After 23 seasons, who are the people that you can call a Survivor Legend? in Lions, Tigers, Survivors

0 Points

After 23 seasons, who are the people that you can call a Survivor Legend?

Started By	Comment
Dr Will Hatch two point oh		#21	[-]
Posts: 10314 (01/20/10 11:00 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	The spontaneous rally will begin at 1:45. Remove this ad As in who the general public remembers? Rudy Richard Jerri Colby Rupert Jon MAYBE Ethan and Boston Rob. That's it.
melicatsmom		#22	[-]
Posts: 558 (01/20/10 02:51 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Hatch, Sue Hawk, Mike Skupin (first medevac), Jerri, Heidik, Boston Rob, Rupert, Fairplay, the entire Palau cast, Gary H (finding the first HII, lying about his identity), Yul, Ozzy, Penner, James the Gravedigger, Cirie, Parvati, Yau-Man, JT, Stephen (the greatest comback to win an immunity challenge ever), Evil Russell
aboutbreakingrules		#23	[-]
Posts: 1040 (01/20/10 06:48 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Borneo: Rich, Susan, Rudy, Colleen. Outback: Elisabeth, Colby, Amber, Tina. Africa: Lex, Big Tom, Ethan, Little Kim. Marquesas: Robfather, Vecepia, Tammy. Thailand: Brian!!! Amazon: Pass. Pearl Islands: Rupert, Sandra, Jonny Rotten. All-Stars: Jenna L ("this is our game now, get the hell off our playing field!"). Vanuatu: Chris, Eliza. Palau: Fireman Tom, Stephenie, and of course Jenn. Guatemala: Gary H, Danni. Panama EI: The top four (with the one Tribal Council where every one of them knew exactly what was going to happen). Cook Islands: Pass. Fiji: Yau-Man and Earl (I mean, to get all nine jury votes isn't legendary?). China: Pass, especially since two of their three HvV representatives are third-timers. Micronesia: Pass. Gabon: Pass. Tocantins: JT and Taj. Samoa: Natalie, Brett. [No, Russell, talking yourself up and smacking everyone else down while production is fawning over you does not make you a legend. ] Heroes vs. Villains: I think Sandra will come away as the ultimate legend.
LSiani		#24	[-]
Posts: 295 (01/20/10 06:59 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	spina wrote: cantthinkofaname wrote: Legends: Hatch, Sue, Colby, Lex, Ethan, Rob M, Heidik, Rob C., JFP, Rupert, Sandra, Chris, Stephenie, Tom W, Jenn, Cirie, Terry, Ozzy, Penner, Yau-Man, Earl, Parvati, Coach, Russell H, Minor legends Rudy, Greg, Elisabeth, Jerri, Big Tom, Kathy, Shii Ann, Eliza, Ami, Bobby Jon, Jamie, Danni, Shane, Peih Gee, Bob, Crystal, Sugar, Brett Fixed. Tell me how this unmemorable, annoying, idiot would be a legend in any way whatsoever?
DarrahColleenJerri		#25	[-]
Posts: 753 (01/20/10 08:08 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Here's what I would consider the "Big Twelve" of Survivors. These are the ones that are memorable not only in terms of what they did in the game but also as characters that would be bankable and CBS can use as people who generate press and exposure for the show. 1. Richard Hatch. Survivor: Borneo, All Stars. 2. Rupert Boneham. Survivor: Pearl Islands, All Stars, Heroes vs. Villains. 3. Colby Donaldson. Survivor: Outback, All Stars, Heroes vs. Villains. 4. Jerri Manthie. Survivor: Outback, All Stars, Heroes vs. Villains. 5. Rudy Boesch. Survivor: Borneo, All Stars. 6. Rob Mariano. Survivor: Marquesas, All Stars, Heroes vs. Villains. 7. Jon Dalton. Survivor: Pearl Islands, Fans vs. Favorites. 8. Sue Hawk. Survivor: Borneo, All Stars. 9. Stephenie La Grossa. Survivor: Palau, Guatemala, Heroes vs. Villains. 10. Russell Hantz. Survivor: Samoa, Heroes vs. Villains. 11. Tom Westman. Survivor: Palau, Heroes vs. Villains. 12. James Clement. Survivor: China, Fans vs. Favorites, Heroes vs. Villains.
DarrahColleenJerri		#26	[-]
Posts: 754 (01/20/10 08:14 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Honourable mentions to: Cirie Sugar Ozzy Yau Man Tina W. Brian H. Jenna M.
Greenkiwi		#27	[-]
Posts: 644 (01/20/10 08:28 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	SurvivorFanGP wrote: Jenn Lyon.
mc3		#28	[-]
