Article from Reality Blurred on back to back seasons in Survivor: The Future Forum

0 Points

Article from Reality Blurred on back to back seasons

Started By	Comment
JerseyJerk		#101	[-]
Posts: 4612 (01/27/10 11:35 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Semi finale: Ads vs. People Remove this ad well in the same sense that they wanted a theme out of HvV why not Brains vs. Brawn. 10 people who made it far because of their brains (masterminds) and 10 people who were seen as "challenge hogs" or people who NEEDED immunity to stay safe. S1 Kelly (Brawn) S2 Colby (Brawn) S3 Lex (Brians) S4 Kathy (Brawn) S5 Helen (Brains) S6 Rob C (Brains) S7 Rubert (Brawn) S8 - No one S9 Ami (Brawn) S10 Ian (Brawn) S11 Stephanie (Brawn) S12 Cirie (Brains) S13 Ozzy (Brawn) S14 Yauman (Brains) S15 P.G. (Brains) S16 S17 Sugar (Brains) S18 Taj (Brains) S19 Russell (Brains) S20 No One S21 Young Girl Brawn S22- Brains vs Brawn Something along these lines....not perfect yet.....
alnusrubra		#102	[-]
Posts: 254 (01/28/10 07:29 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Agreed with the Brains vs. Brawn thing. It seems like with a few exceptions, the male cast of HvV is kind of an alpha-male brawn niche. I can see them having a niche for a male cast made up of people like Yul, Rob C., Yau Man, Todd, Stephen, Penner, Hatch, and so forth.
JLK Name		#103	[-]
Posts: 3055 (01/29/10 03:52 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	JerseyJerk wrote: well in the same sense that they wanted a theme out of HvV why not Brains vs. Brawn. 10 people who made it far because of their brains (masterminds) and 10 people who were seen as "challenge hogs" or people who NEEDED immunity to stay safe. My goodness I was thinking about that too
Olmec Donald		#104	[-]
Posts: 1343 (01/31/10 07:22 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Torched93 wrote: I wanna see people with pre-existing relationships!!!!!! That's been done with Brett and Laura.
Professor Prude		#105	[-]
Posts: 317 (01/31/10 10:43 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Can you make it 3 tribes with the 3rd one being Beauty? Because that potential cast sure is ugly without it.
DaMan12		#106	[-]
Posts: 22 (01/31/10 01:27 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Imagine how epic it would be watching a tribe of 10 "brains" at the beginning of the game all clashing with each other trying to gain control.
SomeGoodBubbles		#107	[-]
Posts: 19 (01/31/10 02:37 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	can i please ask why Kathy from Marquesas is listed on the brawn tribe?????
SomeGoodBubbles		#108	[-]
Posts: 20 (01/31/10 02:50 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	chaos28 wrote: That'd be neat. Put them on opposite tribes. Don't make anyone too close though (you know a mother and son would probably never betray each other for example). Things like ex's, old classmates, old co-workers... it'd be neat to have Contestant A be someone who used to be Contestant B's boss, and maybe even fired them from their job. Something like that. I've thought about this alot and about how funny it would be when someone finally confides in someone on there tribe saying "hey... we've got an in on the other tribe. That guy was my room mate." and then the other person being like "woah woah.... i know someone on the other tribe too. Whats goin on here." It would be pretty classic. But casting would be a clusterfuck. How the hell would they choose a whole cast of people who know someone else on the other team without having the contestants know about it/how would you even follow through with casting? do they cast 8 people and then interview the hell out of em until they hear about someone in their life that is interesting and then track them down and recruit them for the show? It just seems way to complicated from a casting standpoint...
chaos28		#109	[-]
Posts: 3384 (01/31/10 06:08 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Can't be that complex if Big Brother can pull it off. It is a bit gimmicky though. I do like Brains vs. Brawn. And you could even do a Beauty tribe. 3 tribes of 6 hasn't been done since ASS. Or if they're that obsessed with 20 players, do 3 tribes of 7.
JerseyJerk		#110	[-]
Posts: 4620 (02/02/10 07:34 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Semi finale: Ads vs. People Remove this ad can i please ask why Kathy from Marquesas is listed on the brawn tribe????? She really could be on either but I just always remember her being a great athlete...she did win more individual challenges than anyone her season....idk... I think three tribes of 7 would be good or even 3 of 8. I know there is speculation that they are going to do a scenario where the fall season will be 'new' contestants and the spring season will be some type of 'all star' season but I don't see how that can do that EVERY spring without being seen as COMPLETE bullshit. Season 24 as a Brains vs Brawn would be cool IMHO....even if they added the third criteria mentioned of beauty. The problems with the 'beauty' aspect is that it wouldn't sound as smooth to be "Brains vs Beauty vs Brawn" and they would have to think of another name for it, either SURVIVOR: ALL STARS and have Brains, Beauty, and Brawn in place of Outwit ect OR put it under ALL STARS simply as "Brains, Beauty, and Brawn" like "Islands of Fire". The other problem is I only feel women have ever benefited from their looks (at least in enough of a pool so as to have choices from).
