S-19 Edgic (editing and logic) in Survivor Speculation Forum

0 Points

S-19 Edgic (editing and logic)

Started By	Comment
cantthinkofaname		#6201	[-]
Posts: 1743 (01/16/10 12:36 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	The spontaneous rally will begin at 1:45. Remove this ad craig wrote: If this is all the votes we're gonna get then here are the results: Marisa- CPP Mike- OTT Betsy- CPP Ben- OTTN Yasmin- OTTN Ashley- MOR? Russell S.- OTT? Liz- MOR Erik- MOR? Kelly- UTR Laura- MORN John- ?N Dave- MOR Monica- MORN Shambo- OTTM Jaison- MORM Brett- UTRP Mick- MOR Russell H.- CPN Natalie- UTRP Close Calls (as it stands now) Rating John - UTR (27.2%), CP (36.3%), MOR (36.3%) Tone Ashley - neutral (40.9%), mixed (50%), P (9.09%), Russell S. - neutral (18.1%), mixed (54.5%), P (27.2%), (Is this right)? Erik - N (4.5%), neutral (45.4%), mixed (45.4%), P (4.5%), As tone watchdog, I vote the following on close calls. Ashley - Neutral Russell S - Mixed Erik - Mixed I don't recall much tone at all from Ashley. Her N is ep.1 was borderline and weak, as was her P in a couple subsequent scenes. Now that MDN voted, Russell S. is now mixed with no close call. and I had the % switched on Ashley's and the other CCs are now Rating John - UTR (26.08%), CP (34.78%), MOR (39.14%) Tone Ashley - N (4.3%), neutral (47.82%), mixed (34.78%), P (8.6%), Erik - N (8.6%), neutral (43.47%), mixed (39.13%), P (4.3%),
Hippochinfat		#6202	[-]
Posts: 626 (01/17/10 08:07 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	So is Russell S. agreed to be OTTM? I'm just asking because I could see him as CPM. He was very CP in 1 and 4 and CPish in episode 3. His last two episodes were OTT, but his visibility in episode 5 was less then in 1 and 4, and about equal to 3. He comes off to me as a bit more CP, people are just remembering the last episode he was in most I think. It's just hard to give this guy an overall rating, because he was a mix between P and N, CP and OTT.
BlakeB717		#6203	[-]
Posts: 2921 (01/20/10 03:14 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	For those of you who do not venture outside this thread, very sad news has reached the Sucks Community: Jenn Lyon from Palau lost her 5-year fight with breast cancer on Tuesday evening.
Oowatanite		#6204	[-]
Posts: 10103 (01/20/10 11:18 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	R.I.P. Jenn.
astroline		#6205	[-]
Posts: 3122 (01/20/10 12:03 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	RIP Jenn. That second pic is great, Oo. It's so sad.
McPhever224		#6206	[-]
Posts: 561 (01/20/10 05:18 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts
LibrasAbandonedChild1		#6207	[-]
Posts: 1145 (01/20/10 05:51 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	So heartbreaking.
Phoenix1269		#6208	[-]
Posts: 796 (01/21/10 07:16 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	that is such sad news... so young. RIP Jenn
Phoenix1269	Episode 14 Ratings & Close Calls	#6209	[-]
Posts: 797 (01/21/10 07:26 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Overall Rankings OTTP3 - Brett Clouser MOR?2 - Jaison Robinson MOR3 - Mick Trimming CPP3 - Natalie White OTTN5 - Russell Hantz From most to least INV=1, UTR=2, CP=3, MOR=4, OTT=5 4.78 - Brett Clouser 4.33 - Russell Hantz 4.00 - Jaison Robinson 3.89 - Mick Trimming 3.44 - Natalie White Episode Tone Averages From most positive to least positive NN=-2, N=-1, neutral=0, P=1, PP=2 1.444 - Brett Clouser 1.000 - Natalie White -0.111 - Mick Trimming -0.333 - Jaison Robinson -1.444 - Russell Hantz Episode Visibility Averages From most to least 4.89 - Russell Hantz 3.33 - Natalie White 3.11 - Brett Clouser 3.11 - Mick Trimming 2.11 - Jaison Robinson Close Calls Rating There are no close calls for the final Tone Jaison Robinson NN (0%), N (44.4%), neutral (44.4%), P (11.1%), PP (0%)(note: 0 out of 4 neutral votes were for dynamic) Visibility There are no close calls for the final
Phoenix1269	MORDiff and other stats - Episode 14	#6210	[-]
Posts: 798 (01/21/10 07:28 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	The spontaneous rally will begin at 1:45. Remove this ad MOR differential Sum difference from middle of road for total season 4.59 - Ben Browning 2.92 - Russell Hantz 2.79 - Kelly Sharbaugh 2.59 - Brett Clouser 1.89 - Betsy Bolan 1.89 - Marisa Calihan 1.89 - Shannon Waters 1.74 - Mike Borassi 1.47 - Natalie White 1.40 - John Fincher 1.32 - Laura Morett 1.17 - Yasmin Giles 1.12 - Monica Padilla 1.00 - Dave Ball 0.86 - Russell Swan 0.82 - Jaison Robinson 0.71 - Mick Trimming 0.65 - Ashley Trainer 0.53 - Elizabeth Kim 0.20 - Erik Cardona Current midpoint: 2.20 no one is close Current median value: 1.36 Natalie at .11 above Breakdowns Season Rating Averages From most to least (INV=1, UTR=2, CP=3, MOR=4, OTT=5) 4.82 - Ben Browning 4.42 - Mike Borassi 4.27 - Shannon Waters 3.67 - Jaison Robinson 3.58 - Russell Swan 3.57 - Russell Hantz 3.37 - Betsy Bolan 3.30 - Mick Trimming 3.28 - Dave Ball 3.22 - Ashley Trainer 3.11 - Marisa Calihan 3.09 - Yasmin Giles 3.01 - Elizabeth Kim 2.93 - Erik Cardona 2.93 - Monica Padilla 2.72 - Natalie White 2.72 - Laura Morett 2.39 - John Fincher 2.20 - Brett Clouser 2.05 - Kelly