And how can they complain about Ping's signature piece when it was basically only slightly different from her week one garment that they put in the TOP group? Yes, that one also involved fabric draped over a model's arm...

| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
Drew B |
|||
|
I'm so perplexed by the judging on this show. I thought that the winning look - Mila and Jonathan's signature piece - was the WORST look of the night. Mila's jacket was okay, but Jonathan's blouse and pants were downright gross!
And how can they complain about Ping's signature piece when it was basically only slightly different from her week one garment that they put in the TOP group? Yes, that one also involved fabric draped over a model's arm... |
|||
nomii |
|||
|
they did the same to Santino and Rami - initially putting their designs in the top category, but eventually getting tired of it and putting it in the bottom
they simply should've kept Ping because its a fucking tv show. keep the fun character around! specially when she has a unique perspective |
|||
xesmeraude |
|||
|
Week 3
Jay Nicholas & Maya ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() Jesus & Amy ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() Anthony & Seth Aaron ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() Janeane & Ben ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() Mila & Jonathan ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() Ping & Jesse ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() Emilio & Anna ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
|||
Carboys Desire |
|||
|
I thought Jay's and Mya's signature dress was disgusting. I can't believe it was one of the judge's favourites. I liked Jesus' and Amy's much more.
|
|||
Jellybelly71 |
|||
|
oh thank you, baby jesus!! i could not take another week of Ping and her atrocious designs! i hate her.
|
|||
Us Kids Know |
|||
|
So you hate entertaining television and genuinely nice people?
Okay. |
|||
Drew B |
|||
|
A couple of additional thoughts...
How could any of the designers have been surprised when they were told they would have to do an additional look? The second I heard it was a team and they had two days, I knew it would be two looks. Does anybody else expect Heidi to slip and refer to Jesse as 'Logan'? |
|||
laniluvsit77 |
|||
|
I think Maya should have won. The dress was really pretty and well done and the bargain bin outfit was cute. I liked Mila's jacked but that's all I liked and the other dress looked like a feather was glued on last minute
I'll mourn the loss of god.dess Ping Pong. |
|||
Bite My Apple |
|||
|
I now have a seething hate for Jesse. What a whiney worthless little bitch. He could have put on his big boy panties and helped Ping instead of bucking her at every turn. He still would have been safe since Ping was team leader and it would have been her vision that got judged.
|
|||
supersync4d |
|||
|
Aaaaaannddd just like that, and by 'like that' I mean an unbelievably clusterfucky, season 6-esque, and just plain idiotic challenge, combined with the elimination of the only non-snore-inducing character left ...... we went from a potentially fun and exciting new season to the dump that was last season. All in one episode.
Last Edited By: supersync4d
01/29/10 06:55 AM.
Edited 2 times.
|
|||
Ouchie Poo |
|||
|
Well, I may be one of the only ones still watching for the designs. I'm not upset Ping is out. Yes she's a good person but that a good designer does not make. Pings wardrobe would be too difficult to live with considering I'd have to carry all of the fabric as well as my purse and other things.
I liked Mila's jacket but the rest of the outfit was blah. But it was well made. And I don't like how Maya's dress photographs but it moves really well. |
|||
morlock9 |
|||
|
Both that black flamer and Ping should have gone.
I had to go online this morning to find out who got booted. I played the "ping-pong" drinking game last night, and passed out ten minutes into the show. |
|||
lilbitofchaos |
|||
zippityboomboom wrote: http://popwatch.ew.com/20...el-franco-american-idol/ very odd.... |
|||
Kenscookie |
|||
|
-Oh, Ping. -Anthony, please pick up your game, sweetheart. I can't bear to lose you too. -Am I crazy for actually really liking Anthony and Seth Aaron's yellow, feathery inspiration dress? Does this mean I was a drag queen in a past life? -Jesus and Amy...what the hell were those elastic waist jodhpur/Hammer lovechild from hell pants? -I know these judges know infinitely more about fashion than I do, but can I just say that I HATED Mila and Jonathan's stripey leisure suit/track suit whatever thing. That shit was downright fugly and these judges are always talking about youthful and hip and blahblahblah...I cannot see anyone under the age of 65 wearing that thing. In fact, if you walk into any supermarket anywhere in the country, you can find several lovely senior ladies with their puffy hair, shopping for groceries in that exact same outfit in different color variations. |
|||
Gregoire |
|||
|
I'm sorry, Ping did not belong on this show, and we were grateful they could justify getting three weeks out of her. I suspect there will be other outrageous or interesting personality revealed in the coming weeks. So much time was spent on Ping's incompetance and quirks and there are many individuals we don't know anything about.
I'd like to join the chorus and say that Maya should have won. She had the most pressure -- being paired with somebody who didn't need to work that hard -- and she nailed it. That signature dress was a piece of art, and the "look for less" was great as well. Mila was just a funky coat. |
|||
Kenscookie |
|||
Ouchie Poo wrote:Sure, but given the chance she would have found a way to attach the purse, along with said random things, to the hem of the dress, so that it could ALL be draped over your arm, thus leaving your hands free. Come on, you KNOW she had it in her. |
|||
StatelyWayneManor |
|||
|
Ping Ponged.
I guess Jesse didn't "rein in the crazy" enough. |
|||
Nonentitled |
|||
|
Jay Nicholas and Maya's dress looked like it had some sort of mushroom growing out of the shoulder.
There. I said it. |
|||
tomash |
|||
|
Ugh, seriously the producer's need to remember that this is a TV SHOW. Getting rid of Ping this early was really retarded, they could easily have gotten rid of some bores instead.
|
|||
Ouchie Poo |
|||
Gregoire wrote:I agree. |
|||