SomeGoodBubbles		#111	[-]
Posts: 30 (02/03/10 05:07 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	i feel that Brains v Brawn v Beauty would be a trite season. It just sounds so horribly superficial and uninteresting. I feel an Outwit vs Outplay vs Outlast season would be a neat idea. Outwit could easily fit the brains category. Outplay for the brawn since outplay is usually taken in the sense of who is best at challenges. and then outlast could include people who made it to the final tribal council being that they survived the vote and outlasted the other players. I think in this we find a great theme that relates to the main point of the show and could provide a really strong and diverse cast. A quick idea for the cast i threw together (excluding anyone who would be a fourpeat after HvV and attempting to use minimal 3peats) Outwit: Deena (Amazon)<possibly replace with Kathy V.O. if more 3peats is acceptable>, Natalie (Micronesia), Rob C. (Amazon), Scout (Vanuatu), Gregg (Palau), Gary (Guatemala), Peigh Gee (China) Outplay: Kelly (Borneo), Tammy (Marquesas), Boo (Fiji), Jaimie (Guatemala), Terry (Exile Island), Frosti (China), Laura (Samoa) Outlast: Hatch (Borneo), Neleh (Marquesas), Aras (Exile Island), Todd (China), Twila (Vanuatu), Jenna (Amazon), Katie (Palau) I think with the exception of Deena and Rob being on the same tribe it would work out to be a well divided cast with each person on each tribe representing a different season. Also possible mishap is Jenna and Hatch on the same time just like allstars. But hey... I'm down for that.
Polonium		#112	[-]
Posts: 319 (02/03/10 04:44 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	SomeGoodBubbles wrote: i feel that Brains v Brawn v Beauty would be a trite season. It just sounds so horribly superficial and uninteresting. I feel an Outwit vs Outplay vs Outlast season would be a neat idea. Outwit could easily fit the brains category. Outplay for the brawn since outplay is usually taken in the sense of who is best at challenges. and then outlast could include people who made it to the final tribal council being that they survived the vote and outlasted the other players. I think in this we find a great theme that relates to the main point of the show and could provide a really strong and diverse cast. A quick idea for the cast i threw together (excluding anyone who would be a fourpeat after HvV and attempting to use minimal 3peats) Outwit: Deena (Amazon)<possibly replace with Kathy V.O. if more 3peats is acceptable>, Natalie (Micronesia), Rob C. (Amazon), Scout (Vanuatu), Gregg (Palau), Gary (Guatemala), Peigh Gee (China) Outplay: Kelly (Borneo), Tammy (Marquesas), Boo (Fiji), Jaimie (Guatemala), Terry (Exile Island), Frosti (China), Laura (Samoa) Outlast: Hatch (Borneo), Neleh (Marquesas), Aras (Exile Island), Todd (China), Twila (Vanuatu), Jenna (Amazon), Katie (Palau) I think with the exception of Deena and Rob being on the same tribe it would work out to be a well divided cast with each person on each tribe representing a different season. Also possible mishap is Jenna and Hatch on the same time just like allstars. But hey... I'm down for that. If your idea is to work, it's going to need a better cast.
JerseyJerk		#113	[-]
Posts: 4621 (02/03/10 05:56 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	maybe Outwit, Outplay, Outlast could work as a way to have a tribe of winners without some crazzzzzy gimmick Outwit Tribe (people known for their cunning nature and/or great game play) Rob C., Yauman, Russell, Rafe Cirie, Sugar, Helen, Eliza Outplay Tribe (People great in challenges) Colby, Ozzy, Lex, Rupert Kelly W, Kathy, Ami, Stephanie Outlast Tribe (Winners) Rich, Brian, Todd, JT Tina, Jenna, Sandra, Natalie S1: Rich, Kelly W S2: Tina, Colby S3: Lex S4: Kathy S5: Brian, Helen S6: Jenna, Rob C. S7: Sandra, Rupert S9: Ami, Eliza S10: Stephanie S11: Rafe S12: Cirie S13: Ozzy S14: Yauman S15: Todd S17: Sugar S18: JT S19: Natalie, Russell At least one person from every season.....if this is used to S24 than they could use someone from S21, 22, and 23 and take out any one from the seasons with two reps. I just hate when an ASS type season does not have a rep from every season
Bowie.thehole		#114	[-]
Posts: 773 (02/03/10 07:15 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	That's the smartest idea that's been posted for a while, Jerk.
SomeGoodBubbles		#115	[-]
