Jeff's New Season Ranking in Lions, Tigers, Survivors

0 Points

Jeff's New Season Ranking

Started By	Comment
WylDawg		#61	[-]
Posts: 22066 (02/06/10 04:35 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Humpty-Dumpty was pushed! Remove this ad As much as I despise Cook Islands, I get the logic of him ranking it so high. It has the most retreads after Australia, so it would kinda sound weird from a marketting perspective if Probst said it was a crappy seasson.
Mondogecko		#62	[-]
Posts: 243 (02/06/10 04:37 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	"Gina Crews made the necklace that he wore in Samoa" If Gina Crews had won Marquesas I bet he would have rated it the best Season ever no doubt!
roxbury123		#63	[-]
Posts: 767 (02/06/10 05:09 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Every time i read Jeff's ranking I always think "Does he not actually watch the show?". I feel his comments are always based on his feeling as he watches the show. To this day Marquesas is my favorite Seasons (aside from the Original) and it pains me to see how low he ranks it. Come on Lower than Fiji! Jeff Please! And Samoa and FVF in the top 3!!! Does Jeff not know when the Survivor Glory days were! Cause they are not going on now!
roxbury123		#64	[-]
Posts: 768 (02/06/10 05:11 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Jeff still seems bitter Gina left so early in Marquesas! Maybe that is why he hates the season so much. Jeff is so out of touch! And All Stars > Outback, Is he crazy?
Edinboro		#65	[-]
Posts: 5389 (02/06/10 05:15 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	I remember the days when Jeff ranked Australia at number 2. What happened? No surprise Thailand was ranked last. It's pretty obvious Jeff never liked Brian. Samoa at number 3 is just ....... And at least he's starting to appreciate Africa a little more. Got my EW in the mail this morning and was pleased to see this but overall disappointed with the results. Ok, i'm done.
SurvivorSurvivorSurvivor		#66	[-]
Posts: 6515 (02/06/10 05:20 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Jeff whines about Brian being sleazy and then sticks up for Russell. I also remember Jeff being shocked that the general audience loved Gabon and was kind of "so-so" in their reviews of Tocantins. He basically decided on the quality of both before even watching either season.
craig		#67	[-]
Posts: 17097 (02/06/10 05:22 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	3. Samoa ("Not the most exciting cast overall, but sometimes it only takes one, and Russell is in the Survivor hall of fame...") 11. Tocantins ("In a word, Coach.") 15. Vanuatu (The lack of huge characters and huge moments makes this one just another very good season of Survivor but nothing more") For Probst, one great MALE character can make or save a season. But if the guys suck, it usually ranks low. I'm the opposite - Eliza and Ami make S9, and seasons with no interesting women are lacking. However the Black Widows have captured his heart and respect in a way that is unique for women.
CSCin3D		#68	[-]
Posts: 13884 (02/06/10 05:31 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Oh, and WTF is up with him ranking CHINA above Outback?? Going on how he judges the other seasons ("modern Survivor" standards), China should be way down there too (predictable, very few blindsides, average cast). It seems like he just an automatic preference for the recent seasons.
Mondogecko		#69	[-]
Posts: 244 (02/06/10 05:43 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	The people on China were entertaining. However it was so obvious Todd would win he was just so superior to everyone else out there in strategy and gameplay.So as a fan that took all the suspense out of the Season for me.
survivorready		#70	[-]
Posts: 546 (02/06/10 06:12 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Humpty-Dumpty was pushed! Remove this ad Jeff is out of his mind! there is no way Samoa is the top 3!!!!! Shit head
SirCrocodilep		#71	[-]
