Survivor -- Winners vs. Second Chance in Survivor: The Future Forum

0 Points

Survivor -- Winners vs. Second Chance

Started By	Comment
chapera rocks	Survivor -- Winners vs. Second Chance	Lead	[-]
Posts: 12789 (01/26/10 10:31 PM) Registered User More Recent Posts	The spontaneous rally will begin at 1:45. Remove this ad Hey, matty's thread got results, so maybe this will too. We all know that most of survivor's winners are boring or refuse to come back or have played three times already. We know an all second chance edition would be somewhat lame and a turn off for casual fans. Why not make a gimmick ... second chance, which will bring the personality and want to prove they can win the game, vs. winners who want to hold on to their title. Flame away. Or start the inevitable cast list discussion.
Mypoody2		#1	[-]
Posts: 10947 (01/26/10 10:41 PM) Registered User More Recent Posts	Well we know theyre dying to get Hatch back into the game. I think the only way to do a winners edition is with half winners and half something else... Unless they want to wait until Survivor 30.
ElisabethNelehHeidiRok		#2	[-]
Posts: 1969 (01/26/10 10:50 PM) Registered User More Recent Posts	If they could get Vecepia and Danni to do it again I think they could have a winners edition with 16 survivors. Richard Hatch Aras Bauskauskas Yul Kwon Earl Cole Jt Thomas Todd Herzong Chris Daughtry Tom Westman Tina Wesson Vecepia Towery Danni Boatwright Jenna Morasca Amber Brkich Sandra Diaz-Twine Parvati Shallow Natalie White I would love to see a winners eidition.
DaMan12		#3	[-]
Posts: 18 (01/27/10 03:48 PM) More Recent Posts	Me too, I would be completely content with no more all stars seasons until 29/30. Do season 29 as a regular all stars (no 3 peats) with no winners and season 30 as an all winners game to end the show for good. Make the tribes as big/small as you need to depending on how many want to participate. Offer the season 29 winner the chance to come back for 30 as well. Make the prize for season 30 like 3mil or something.
dropurbuffs		#4	[-]
Posts: 34 (01/27/10 07:02 PM) More Recent Posts	Could be very cool! I think with this kind of set-up though, the 'second chance' tribe would have to be players that actually had game and progressed deep into the game. Winners tribe: Richard Tina Tom (just because you know that they would) Todd Parvati (also inevitable) Natalie Danni Jenna Yul Earl Second chance tribe: Terry Ian Crystal PG Taj Kenny Natalie B. Heidi Stephen Mick
JerseyJerk		#5	[-]
Posts: 4610 (01/27/10 08:56 PM) Registered user More Recent Posts	why did this need a thread?
Michaelf7777777		#6	[-]
Posts: 33 (01/28/10 03:52 AM) More Recent Posts	Winners Richard Tom W JT Todd Chris Jenna M Natalie Amber Tina Sandra Second Chance Mike S Ace Brian (S11) Ben Cao Boi Tracey Marissa Trish Sydney Lindsey
JVJrule		#7	[-]
Posts: 3932 (01/28/10 09:09 AM) Registered user More Recent Posts	I'm all for it as long as Parvati/Amber/Natalie (my 3 favorites who've won the game) form a super alliance and make it all the way to the end with Lindsey/Shawna/Gabe with them in the 2nd Chance group.
matty p		#8	[-]
Posts: 400 (01/30/10 03:28 AM) More Recent Posts	ElisabethNelehHeidiRok wrote: If they could get Vecepia and Danni to do it again I think they could have a winners edition with 16 survivors. Richard Hatch Aras Bauskauskas Yul Kwon Earl Cole Jt Thomas Todd Herzong Chris Daughtry Tom Westman Tina Wesson Vecepia Towery Danni Boatwright Jenna Morasca Amber Brkich Sandra Diaz-Twine Parvati Shallow Natalie White I would love to see a winners eidition. Yeah, I reckon something like that would make a great cast for a winners edition in around season 24. It'd be great to see mastermind winners such as Richard, Todd, Yul (and maybe even Brian) pit themselves against each other. I think they've finally got enough interesting winners to do it in the next few seasons (season 24). I'd replace Earl with Brian (although I'm not sure the producers want him back) and Aras with Bob (as he was a fan favourite and offers something different): Males: Richard Hatch (Borneo) Brian Heidik (Thailand) Chris Daughtry (Vanuatu) Tom Westman (Palau) - Aras if Tom doesn't want to do it for a 3rd time Yul Kwon (Cook Islands) Todd Herzog (China) JT Thomas (Tocantins) Females: Tina Wesson (Australia) Vecepia Towery (Marquesas) Jenna Morasca (Amazon) Amber Brkich (All-Stars) Sandra Diaz-Twine (Pearl Islands) Danni Boatwright (Guatemala) Parvati Shallow (Micronesia) Natalie White (Samoa)
matty p		#9	[-]
Posts: 401 (01/30/10 03:30 AM) More Recent Posts	Sorry, forgot to add Bob to the males in my above post for a winners edition: Males: Richard Hatch (Borneo) Brian Heidik (Thailand) Chris Daughtry (Vanuatu) Tom Westman (Palau) - Aras if Tom doesn't want to do it for a 3rd time Yul Kwon (Cook Islands) Todd Herzog (China) Bob Crowley (Gabon) JT Thomas (Tocantins) Females: Tina Wesson (Australia) Vecepia Towery (Marquesas) Jenna Morasca (Amazon) Amber Brkich (All-Stars) Sandra Diaz-Twine (Pearl Islands) Danni Boatwright (Guatemala) Parvati Shallow (Micronesia) Natalie White (Samoa)
Paparazzi		#10	[-]
Posts: 99 (01/30/10 05:11 AM) More Recent Posts	The spontaneous rally will begin at 1:45. Remove this ad I don't really want any more gimicky A VS B stuff. All winners would be <3 though. Would they really bring back Parvati for a FOURTH time though? Would she even want to come back? I think they'd have to weight until they had more female winners.
