Sucks' 40 Greatest Survivor Players - Winner Revealed On Page 14! in Clubs that Suck. No, Really. Forum

0 Points

Sucks' 40 Greatest Survivor Players - Winner Revealed On Page 14!

Started By	Comment
SurvivorSurvivorSurvivor		#201	[-]
Posts: 6499 (01/22/10 04:18 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Humpty-Dumpty was pushed! Remove this ad 20. Colby Donaldson, Australian Outback (Score: 419.6) #28 on previous list (up 8) 19. Twila Tanner, Vanuatu (Score: 421) #27 on previous list (up 8) #18. Sandra Diaz-Twine, Pearl Islands (Score: 427.8) #14 on previous list (down 4) - 2 votes for Best Player Ever 17. Kathy Vavrick-O'Brien, Marquesas (Score: 440.4) #20 on previous list (up 3) - 1 vote for Best Player Ever 16. Todd Herzog, China (Score: 468.3) #9 on previous list (down 7) - 3 votes for Best Player Ever
SleepTight		#202	[-]
Posts: 788 (01/22/10 04:42 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Good update. Kathy <3
solesurvivor01		#203	[-]
Posts: 6895 (01/22/10 07:05 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	IMO Todd is way too low and Colby is way too high.
JackSparrowBauer		#204	[-]
Posts: 4573 (01/22/10 10:37 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Colby and Twila are about at the right spot. but seriously wtf are Kathy and Sandra doing that high?
ilovekelly752		#205	[-]
Posts: 1091 (01/22/10 02:32 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Todd is way too low!
SurvivorSurvivorSurvivor		#206	[-]
Posts: 6500 (01/24/10 10:52 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	15. Chris Daugherty, Vanuatu (Score: 474.7) #21 on previous list (up 6) - 2 Votes For Best Player Ever #14. Ami Cusack, Vanuatu (Score: 479.2) #18 on previous list (up 4) 13. Stephen Fishbach, Tocantins (Score: 479.6) #12. Natalie White, Samoa (Score: 499.9) - 1 vote for Best Player Ever #11. Tina Wesson, Australian Outback (Score: 504.9) #13 on previous list (up 2) - 2 votes for Best Player Ever The Top 10 Borneo - 1 (Richard) Australian Outback - 0 Africa - 0 Marquesas - 0 Thailand - 1 (Brian) Amazon - 1 (Rob) Pearl Islands - 1 (Jon) All Stars - 1 (Rob) Vanuatu - 0) Palau - 1 (Tom) Guatemala - 1 (Rafe) Panama - 1 (Cirie) Cook Islands - 0 Fiji - 0 China - 0 Micronesia - 2 (Parvati/Cirie) Gabon - 0 Tocantins - 0 Samoa - 0 S1-S9: 5 S10-S19: 5 Males: 7 Females: 3 Winners: 4 Runner-Ups: 1 Third Place: 4 Lowest Placing Left On The List: Cirie (Panama) - 4th Place Winners: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Tina 6. Natalie 7. Chris 8. Todd 9. Sandra 10. JT 11. Danni 12. Earl 13. Vecepia 14. Amber 15. Jenna 16. Yul 17. Ethan 18. Aras 19. Bob Last Edited By: SurvivorSurvivorSurvivor 01/25/10 12:38 AM. Edited 1 times.
SleepTight		#207	[-]
Posts: 826 (01/24/10 12:48 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Epic lulz at Natalie ranking higher than: Chris, Todd, Sandra, JT, Danni, Earl, Vacepia, Yul , Aras, Bob Amber and Ethan played the same game, only they weren't as invisible. Jenna is worse, though.
tomash		#208	[-]
Posts: 2861 (01/24/10 12:55 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	SleepTight wrote: Amber and Ethan played the same game, only they weren't as invisible. You know there's a thing called editing, right?
ilovekelly752		#209	[-]
Posts: 1105 (01/24/10 01:14 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	So far, if you just had people vote for the best player, Todd's in the lead.
Katy Carney		#210	[-]
Posts: 10225 (01/24/10 01:25 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Humpty-Dumpty was pushed! Remove this ad lol at Ami being so high. I don't strongly disagree with anyone in the top ten (well maybe Rafe) but I am surprised that there are more men than women.
ilovekelly752		#211	[-]
Posts: 1106 (01/24/10 01:31 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Switch Jon and Rafe for Todd and Tina, and it's a great top ten. Ami is way too high, as are Jon and Rafe.
Axie.rsfd		#212	[-]
Posts: 1517 (01/24/10 02:00 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Natalie was overdue. And Rafe is even more so. Seriously, handing a million dollars check to Danni is not top 10 material.
tomash		#213	[-]