Posts: 2443 (02/06/10 06:21 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Y2RAYproblem wrote: SmashItWithAHamma wrote: beatles20147 wrote: It's in the new EW issue. Here's the ranking, with select quotes. Don't turn this into a "Here's my ranking" thread; this is just for discussing how wrong Jeff is with 90% of it. 1. Borneo ("This spot will never be replaced [. . .] it will always hold a special place in my heart...") 2. Micronesia ("The Parvati-led women's alliance produced some of the most memorable moments in the history of the show...") 3. Samoa ("Not the most exciting cast overall, but sometimes it only takes one, and Russell is in the Survivor hall of fame...") 4. Palau 5. Pearl Islands ("This is a season I would recommend showing to someone you want to introduce to Survivor...") 6. China 7. All-Stars ("I still like this season for everything that drove me crazy about it six years ago...") 8. Outback 9. Cook Islands 10. Amazon 11. Tocantins ("In a word, Coach.") 12. Africa ("This season has stood the test of time better than I expected...") 13. Panama 14. Gabon 15. Vanuatu ("I always liked this season more than the audience did, and that has probably influenced why it has dropped since my last ranking [. . .] The lack of huge characters and huge moments makes this one just another very good season of Survivor but nothing more") 16. Guatemala 17. Fiji ("If it weren't for Yau-Man and Dreamz, this might have edged out Thailand as the worst season ever...") 18. Marquesas ("This was just a snoozer...") 19. Thailand ("I didn't like it then, I don't like it now, and you'll notice nobody from this season was invited back for Heroes vs. Villains") It's not nearly as in-depth as his post-Vanuatu ranking but there are some revelations; he wanted the Cook Islands racial divide to last longer; he finally acknowledges Chris's gameplay; and Gina Crews made the necklace that he wore in Samoa. That's about it. He's still pissed off about Lill outlasting Savage. Lol why the hell is he singling out Thailand when they couldn't even bother to get someone to represent the VERY FIRST SEASON of the friggen show? Other than that I didn't think this ranking was all that bad. The only two big abnormalities for me are Samoa and Marquesas. They tried. Hatch had legal issues, Sue is probably never coming back, Rudy's too old now, and I saw an interview with Kelly where she said she would do it, but that they didn't ask or couldn't find her or something since she's living in Mexico. As for the list, I definitely don't agree with the low ranking of Marquesas. It's top 10 for me. I also think Panama was a little low. they could have went for Dr. Sean instead
Dr Will Hatch two point oh		#72	[-]
Posts: 10420 (02/06/10 06:54 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	It seems like he just an automatic preference for the recent seasons. Probably because they're edited to his specifications.
chaddie		#73	[-]
Posts: 268 (02/06/10 07:35 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	craig wrote: 3. Samoa ("Not the most exciting cast overall, but sometimes it only takes one, and Russell is in the Survivor hall of fame...") 11. Tocantins ("In a word, Coach.") 15. Vanuatu (The lack of huge characters and huge moments makes this one just another very good season of Survivor but nothing more") For Probst, one great MALE character can make or save a season. But if the guys suck, it usually ranks low. I'm the opposite - Eliza and Ami make S9, and seasons with no interesting women are lacking. i agree. Samoa was lucky to have Laura otherwise it would have been even shitter than it already is D:
beatles20147		#74	[-]
Posts: 12643 (02/06/10 09:39 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	spragenspelt wrote: at the idea that ONE memorable character (due to shitty editors) is enough to make a season worthwhile The worst thing is that apparently Russell alone is enough to put Samoa at #3 (which is absolutely ridiculous, but I think will go down in the future--he used to consider CI a top 5 season right after it aired), and Coach alone brings Tocantins to #11...but in his Marquesas write-up, he mentions that they didn't come out empty-handed because Boston Rob is one of the all-time greatest. So how come the presence of Russell and Coach inflates the ranking of their seasons, yet Rob doesn't do anything to raise Marquesas? Granted, he didn't last as long as either of them, but it's completely contradictory. And on that note... Jeff whines about Brian being sleazy and then sticks up for Russell. I ranted about this a few months ago. Brian's just a victim of bad timing; he played that game before it was acceptable to be merciless. Had he appeared five years later, the show would be all over him.