Posts: 34 (02/03/10 08:48 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	JerseyJerk wrote: maybe Outwit, Outplay, Outlast could work as a way to have a tribe of winners without some crazzzzzy gimmick Outwit Tribe (people known for their cunning nature and/or great game play) Rob C., Yauman, Russell, Rafe Cirie, Sugar, Helen, Eliza Outplay Tribe (People great in challenges) Colby, Ozzy, Lex, Rupert Kelly W, Kathy, Ami, Stephanie Outlast Tribe (Winners) Rich, Brian, Todd, JT Tina, Jenna, Sandra, Natalie S1: Rich, Kelly W S2: Tina, Colby S3: Lex S4: Kathy S5: Brian, Helen S6: Jenna, Rob C. S7: Sandra, Rupert S9: Ami, Eliza S10: Stephanie S11: Rafe S12: Cirie S13: Ozzy S14: Yauman S15: Todd S17: Sugar S18: JT S19: Natalie, Russell At least one person from every season.....if this is used to S24 than they could use someone from S21, 22, and 23 and take out any one from the seasons with two reps. I just hate when an ASS type season does not have a rep from every season The problem here really only is that 18 of the 24 would be playing for either there 3rd or 4th time. Not saying that this wouldnt invove some of the best characters and players but it would just be an ASS FvF and HvV mashup. I just do not want to see this really start to turn into a ridiculous real world road rules thing. There are so many survivors to choose from can we really not give some more another chance? Other players that did decently well on there season but werent stand out players that came back for an ASS style season emerged with a better look on how to play the game and did quite well strategically.
MrHillbilly		#116	[-]
Posts: 220 (02/03/10 09:14 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Why not just have one Survivor season per year (instead of two) with fresh faces and hopefully fresh ideas? I think having a gimmick season every year will be the doom of Survivor.
spragenspelt		#117	[-]
Posts: 4149 (02/03/10 11:35 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	We should consider another 50/50 season like Fans vs Favorites. How about a season where it is old Survivors plus a relative or close friend of theirs? Like if the "visit from home" challenge folks decided to stay. I think that could be entertaining especially if some of them turn on each other <3
Mypoody2		#118	[-]
Posts: 11000 (02/04/10 12:45 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	spragenspelt wrote: We should consider another 50/50 season like Fans vs Favorites. How about a season where it is old Survivors plus a relative or close friend of theirs? Like if the "visit from home" challenge folks decided to stay. I think that could be entertaining especially if some of them turn on each other <3 I thought the fact that they were having application contests online from fans was a bit fishy. Could be prepping for another Fans vs. Favorites season... but I doubt they'd jump into one so soon after an all-stars. They'll probably do another one in s24 after we've had some new people to add to the favorites category.
Bowie.thehole		#119	[-]
Posts: 776 (02/04/10 12:55 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Mypoody2 wrote: spragenspelt wrote: We should consider another 50/50 season like Fans vs Favorites. How about a season where it is old Survivors plus a relative or close friend of theirs? Like if the "visit from home" challenge folks decided to stay. I think that could be entertaining especially if some of them turn on each other <3 I thought the fact that they were having application contests online from fans was a bit fishy. Could be prepping for another Fans vs. Favorites season... but I doubt they'd jump into one so soon after an all-stars. They'll probably do another one in s24 after we've had some new people to add to the favorites category. The weakness of the prize (one person wins... an AUDITION? alol) suggests to me that this current competition is possibly merely a 'test' for doing the same type of thing a little down the road; testing how popular it is, how wise public voting is, etc... indeed the next step from this WOULD be a season of online-voted fans, whether a half-fans-half-favorites device again or a full season. Perhaps the producers will organize people into categories, similar to what has been mentioned here (brains/brawns/beauties/outwit/outplay/outlast/older men/older women/younger men/younger women, etc). Either way, I think we can all admit there's something "fishy" or "up" with the online application drive, especially in light of recent rumors involving Lynne Spellman and casting issues...
Michaelf7777777		#120	[-]
Posts: 82 (02/04/10 05:23 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Semi finale: Ads vs. People Remove this ad I also think that outwit vs outplay vs outlast would be a good concept. My tribes for this with no winners on the out play or outlast tribe would be Outwit Kenny (Gabon) Rafe (Guatemela) Rob M (Marquesas/ All Stars) Rob C (Amazon/ All Stars) Cirie (Exile Island/ Fans vs Favourites) Ami (Vanuatu/ Fans vs Favourites) Twila (Vanuatu) Outplay Colby (Australian Outback/ All Stars) Terry (Exile Island) Bob (Gabon) Amanda (China/ Fans vs Favourites) Kathy (Marquesas/ All Stars) Kelly (Borneo) Darrah (Pearl Islands) Outlast Richard (Borneo) Todd (China) JT (Tocantins) Tom W (Palau) Parvati (Cook Islands/ Fans vs Favourites) Tina (Australian Outback/ All Stars) Jenna (Amazon)

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

Article from Reality Blurred on back to back seasons