Sharbaugh Season Tone Averages From most positive to least (NN=-2, N=-1, neutral=0, P=1, PP=2) 0.974 - Betsy Bolan 0.842 - Marisa Calihan 0.416 - Natalie White 0.260 - Brett Clouser 0.127 - Elizabeth Kim 0.126 - Jaison Robinson 0.098 - Mick Trimming 0.043 - Russell Swan 0.008 - Shannon Waters -0.006 - Ashley Trainer -0.044 - Erik Cardona -0.093 - Kelly Sharbaugh -0.150 - Dave Ball -0.154 - Monica Padilla -0.182 - John Fincher -0.184 - Mike Borassi -0.285 - Laura Morett -0.512 - Yasmin Giles -0.668 - Russell Hantz -1.503 - Ben Browning Season Visibility Averages From most to least 4.68 - Russell Hantz 4.26 - Ben Browning 3.95 - Marisa Calihan 3.62 - Shannon Waters 3.55 - Betsy Bolan 3.42 - Ashley Trainer 3.24 - Russell Swan 3.02 - Jaison Robinson 2.92 - Erik Cardona 2.87 - Mike Borassi 2.69 - Mick Trimming 2.61 - Elizabeth Kim 2.43 - Yasmin Giles 2.43 - Dave Ball 2.39 - John Fincher 2.25 - Laura Morett 2.23 - Natalie White 2.10 - Monica Padilla 1.47 - Brett Clouser 1.26 - Kelly Sharbaugh
cantthinkofaname		#6211	[-]
Posts: 1749 (01/23/10 06:36 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	We need to resolve the close calls for episodes 12 and 13 episode 12: http://survivorsucks.com/topic/57357?page=244 episode 13: http://survivorsucks.com/topic/57357?page=275
Hippochinfat		#6212	[-]
Posts: 633 (01/23/10 12:06 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Kind of surprised Russell got OTTNN5, when it was mostly just one scene that was like that, he was pretty CP in the episode too from what I remember, like when discussing if he should take Brett with him.
McPhever224		#6213	[-]
Posts: 562 (01/23/10 02:52 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Hippochinfat wrote: Kind of surprised Russell got OTTNN5, when it was mostly just one scene that was like that, he was pretty CP in the episode too from what I remember, like when discussing if he should take Brett with him. He didn't. He got OTTN5.
Hippochinfat		#6214	[-]
Posts: 634 (01/24/10 08:32 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	McPhever224 wrote: Hippochinfat wrote: Kind of surprised Russell got OTTNN5, when it was mostly just one scene that was like that, he was pretty CP in the episode too from what I remember, like when discussing if he should take Brett with him. He didn't. He got OTTN5. Shut up I crossed my eyes and saw 2 Ns.
getting real		#6215	[-]
Posts: 2037 (01/24/10 05:49 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Shut up I crossed my eyes and saw 2 Ns. That's nothing. I crossed myself and had an apocalyptic vision. Something involving Brett Favre, Neleh's regurgitated mint and Parvati.
astroline		#6216	[-]
Posts: 3140 (01/26/10 01:51 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Just letting you guys know since that I am still the only veteran Edgicer that admitted to seeing that spoiler troll's entire bootlist in this thread (just the first time, not the second, although apparently none of you saw the second one, which is a load of BS), I'm posting in Spoilers this season and I am prepared to rat any of you guys out if I even see your name in there at all. Phoenix if you have any suspicions or doubts about anyone, let me know and I'll scope it out. :) Otherwise I'll be doing it on my own too, so watch out. I still find it very, very, VERY hard to believe that the only 3 semi-regular posters in here that saw the spoilers were myself, Cindi & McPhever. And the spoilers were posted completely in huge font, for multiple pages, at two different times. Don't trust anyone in this thread, there are a bunch of liars in here trying to save face just so they can vote for the next Mick/Marcus/Stephen in the winner picks. That being said, enjoy picking the Episode 1 MOR male for your #1 winner pick.
brettfan22		#6217	[-]
Posts: 43 (01/26/10 02:17 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	90% of edgicers have probably read the bootlist. This isn't exactly breaking news. Here's my advice for edgic this season: Ignore the fucking bootlist and go back to analyzing the actual editing for a change. Instead of making winner picks based on spoilers or whichever player you happen to be rooting for at the time. Try it. You might like it. And if the bootlist turns out to be wrong, and you guys get it right, you'll have bragging rights for years to come. Learn from the mistakes of previous seasons instead of repeating them over and over again.
chapera rocks		#6218	[-]
Posts: 12779 (01/26/10 02:31 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	I've seen it. I've never denied it. (Though I did see it before the troll posted it here).
BlakeB717		#6219	[-]
Posts: 2929 (01/26/10 03:00 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Are we still beating this poor, dead horse?
Oowatanite		#6220	[-]
Posts: 10123 (01/26/10 06:16 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	The spontaneous rally will begin at 1:45. Remove this ad I'm surprised people still think there will be an Edgic thread for S20. It ain't happening, folks ! The best you'll get is a little thread with a bunch of noobs, ghosties and trolls.

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

S-19 Edgic (editing and logic)