Posts: 144 (01/20/10 08:55 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	top 2 russell hantz boston rob ozzie (doesn't really count but just for his physical challenge ability) cirie was quite good but not up there with the top 3 i liked richard hatch in s1 but he didnt do enough in ASS1 to impress me , same with ethan
KMKinCB		#29	[-]
Posts: 649 (01/20/10 09:49 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	SurvivorFanGP wrote: Jenn Lyon. THIS
ilovekelly752		#30	[-]
Posts: 1082 (01/20/10 09:51 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	The spontaneous rally will begin at 1:45. Remove this ad Richard Hatch Jerri Manthey Jon Dalton Rupert Boneham Jenn Lyon
KMKinCB		#31	[-]
Posts: 650 (01/20/10 09:56 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	ilovekelly752 wrote: Richard Hatch Jerri Manthey Jon Dalton Rupert Boneham Jenn Lyon Sue Hawk FIXED
ilovekelly752		#32	[-]
Posts: 1083 (01/20/10 10:04 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	KMKinCB wrote: ilovekelly752 wrote: Richard Hatch Jerri Manthey Jon Dalton Rupert Boneham Jenn Lyon Sue Hawk FIXED sure, why not, that speech is still remembered by casual fans
ElisabethNelehHeidiRok		#33	[-]
Posts: 1940 (01/20/10 10:27 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Richard Hatch Kelly Wiglesworth Rudy Boesch Sue Hawk Colleen Haskell Jenna Lewis Colby Donaldson Elisabeth Filarski Jerri Manthey Ethan Zohn Rob Mariano Jenna Morasca Heidi Strobel Rob Cestrinino Rupert Boneham Tom Westman Jenn Lyon Stephenie Lagrossa Cirie Fields Courtney Yates Parvati Shallow Russell Hantz
JLK Name		#34	[-]
Posts: 2949 (01/21/10 02:00 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	spina wrote: JLK Name wrote: spina wrote: cantthinkofaname wrote: Legends: Hatch, Sue, Colby, Lex, Ethan, Rob M, Heidik, Rob C., JFP, Rupert, Sandra, Chris, Stephenie, Tom W, Jenn, Cirie, Terry, Ozzy, Penner, Yau-Man, Earl, Parvati, Coach, Russell H, Minor legends Rudy, Greg, Elisabeth, Jerri, Big Tom, Kathy, Shii Ann, Eliza, Ami, Bobby Jon, Jamie, Gary H Danni, Shane, Peih Gee, Bob, Crystal, Sugar, Brett Fixed. Hahahahaha Jerri a minor legend.... you gotta be kidding em And Guys just because they won a season, doesn't mean they are legends Chris - Overcame a 6-1 deficit to win Heidik - Pulled off a near perfect game Sandra - I CAN GET LOUD TOO WHAT THE FUCK! will cement her status as a legend Tom W - Dominated Palau and mindfucked Ian into quitting Earl - Played a freakish game for a recruit who hadn't seen the show Jerri is a minor legend because she didn't get close either of her shots. Yeah but this not who are the best players and the most strategic players.... you are basing your opinions just because you like them Legends are popular.... and since when Chris and Earl became popular they are very underrated... Heidik is a very under-the-radar winner I don't think he had all the hype. Sandra was overshadowed by Rupert and Tom was overshadowed by Stephenie. Geekz wrote: Russell He reinvented the game nineteen seasons in. Hahaha more like reinvented the editing of Survivor = extremely craptacular DarrahColleenJerri wrote: Here's what I would consider the "Big Twelve" of Survivors. These are the ones that are memorable not only in terms of what they did in the game but also as characters that would be bankable and CBS can use as people who generate press and exposure for the show. Not sure about this 5 people Rudy and Sue are probably Honorable Mentions. Tom is a winner and a good player but a legend??? CBS gave Russell tons of screentime so I can see why he's popular, but a Legend??? And James...... please SkyDreamer wrote: The final 4 in Micronesia. Puhlease.... Amanda and Parvati will never be a Survivor Legend... those 2 aren't just popular with the casual viewers no matter how good looking they are and how strategic they are... aboutbreakingrules wrote: Borneo: Rich, Susan, Rudy, Colleen. Outback: Elisabeth, Colby, Amber, Tina. Africa: Lex, Big Tom, Ethan, Little Kim. Marquesas: Robfather, Vecepia, Tammy. Thailand: