


| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
Screerider |
|||
|
I couldn't find a McKinney thread...
![]() ![]()
|
|||
StatelyWayneManor |
|||
|
|||
Apprentice Talker |
|||
|
There is a Cardin McKinney thread in Past Seasons subthread. You can easy to find it, Scree.
|
|||
Screerider |
|||
|
Tanks, AT. You're da best.
|
|||
msacras |
|||
|
You should revise this list! More than half don't belong anyway.
As for who's hottest, Megan wins hands down suckas. |
|||
assface killah |
|||
|
In order...
Katharine McPhee Carrie Underwood Pia Toscano Kelly Clarkson (DURING AI only... though I am still a huge fan) Cardin McKinney Casey Carlson Becky O'Donohue Haley Scarnato Kady Malloy Lindsey Cardinale Amanda Avila Katie Webber That is all 10 seasons worth for me... no one else I found even remotely attractive |
|||
high dudester 2 |
|||
![]() /thread |
|||
Hanson |
|||
|
AK's list is missing Julie Zorrilla and Janell Wheeler and Amy Davis.
|
|||
8trackmind |
|||
|
Everybody on AK's list is fine but it's also missing Ryan Starr, Julia DeBigtits, Syesha Mercado & Didi Benami.
|
|||
Hanson |
|||
|
Waitaminute -- no Megan Joy? AK, you slackin', bro.
|
|||
assface killah |
|||
|
Amy Davis (who?)... Jannelle seemed to trailer trashy for me... Julia Zorilla seemed to have slightly more brain cells than an orange... Julia Demato looked to be close to 40... Ryan Starr was far too slutty and dirty... and Megan Joy and Didi are fucking ugly and both look like they smell... so... no... my list is correct
Both of your first mistakes are questioning my taste in women in the first place And Hanson... your second mistake is calling me... "bro". |
|||
27ravens |
|||
![]() ![]()
Last Edited By: 27ravens
03/28/11 06:41 PM.
Edited 1 times.
|
|||
Hanson |
|||
assface killah wrote: In no particular order, my list would be Casey, Julie, Janell, Cardin, Katharine, Becky, & Amy. Kat's the only one to make it out of the semis (Cardin didn't even make it to a performance show). As for Amy -- Scree, where are those Amy Davis bikini pics?
|
|||
returnofsteveninstone |
|||
|
Ok, 2 years ago I posted a list of the hottest women ever that were voted on a poll on a different website. I have decided to revise the list last week since there has been some minor controversy over the girls selected being all white, some of them undeserving of being on the list, or all looking the same.
Last time I posted 50 names and the 12 highest regardless of hair color would get in the top 12 (coincidentally, it was half brunette/blonde split). This time I posted 24 names, 12 brunettes, 12 blondes and 6 of each hair color would get through. 90,000 votes were cast during the 72 hours it was open. Here is the REVISED Top 12, in Alpha order. (Green bold shows girl also voted in the poll last time) Brunettes ________ Haley Scarnato Katharine McPhee Kelly Clarkson Pia Toscano Syesha Mercado Tatiana Nicole Del Toro Blondes ________ Carrie Underwood Didi Benami Kellie Pickler Kendra Chantelle Lauren Alaina Suddeth Megan Joy Corkrey There were some surprises, such as Lauren Alaina getting a decent lead over Kristy Lee Cook (who seemed to be a shooin at first) during the last 10 hours of the poll. Tatiana also got a vote boost during the final 24 hours the poll was up over favorites like Jennifer Hudson or Antonella Barba who seemed to be battling it out for the final sixth place spot until Tatiana breezed through. So that's the revised list! Tell me what you think, and vote who is the hottest out of that list!
|
|||
8trackmind |
|||
|
I do have a problem with the white bread nature of the list (aside from a few latinas). Having no black or asian women at all is insane. IMHO Syesha Mercado & Jasmine Trias belong on any decent list. BTW, Amy Jean Davis was the first woman voted off the semis in season 7. She sang a so-so version of "Where The Boys Are." If she dressed that night more like she did in Screerider's pics that were posted later, she probably would have lasted a lot longer.
Re Tatiana's hotness: I understand the reservations about certain aspects of her looks. What people are missing is the element of DANGER. A date would her would have about an equal chance of ending up being rolled in the alley with all money and credit cards gone OR being f*cked like there's no tomorrow. Or both!
|
|||
Hanson |
|||
|
Actually, Amy Davis is half Asian. But the other thing is most of these Idol hotties never make it past the semis. So they're basically in there for eye candy, and the producers pick white & latino girls for that.
As for Tati, I am in fact turned off by insane, with insane desperation being the worst combo of personality traits. Plus, she was not very fit when she was on the show. |
|||
bbagdan |
NAIMA | ||
|
Honestly, if Naima didn't have teeth like a jack o lantern she would be among the most elegantly beautiful girls ever on the show. World class model material. Damn those teeth!
|
|||
27ravens |
|||
|
Tatiana's sincere and fun-loving personality is what makes her hot <3
|
|||
Screerider |
|||
Hanson wrote:Most got eaten by time here: Amy JEAN Davis: AI7's obligatory fodder with tits Fortunately, it looks like Lazygirls has stored up a bunch of them: http://www.lazygirls.info/Amy_Davis
Last Edited By: Screerider
03/29/11 11:15 AM.
Edited 1 times.
|
|||
assface killah |
|||
|
Man... I posted in that thread and didn't even remember who Amy Davis was.
Yes she was hot... at first... but after awhile her face really started to bother me and wasn't attractive at all. Still a hot body though... she would possibly be last on my current list (would be higher if she had a prettier face!) FUCK forgot about Sarah Mather... but like Amy Davis... her face ruined what could have been an extremely hot girl (those TEETH!)
Last Edited By: assface killah
03/29/11 11:56 AM.
Edited 1 times.
|
|||