logse34		#11	[-]
Posts: 38 (01/30/10 03:39 PM) Registered User More Recent Posts	Survivor: Greece - Champions MEN Rich Ethan Tom Yul Earl Todd Bob JT WOMEN Tina Vecepia Jenna Sandra Amber Danni Parvati Natalie Men vs. Women. If they're shooting seasons back-to-back in similar locations, do a Survivor: Athens with regular contestants and then Survivor: Greece - Champions right after.
JVJrule		#12	[-]
Posts: 3967 (01/30/10 06:29 PM) Registered user More Recent Posts	I mean half-winners would be pretty awesome too. It doesn't have to be an all-winners season because Ethan probably can't do it. Parv I doubt would do it a 4th time, Tom/Sandra I doubt would do it a 3rd time. Don't get me wrong, I'd LOVE to see an All-winners edition - to see Amber, Parvati, and Natalie (my 3 favorites who went on to win) on the same tribe would be awesome, but I just don't see it happening.
Ahora		#13	[-]
Posts: 876 (01/31/10 02:41 AM) More Recent Posts	I can see a winners vs runner-ups, but I don't see a full winners edition for a long, long time.
matty p		#14	[-]
Posts: 408 (01/31/10 04:15 AM) More Recent Posts	Ahora wrote: I can see a winners vs runner-ups, but I don't see a full winners edition for a long, long time. Now that they've got at least 8 male and 8 female winners, and a quite diverse range of characters who have won the game, I think an All Winners season may happen by season 24. They'd probably be hoping for a couple more female winners before season 24 to give them more to choose from though, but I think they'll have enough.
Turan		#15	[-]
Posts: 9 (01/31/10 02:49 PM) More Recent Posts	The problem with doing an "All Winners" edition, is that the gimic will lose a lot of weight if in the imminent or even subsequent allstar cycles, someone who has already won wins again IE Probst can't say "This season, on 'Survivor: People who don't need to play again', one of these X people will be the only person to ever win the most body-thrashing, brain-wracking game in the universe TWICE! Tune in to find out!"
Ichiro20		#16	[-]
Posts: 3075 (01/31/10 03:18 PM) Registered user More Recent Posts	Before survivor stops airing Hatch WILL come back and play again.
SomeGoodBubbles		#17	[-]
Posts: 21 (01/31/10 03:22 PM) More Recent Posts	Honestly I'm sure if they do a winner's edition it will only be for the final season of survivor. It would be pitched as deciding once and for all who is the best survivor player of all time and crowning the final Sole Survivor. They're gonna go out on a returning players season for sure and this would be the one thing I think they could or should do to wrap it all up. With the current given winners two have a classic 16 person game we just remove three men who I assume would be Ethan, Yul who is persuing his political career, and Brian cause he crossbowed a puppy. But of course all winners to come up until the end of the series will be more likely to be added to this list over some others cause the audience will recognize newer winners. Men: Richard Chris Tom Aras Earl Todd Bob JT Women: Natalie Tina Parvati Danni Amber Sandra Jenna Vecepia
Bowie.thehole		#18	[-]
Posts: 757 (01/31/10 06:30 PM) More Recent Posts	Ethan will be back along with Jenna.
matty p		#19	[-]
Posts: 409 (01/31/10 09:57 PM) More Recent Posts	SomeGoodBubbles wrote: Honestly I'm sure if they do a winner's edition it will only be for the final season of survivor. It would be pitched as deciding once and for all who is the best survivor player of all time and crowning the final Sole Survivor. They're gonna go out on a returning players season for sure and this would be the one thing I think they could or should do to wrap it all up. With the current given winners two have a classic 16 person game we just remove three men who I assume would be Ethan, Yul who is persuing his political career, and Brian cause he crossbowed a puppy. But of course all winners to come up until the end of the series will be more likely to be added to this list over some others cause the audience will recognize newer winners. Men: Richard Chris Tom Aras Earl Todd Bob JT Women: Natalie Tina Parvati Danni Amber Sandra Jenna Vecepia I used to think that they'd do an All-Winners edition in the last season ever, but the more I think about it, they're going to want to go out with an absolute bang in the last season, and to do that, they'll want to bring back all the big characters and fan favourites (Rupert, Hatch, Fairplay, Russell, Coach, Sugar, Stephenie, Cirie, James etc). Therefore, I have a feeling that the last season will be an Ultimate All-Stars season. They will have a Winners edition before this, and this will probably be in the next few seasons (hopefully season 24) as they look for new ideas and themes to use on 'returning players' seasons, since they will probably be having returning players once every two seasons now.
dropurbuffs		#20	[-]
Posts: 36 (01/31/10 10:16 PM) More Recent Posts	The spontaneous rally will begin at 1:45. Remove this ad This isn't necessarily the best thread to ask this in... but has Elisabeth from Australia said that she will not do another season of Survivor? Or is there still that slim chance that she might be back some day?

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

Survivor -- Winners vs. Second Chance

Survivor -- Winners vs. Second Chance