Brian!!! Amazon: Pass. Pearl Islands: Rupert, Sandra, Jonny Rotten. All-Stars: Jenna L ("this is our game now, get the hell off our playing field!"). Vanuatu: Chris, Eliza. Palau: Fireman Tom, Stephenie, and of course Jenn. Guatemala: Gary H, Danni. Panama EI: The top four (with the one Tribal Council where every one of them knew exactly what was going to happen). Cook Islands: Pass. Fiji: Yau-Man and Earl (I mean, to get all nine jury votes isn't legendary?). China: Pass, especially since two of their three HvV representatives are third-timers. Micronesia: Pass. Gabon: Pass. Tocantins: JT and Taj. Samoa: Natalie, Brett. [No, Russell, talking yourself up and smacking everyone else down while production is fawning over you does not make you a legend. ] Heroes vs. Villains: I think Sandra will come away as the ultimate legend. Hahaha this is more like a popularity list Last Edited By: JLK Name 01/21/10 02:11 AM. Edited 2 times.
prixlet		#35	[-]
Posts: 282 (01/21/10 04:22 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	with so many seasons its hard to pin down who is a legend and who is not because each season has its distinct set players, twists, tcs that can make the newest viewer be like, wow yeah ill def remember that. regardless i dont think anyone will ever forget the first winner richard hatch and how he won the game by being so ruthless. he opened the doors for many seasons to come and showed people how to play the game of survivor and many after that point modeled their strategies after him. the win still to this day was pretty iconic and legendary.
roxbury123		#36	[-]
Posts: 739 (01/21/10 01:39 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	I would hardly call anyone post maybe Season 12 "Legends" yet. But yea my list would include Borneo Final 4 [Rich, Rudy, Kelly, Sue] Colleen Colby Tina Jerri * I would say Lex but his terrible display in All Stars overshaddows how great he was in Africa. Colby/Tina stay on the list cause their original runs outshine the their terrible All Stars run. Kathy Rob C Johnny Fair Play Amber + Rob (Together) Tom Steph Cirie
astroline		#37	[-]
Posts: 3125 (01/21/10 01:48 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Richard, Sugar, Russell H., Coach, Stephenie, Rupert, Boston Rob, Jerri, Colby, Cirie. Those are probably the top 10 most memorable/recognized for casual Survivor fans, like it or not.
WylDawg		#38	[-]
Posts: 21930 (01/21/10 02:07 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	I actually thought of starting this thread a while ago. I'd say: Hatch Rudy Sue* Colby Jerri Lex Kathy Boston Rob Brian Rob C Rupert Sandra* Fairplay Ami Stepehenie Tom Cirie Ozzy YauMan Amanda* Parvati* Coach* Russell *Arguable for various reasons. Of course this is according to the general public. If it was according to Sucksters Crystal would have to be on top of the list. ETA: DJC's big 12 is pretty much dead on, but swap James for Cirie. Last Edited By: WylDawg 01/21/10 02:10 PM. Edited 1 times.
astroline		#39	[-]
Posts: 3126 (01/21/10 02:13 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	I am honestly shocked that Sugar is not on everyone's list. The entire season of Gabon was edited through her eyes, she had a huge edit for a female, a very memorable storyline, and was a casual fan favorite. I put her, Coach & Russell H. all in the exact same category. She was the star of her season without a doubt and a lot of you seem to omitting her just because you know that it was her goal, but it doesn't make her memorability/popularity with the general public any less. I'm not a big fan but she was a huge character.
WylDawg		#40	[-]
Posts: 21931 (01/21/10 02:22 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	The spontaneous rally will begin at 1:45. Remove this ad If it wasn't for everyone here bitching on a daily basis that Sugar ruined Gabon, I honestly would've found her forgettable by now.

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

After 23 seasons, who are the people that you can call a Survivor Legend?