chapera rocks		#75	[-]
Posts: 12897 (02/06/10 09:53 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Does anyone have the entire write-up or where to read it online? WTF at him thinking the only good thing to come out of Marquesas was BRob. It was one of the strongest casts, ever. Not a single dud, besides the General and maybe Vee, IMO. Not to mention all the gold merge gamers. John. Tammy. Sean. Paschal. Kathy. Neleh.
Mypoody2		#76	[-]
Posts: 11035 (02/06/10 09:53 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	God damn, the dude ranks seasons in an article and you jump down his throat. Wish I had that kind of power to write an opinion and everyone to be outraged over it... oh wait.
Paparazzi		#77	[-]
Posts: 121 (02/06/10 09:56 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	...Samoa the third best season ever? Just... What?
Thailandsurvivor		#78	[-]
Posts: 9813 (02/06/10 10:02 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	chapera rocks wrote: Does anyone have the entire write-up or where to read it online? WTF at him thinking the only good thing to come out of Marquesas was BRob. It was one of the strongest casts, ever. Not a single dud, besides the General and maybe Vee, IMO. Not to mention all the gold merge gamers. John. Tammy. Sean. Paschal. Kathy. Neleh. Zoe is the only one who could be considered a dud. The General is an American hero.
Mondogecko		#79	[-]
Posts: 246 (02/06/10 10:38 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts	chapera rocks wrote: Does anyone have the entire write-up or where to read it online? WTF at him thinking the only good thing to come out of Marquesas was BRob. It was one of the strongest casts, ever. Not a single dud, besides the General and maybe Vee, IMO. Not to mention all the gold merge gamers. John. Tammy. Sean. Paschal. Kathy. Neleh. Yea can anyone please put up a write-up?
ElisabethNelehHeidiRok		#80	[-]
Posts: 1991 (02/06/10 10:53 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Humpty-Dumpty was pushed! Remove this ad beatles20147 wrote: It's in the new EW issue. Here's the ranking, with select quotes. Don't turn this into a "Here's my ranking" thread; this is just for discussing how wrong Jeff is with 90% of it. 1. Borneo ("This spot will never be replaced [. . .] it will always hold a special place in my heart...") 2. Micronesia ("The Parvati-led women's alliance produced some of the most memorable moments in the history of the show...") 3. Samoa ("Not the most exciting cast overall, but sometimes it only takes one, and Russell is in the Survivor hall of fame...") 4. Palau 5. Pearl Islands ("This is a season I would recommend showing to someone you want to introduce to Survivor...") 6. China 7. All-Stars ("I still like this season for everything that drove me crazy about it six years ago...") 8. Outback 9. Cook Islands 10. Amazon 11. Tocantins ("In a word, Coach.") 12. Africa ("This season has stood the test of time better than I expected...") 13. Panama 14. Gabon 15. Vanuatu ("I always liked this season more than the audience did, and that has probably influenced why it has dropped since my last ranking [. . .] The lack of huge characters and huge moments makes this one just another very good season of Survivor but nothing more") 16. Guatemala 17. Fiji ("If it weren't for Yau-Man and Dreamz, this might have edged out Thailand as the worst season ever...") 18. Marquesas ("This was just a snoozer...") 19. Thailand ("I didn't like it then, I don't like it now, and you'll notice nobody from this season was invited back for Heroes vs. Villains") It's not nearly as in-depth as his post-Vanuatu ranking but there are some revelations; he wanted the Cook Islands racial divide to last longer; he finally acknowledges Chris's gameplay; and Gina Crews made the necklace that he wore in Samoa. That's about it. He's still pissed off about Lill outlasting Savage. I really dont get how Guatemala and Marquesas are soo freaking low!! And Amazon and Outback are the 2 best seasons of survivor in my opinion, its sickening that All-Stars is ranked above both. Samao is better than what everyone here thinks, its way better than the previous 2 seasons. How is Thailand and Marquesas below Fji? really thats nuts. China is too high as well.

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

Jeff's New Season Ranking