Posts: 2872 (01/24/10 02:17 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Yeah, Rafe is kinda overrated. I mean, he played well for the majority of the game, but his implosion during the end of the game =/= top 10 material.
JackSparrowBauer		#214	[-]
Posts: 4600 (01/24/10 09:52 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	wtf is Rafe doing in the top 10? Natalie, Tina and Stephen were all way too high.
craig		#215	[-]
Posts: 17042 (01/24/10 11:44 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	People are ridiculously inconsistent. Natalie beats Amber by miles. Rob M is Top 10 and Russell doesn't make the list. When situations are the same. Ami screwed up big at F7, Twila was Chris's goat, yet both are ahead of Jenna and many beater players. Colby is an IC whore who made a stupdid decision, makes Top 20, yet Ozzy is nowhere to be seen. Correction - it's 7 men and 2 women in Top 10 (Cirie x2).
JackSparrowBauer		#216	[-]
Posts: 4606 (01/24/10 11:56 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Jenna is not a better player by any means yw and Colby was so much more than just an immunity whore.
Thailandsurvivor		#217	[-]
Posts: 9661 (01/25/10 04:18 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	craig wrote: People are ridiculously inconsistent. Natalie beats Amber by miles. Rob M is Top 10 and Russell doesn't make the list. When situations are the same. Ami screwed up big at F7, Twila was Chris's goat, yet both are ahead of Jenna and many beater players. Colby is an IC whore who made a stupdid decision, makes Top 20, yet Ozzy is nowhere to be seen. Correction - it's 7 men and 2 women in Top 10 (Cirie x2). I am confused why Natalie is so far ahead, but you cannot come close to comparing Russell to Rob. Russell carried his tribe to a 8-4 minority. Without an idol, he leaves in 11th at best. They may have even taken him out at 12th due to his obvious scheming. Rob led Chapera to a majority lead, and no one even thought to threaten his power. Rob was never in danger of being voted out until the final 4. People on Foa Foa even targeted Russell. I will give him credit for taking those people out, but Rob never had anyone target him during the entire game. I don't know if he is top 10 worthy, but he should be way ahead of Russell. Chris should be way ahead of both Ami and Twila, but Jenna was not a great player. In fact, Jenna fucking sucked. Ozzy's strategy was gather food and win challenges. Colby was involved in both alliances on Ogakor, and he made the decision of whether Keith or Mitchell left. Then, he managed to get Kucha to vote for him at the merge. There is far more to his game, but they are not even comparable. One bad move at the end does not kill the rest of his great game. I'd probably put both him and Rafe in the top 10.
Thailandsurvivor		#218	[-]
Posts: 9662 (01/25/10 04:20 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	tomash wrote: SleepTight wrote: Amber and Ethan played the same game, only they weren't as invisible. You know there's a thing called editing, right? How does editing change the fact that they played the exact same game? Natalie could have been given the Russell edit, and we would have still watched her make the same strategic decisions of walking to the finals with a huge goat without having to make any huge decisions. She was like Earl, except Earl had a far better social game and never received any votes. ETA- Actually, I'd put Ethan far ahead of Natalie for never being anyone's target. People praise Natalie for her social game, yet she was still targeted at the final 10. Sure, Russell could have had the idol, so they couldn't vote for him, right? Well, why didn't they vote for Mick or Jaison? Last Edited By: Thailandsurvivor 01/25/10 04:23 PM. Edited 1 times.
FarnsworthFan		#219	[-]
Posts: 258 (01/25/10 04:26 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	o_O @ Chris and Sandra being on the list
Lexxan		#220	[-]
Posts: 1377 (01/25/10 04:32 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Humpty-Dumpty was pushed! Remove this ad Top ten anticipation 1) Hatch 2) Boston Rob 3) Tom 4) Panama Cirie 5) Heidik 6) Micro Parv 7) Cesternino 8) Micro Cirie 9) Fairplay 10) Rafe That is the only correct ranking.

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

Sucks' 40 Greatest Survivor Players - Winner Revealed On Page 14!