm sure some aren't. Its not the format that matters much, especially since Simon's machine is at the helm of both. |
|||
abrahammy |
|||
|
America's Got Talent is a terrible format. If American Idol was run like that, Scott Macintyre might have won last year, and Kris Allen would not have
been anywhere near the end - although Adam might have been.
X-Factor? Dunno. Haven't seen. |
|||
pjadedd |
|||
|
I'm going with format of The Mole.
|
|||
KellysMomCalledMeFine |
|||
|
Idol. We have more options to choose from.
X-Factor has the best semi-final format, but we are given 12 or so contestants and thats it. Whoopty-doo. |
|||
Seyz |
|||
|
|
|||
The Purple Parrot |
|||
|
Idol.
|
|||
Will |
|||
|
Whichever one is least rigged.
|
|||
survivorjordancontestant |
|||
|
bitch please, X Factor hands down, judge v.s. judge, back up dancers and props, real fucking sing-offs. practically no age limit.
|
|||
SardonicallyIrrelevant |
|||
|
Fame.
|
|||
Yeaster |
|||
|
Making The Band!
|
|||
pjadedd |
|||
|
Can I make a change to American Juniors?
|
|||
managerr |
|||
|
If you HAVE TALENT, not Idol. Or frankly, nothing where America votes.
If you don't have much singing talent, but have an interesting backstory, are hot, or your wife just died, then definitely Idol. |
|||